{ "schema_version": "1.0", "target_id": "e1", "language": "en", "nodes": [ { "id": "e1", "name": "Enron Corp. (historical issuer)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "subject", "claim_ids": [ "c-alliance-verdict", "c-andersen-no-retrial", "c-andersen-reversal", "c-asset-sales-pattern", "c-azurix-dismissal", "c-bacchus", "c-backbone", "c-bank-class-settlements", "c-bankruptcy-plan", "c-barge-acquittal", "c-barge-appeal", "c-board-response", "c-board-snapshot", "c-causey-sentence", "c-cerberus", "c-chase-prepays", "c-chase-settlement", "c-chewco-approval", "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-fees", "c-chewco-reserve", "c-chewco-tax", "c-cibc-settlement", "c-citi-estate-settlement", "c-citigroup-nahanni", "c-citigroup-prepays", "c-citigroup-settlement", "c-civil-class-reversal", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-clo", "c-committee-scope", "c-crosscountry-sale", "c-cuiaba", "c-director-settlement", "c-disclosed-business", "c-dynegy-resolution", "c-equity-trusts", "c-executive-roles", "c-fastow-sentence", "c-fishtail", "c-glisan-sentence", "c-hewitt-indemnity", "c-identity", "c-jedi-origin", "c-jedi-own-shares", "c-kopper-radr-civil", "c-kopper-sentence", "c-lay-vacatur", "c-leadership-transition", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-ljm-services", "c-megs", "c-merger-survivor", "c-merrill-sec", "c-milbank-goldman", "c-nikita", "c-nowa-sarzyna", "c-oversight-controls", "c-ownership-snapshot", "c-portland-scope", "c-prisma-aei", "c-raptor-dates", "c-raptor-end", "c-raptor-one", "c-raptor-priority", "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-three", "c-raptor-vehicles", "c-rhythms-purpose", "c-rhythms-review", "c-rhythms-unwind", "c-rice-hannon", "c-skilling-resentence", "c-skilling-supreme-court", "c-skilling-verdict", "c-slapshot", "c-southampton-returns", "c-spe-test", "c-staff-civil-settlements", "c-sundance", "c-swap-sub-structure", "c-tax-scope", "c-watkins-review", "c-whitewing-chain", "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "us" }, { "id": "e5", "name": "Andrew S. Fastow", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-asset-sales-pattern", "c-board-snapshot", "c-chewco-approval", "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-tax", "c-cuiaba", "c-executive-roles", "c-fastow-civil", "c-fastow-sentence", "c-kopper-radr-civil", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-ljm-control-limits", "c-ljm-services", "c-ljm1-chain", "c-ljm2-chain", "c-natwest-pleas", "c-oversight-controls", "c-raptor-end", "c-rhythms-unwind", "c-southampton-chain", "c-southampton-returns", "c-swap-sub-structure", "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e7", "name": "Kenneth L. Lay", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-chewco-approval", "c-executive-roles", "c-lay-vacatur", "c-leadership-transition", "c-watkins-review" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e8", "name": "Jeffrey K. Skilling", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-chewco-approval", "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-tax", "c-cuiaba", "c-executive-roles", "c-leadership-transition", "c-oversight-controls", "c-raptor-dates", "c-raptor-rescue", "c-skilling-resentence", "c-skilling-supreme-court", "c-skilling-verdict" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e13", "name": "Kenneth D. Rice", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-executive-roles", "c-rice-hannon" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e14", "name": "Richard B. Buy", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-oversight-controls", "c-raptor-dates" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e15", "name": "Richard A. Causey", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-causey-sentence", "c-executive-roles", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-ljm-services", "c-oversight-controls", "c-raptor-dates", "c-rhythms-unwind" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e16", "name": "James V. Derrick, Jr.", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-watkins-review" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e20", "name": "Robert A. Belfer", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement", "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e21", "name": "Norman P. Blake, Jr.", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e22", "name": "Ronnie C. Chan", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e23", "name": "John H. Duncan", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e24", "name": "Wendy L. Gramm", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e25", "name": "Ken L. Harrison", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e26", "name": "Robert K. Jaedicke", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-response", "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement", "c-oversight-controls" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e27", "name": "Charles A. LeMaistre", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e28", "name": "John Mendelsohn", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e29", "name": "Jerome J. Meyer", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e30", "name": "Paulo V. Ferraz Pereira", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e31", "name": "Frank Savage", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-alliance-verdict", "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e32", "name": "John A. Urquhart", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement", "c-disclosed-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e33", "name": "John Wakeham", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot", "c-director-settlement", "c-disclosed-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e34", "name": "Herbert S. Winokur, Jr.", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-response", "c-board-snapshot", "c-committee-scope", "c-director-settlement", "c-disclosed-business", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-natco-capricorn", "c-oversight-controls" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e35", "name": "Arthur Andersen LLP", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-andersen-no-retrial", "c-andersen-reversal", "c-board-response", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-jedi-own-shares", "c-oversight-controls", "c-raptor-end", "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-rhythms-review", "c-watkins-review" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e36", "name": "EOTT Energy Partners, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-nikita" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e37", "name": "Whitewing", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-clo", "c-nowa-sarzyna", "c-whitewing-chain", "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e38", "name": "The New Power Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-three" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e40", "name": "Michael J. Kopper", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-approval", "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-control", "c-chewco-fees", "c-chewco-tax", "c-kopper-radr-civil", "c-kopper-sentence", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-ljm-control-limits", "c-ljm-services", "c-ljm2-chain", "c-natwest-pleas", "c-raptor-end", "c-southampton-chain", "c-southampton-returns" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e41", "name": "LJM Cayman, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-asset-sales-pattern", "c-cuiaba", "c-fastow-sentence", "c-ljm-control-limits", "c-ljm1-chain", "c-rhythms-purpose", "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e42", "name": "LJM2 Co-Investment, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-asset-sales-pattern", "c-backbone", "c-clo", "c-fastow-sentence", "c-fishtail", "c-glisan-sentence", "c-ljm-capital-dispute", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-ljm-control-limits", "c-ljm-remand", "c-ljm-services", "c-ljm2-chain", "c-ljm2-investors", "c-megs", "c-nowa-sarzyna", "c-raptor-end", "c-raptor-one", "c-raptor-priority", "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-three", "c-raptor-vehicles", "c-whitewing-chain", "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e43", "name": "Credit Suisse First Boston", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-class-reversal", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-ljm1-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e46", "name": "U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-settlement", "c-citigroup-settlement", "c-fastow-civil", "c-kopper-radr-civil", "c-merrill-sec", "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e47", "name": "Chewco Investments, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-approval", "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-control", "c-chewco-fees", "c-chewco-reserve", "c-chewco-tax", "c-jedi-origin" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e48", "name": "Joint Energy Development Investments LP", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-fees", "c-chewco-reserve", "c-jedi-origin", "c-jedi-own-shares" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e49", "name": "Barclays Bank PLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-reserve" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e50", "name": "Chase Manhattan Bank", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays", "c-fishtail", "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e51", "name": "California Public Employees' Retirement System", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-jedi-origin" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e52", "name": "Talon LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-clo", "c-glisan-sentence", "c-raptor-dates", "c-raptor-one", "c-raptor-priority", "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e53", "name": "Southampton Place LP", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e54", "name": "LJM Swap Sub, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-rhythms-purpose", "c-rhythms-review", "c-rhythms-unwind", "c-southampton-chain", "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e58", "name": "Fastow Family Foundation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain", "c-southampton-returns" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e59", "name": "Janus Capital Corporation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e60", "name": "Lawrence Ruben", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e61", "name": "Jack Saltz", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e62", "name": "Enron Corp. Savings Plan", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e63", "name": "Lay/Wittenberg Travel Agency in the Park, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e64", "name": "Sharon Lay", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e65", "name": "Enron Supply Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e66", "name": "National Tank Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business", "c-natco-capricorn" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e67", "name": "Belco Oil & Gas Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e68", "name": "Enron North America Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bankruptcy-plan", "c-cerberus", "c-clo", "c-disclosed-business", "c-fishtail" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e69", "name": "Ben Glisan", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-cuiaba", "c-glisan-sentence", "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "c-southampton-chain", "c-southampton-returns" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e70", "name": "Kristina Mordaunt", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain", "c-southampton-returns" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e71", "name": "Kathy Lynn", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services", "c-southampton-chain", "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e72", "name": "Anne Yaeger", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services", "c-southampton-chain", "c-southampton-returns" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e74", "name": "William Powers, Jr.", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-committee-scope" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e75", "name": "Enron Nigeria Barge Ltd.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-merrill-sec" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e76", "name": "Osprey Trust", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-buyout", "c-whitewing-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e77", "name": "LJM Partners, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e78", "name": "ERNB Ltd.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e79", "name": "Campsie Ltd.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e80", "name": "LJM Partners, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e81", "name": "LJM2 Capital Management, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute", "c-ljm-remand", "c-ljm2-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e82", "name": "Merrill Lynch", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal", "c-barge-appeal", "c-civil-class-reversal", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-ljm2-investors", "c-merrill-sec" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e83", "name": "J.P. Morgan Chase & Co.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bank-class-settlements", "c-chase-prepays", "c-chase-settlement", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-ljm2-investors", "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e84", "name": "Citicorp", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e85", "name": "First Union", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e87", "name": "G.E. Capital", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e88", "name": "Dresdner Kleinwort Benson", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e89", "name": "LJM2 Capital Management, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e90", "name": "Big Doe LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain", "c-southampton-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e91", "name": "Big River Funding LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-control" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e92", "name": "Little River Funding LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-control" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e93", "name": "William D. Dodson", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-buyout", "c-chewco-capital", "c-chewco-control" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e94", "name": "SONR #1 L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control", "c-chewco-fees" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e95", "name": "Harrier I LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-one", "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e96", "name": "Timberwolf", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e97", "name": "Bobcat", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e98", "name": "Porcupine I LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-rescue", "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-three", "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e101", "name": "BSCS XXIII, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e102", "name": "Lord Securities Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e104", "name": "Partnership Services, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute", "c-ljm-remand" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e105", "name": "LJM2 Liquidation Statutory Trust B", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e113", "name": "Enron Dissolution Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-merger-survivor" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e115", "name": "Raymond S. Troubh", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-committee-scope" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e117", "name": "LJM Management L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e118", "name": "LJM SwapCo.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain", "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e119", "name": "Southampton, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-fastow-sentence", "c-natwest-pleas", "c-rhythms-unwind", "c-southampton-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e120", "name": "Michael Hinds", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e121", "name": "Peregrine I LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-whitewing-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e122", "name": "Hawaii 125-0", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-three" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e123", "name": "Grizzly I, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e124", "name": "Pronghorn I LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-three", "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e125", "name": "Roadrunner I LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e127", "name": "Blue Herron I LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-whitewing-chain" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e129", "name": "Portland General Electric Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bankruptcy-plan", "c-portland-scope" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e161", "name": "Alliance Capital Management L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-alliance-verdict" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e166", "name": "Capricorn Holdings, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e167", "name": "Capricorn Investors, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e168", "name": "Azurix Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-azurix-dismissal", "c-natco-capricorn" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e171", "name": "Vinson & Elkins L.L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-response", "c-chewco-tax", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-sundance", "c-watkins-review" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e172", "name": "Empresa Productora de Energia Ltda", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cuiaba", "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e173", "name": "Mahonia Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e174", "name": "Mahonia Natural Gas Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e175", "name": "Citigroup, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus", "c-bank-class-settlements", "c-citi-estate-settlement", "c-citigroup-nahanni", "c-citigroup-prepays", "c-citigroup-settlement", "c-civil-pleadings", "c-sundance" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e176", "name": "Delta Energy Corporation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-prepays" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e179", "name": "Northern Natural Gas Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-dynegy-resolution" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e180", "name": "Dynegy Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-dynegy-resolution" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e182", "name": "Marengo Assets, L.P.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-nahanni" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e183", "name": "Nahanni Investors L.L.C.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-nahanni" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e184", "name": "Caymus Trust", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus", "c-sundance" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e186", "name": "Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cibc-settlement", "c-civil-pleadings" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e193", "name": "Rebecca P. Mark", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e199", "name": "Kevin A. Howard", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-broadband-other-outcomes" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e202", "name": "Citrus Corp.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e204", "name": "Yosemite Securities Trust", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-prepays", "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e205", "name": "Enron Finance Partners, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e206", "name": "Enron Intermediate Holdings, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e207", "name": "Royal Bank of Canada", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e208", "name": "Coöperatieve Centrale Raiffeisen-Boerenleenbank B.A.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e209", "name": "Enron Asset Holdings, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e210", "name": "Heracles Trust", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e211", "name": "EOG Resources, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e212", "name": "Enron Broadband Services, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone", "c-bankruptcy-plan", "c-broadband-other-outcomes", "c-executive-roles", "c-rice-hannon" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e213", "name": "LJM2-Backbone II, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e216", "name": "Backbone Trust II", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e217", "name": "Fishtail LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus", "c-fishtail", "c-sundance" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e218", "name": "Annapurna LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e219", "name": "Long Lane Master Trust IV", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e220", "name": "Sundance Industrial Partners", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot", "c-sundance" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e221", "name": "Compagnie Papiers Stadacona", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e222", "name": "Flagstaff Capital Corporation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e223", "name": "PricewaterhouseCoopers", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-rhythms-review" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e224", "name": "Charls Walker", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-director-settlement" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e225", "name": "Daniel H. Bayly", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal", "c-barge-appeal", "c-brown-later", "c-merrill-sec" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e226", "name": "Robert S. Furst", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal", "c-barge-appeal", "c-brown-later", "c-merrill-sec" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e227", "name": "Schuyler M. Tilney", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-merrill-sec" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e228", "name": "Thomas W. Davis", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-merrill-sec" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e229", "name": "Stephen F. Cooper", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts", "c-leadership-transition" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e230", "name": "Prisma Energy International", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-prisma-aei" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e231", "name": "Lea Fastow", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-lea-misdemeanor" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e232", "name": "Barclays PLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-class-reversal", "c-civil-pleadings" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e233", "name": "Jeffrey McMahon", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-buyout", "c-leadership-transition", "c-megs", "c-staff-civil-settlements", "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e234", "name": "Hewitt Associates, L.L.C.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-hewitt-indemnity" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e237", "name": "Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy LLP", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-milbank-goldman" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e238", "name": "Goldman, Sachs & Co.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-milbank-goldman" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e239", "name": "The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-milbank-goldman" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e241", "name": "David Bermingham", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e242", "name": "Giles Robert Hugh Darby", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e243", "name": "Gary Steven Mulgrew", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e244", "name": "National Westminster Bank Plc", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain", "c-natwest-pleas" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e245", "name": "The Regents of the University of California", "type": "other", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bank-class-settlements", "c-cibc-settlement", "c-civil-class-reversal", "c-civil-pleadings" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e248", "name": "James A. Brown", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal", "c-barge-appeal", "c-brown-later" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e250", "name": "William R. Fuhs", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal", "c-barge-appeal", "c-brown-later" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e251", "name": "Daniel Boyle", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e252", "name": "Sheila Kahanek", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal", "c-brown-later" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e253", "name": "NATCO Group Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e257", "name": "CCE Holdings, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e258", "name": "CrossCountry Energy, LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e259", "name": "Stephen Forbes Cooper LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e263", "name": "David B. Duncan", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-andersen-no-retrial" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e264", "name": "Ashmore Energy International Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-prisma-aei" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e265", "name": "Kirkland & Ellis", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-pleadings" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e267", "name": "Deloitte & Touche LLP", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-committee-scope" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e268", "name": "Deutsche Bank AG", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-pleadings", "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e269", "name": "Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-pleadings" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e270", "name": "Bank of America Corporation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-pleadings" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e278", "name": "Ashmore Investment Management Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-prisma-aei" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e313", "name": "Kevin Hannon", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-rice-hannon" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e326", "name": "Edward N. Meyer", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4001", "name": "Michael Krautz", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-broadband-other-outcomes" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4002", "name": "Scott Yeager", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-broadband-other-outcomes" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4003", "name": "American Home Assurance Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4004", "name": "Arkansas Teachers Retirement System", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4005", "name": "MacArthur Foundation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4006", "name": "Rhythms NetConnections, Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-rhythms-purpose", "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4007", "name": "Royal Bank of Scotland", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas", "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4008", "name": "Nowa Sarzyna power project holding company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-nowa-sarzyna" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4009", "name": "MEGS LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-megs" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4010", "name": "Condor Trust (Whitewing subsidiary described in Powers report)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4011", "name": "LJM2-Ampato LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4012", "name": "BV-1 (Sundance Dutch holding vehicle)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4013", "name": "BV-2 (Sundance Dutch holding vehicle)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4014", "name": "Hansen (Canadian Slapshot vehicle)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4015", "name": "Newman (Canadian Slapshot vehicle)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4016", "name": "Industrial Bank of Japan", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4017", "name": "Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4018", "name": "LJM2-Backbone LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4019", "name": "Backbone Trust I", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4020", "name": "Qwest Communications Corporation", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4021", "name": "ABN AMRO", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4022", "name": "Fleet National Bank", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4023", "name": "Aeneas LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4024", "name": "Psyche LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4025", "name": "Sherron Watkins", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-watkins-review" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4026", "name": "Enron Common Equity Trust", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4027", "name": "Enron Preferred Equity Trust", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4028", "name": "Southern Union Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4029", "name": "Transwestern Pipeline Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4030", "name": "Northern Plains Natural Gas Company", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4031", "name": "GE Commercial Finance Energy Financial Services", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4032", "name": "Jerry K. Castleman", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e4033", "name": "RADR (SPE named in Lea Fastow plea)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-lea-misdemeanor" ], "badges": [] } ], "edges": [ { "id": "r-1", "from": "e7", "to": "e1", "role": "Chairman; former chief executive", "period": "Early 2001 filing", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-executive-roles" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-2", "from": "e8", "to": "e1", "role": "President and chief executive", "period": "Early 2001 filing", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-executive-roles" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-3", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Chief financial officer", "period": "Early 2001 filing", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-executive-roles" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-4", "from": "e15", "to": "e1", "role": "Chief accounting officer", "period": "Early 2001 filing", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-executive-roles" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-5", "from": "e13", "to": "e212", "role": "Chairman and chief executive", "period": "Early 2001 filing", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-executive-roles" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-6", "from": "e8", "to": "e1", "role": "Former executive; criminal convictions and 2013 resentencing", "period": "Historical Enron proceedings", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-skilling-resentence" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-7", "from": "e7", "to": "e1", "role": "Former executive; convictions vacated after death", "period": "Historical Enron proceedings", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-lay-vacatur" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-8", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Former CFO; guilty plea and six-year sentence", "period": "Historical Enron proceedings", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fastow-sentence" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-9", "from": "e40", "to": "e1", "role": "Former finance executive; guilty plea and 37-month sentence", "period": "Historical Enron proceedings", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-kopper-sentence" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-10", "from": "e69", "to": "e1", "role": "Former treasurer; guilty plea and 60-month sentence", "period": "Historical Enron proceedings", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-glisan-sentence" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-11", "from": "e15", "to": "e1", "role": "Former accounting chief; securities-fraud plea and sentence", "period": "Historical Enron proceedings", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-causey-sentence" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-12", "from": "e5", "to": "e46", "role": "Civil settlement; permanent officer-and-director bar", "period": "January 2004", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fastow-civil" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-13", "from": "e231", "to": "e4033", "role": "Tax plea concerned undisclosed RADR-derived income", "period": "May 2004 outcome", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-lea-misdemeanor" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-14", "from": "e13", "to": "e212", "role": "Former CEO; securities-fraud conviction", "period": "2007 sentences", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-rice-hannon" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-15", "from": "e313", "to": "e212", "role": "Former COO; conspiracy conviction", "period": "2007 sentences", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-rice-hannon" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-16", "from": "e199", "to": "e212", "role": "Former finance chief; reported plea and probation", "period": "November 2011 retrospective", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-broadband-other-outcomes" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-17", "from": "e4001", "to": "e212", "role": "Former accountant; reported acquittal", "period": "November 2011 retrospective", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-broadband-other-outcomes" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-18", "from": "e4002", "to": "e212", "role": "Former strategic-business executive; reported dismissal", "period": "November 2011 retrospective", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-broadband-other-outcomes" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-19", "from": "e35", "to": "e1", "role": "Auditor; obstruction conviction reversed, no retrial reported", "period": "2005 outcomes", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-andersen-reversal", "c-andersen-no-retrial" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-20", "from": "e263", "to": "e35", "role": "Audit partner; guilty plea withdrawn after reversal", "period": "December 2005 outcome", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-andersen-no-retrial" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-21", "from": "e248", "to": "e82", "role": "Barge defendant; fraud counts reversed, perjury and obstruction affirmed", "period": "August 2006 appeal", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-appeal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-22", "from": "e250", "to": "e82", "role": "Barge defendant; insufficient evidence on appeal", "period": "August 2006 appeal", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-appeal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-23", "from": "e225", "to": "e82", "role": "Barge defendant; conspiracy and wire-fraud convictions reversed", "period": "August 2006 appeal", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-appeal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-24", "from": "e226", "to": "e82", "role": "Barge defendant; conspiracy and wire-fraud convictions reversed", "period": "August 2006 appeal", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-appeal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-25", "from": "e252", "to": "e1", "role": "Barge-trial defendant; acquitted of all charges", "period": "2004 trial recorded in 2006 appeal", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-26", "from": "e251", "to": "e1", "role": "Barge-trial defendant; convicted, not appellant in this opinion", "period": "2004 trial recorded in 2006 appeal", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-barge-acquittal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-27", "from": "e1", "to": "e48", "role": "General partner; original stock contribution", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-jedi-origin" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-28", "from": "e51", "to": "e48", "role": "Original limited partner; interest redeemed in 1997", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-jedi-origin" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-29", "from": "e47", "to": "e48", "role": "Replacement limited partner from 1997", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-jedi-origin" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-30", "from": "e94", "to": "e47", "role": "General partner", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-31", "from": "e91", "to": "e47", "role": "Limited partner", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-32", "from": "e92", "to": "e91", "role": "Sole member", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-33", "from": "e93", "to": "e92", "role": "Ownership transferred from Kopper in December 1997", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-34", "from": "e40", "to": "e94", "role": "More than 95% limited interest; manager of GP structure", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-35", "from": "e93", "to": "e94", "role": "Remaining limited-partner interest", "period": "Historical 1993–2001 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-control" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-36", "from": "e49", "to": "e47", "role": "$240 million subordinated lender", "period": "December 1997", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-37", "from": "e1", "to": "e47", "role": "Guarantor of Barclays loan", "period": "December 1997", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-38", "from": "e48", "to": "e47", "role": "$132 million revolving advance", "period": "December 1997", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-39", "from": "e49", "to": "e91", "role": "Lender supporting apparent outside equity", "period": "December 1997", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-40", "from": "e49", "to": "e92", "role": "Lender supporting apparent outside equity", "period": "December 1997", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-capital" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-41", "from": "e48", "to": "e49", "role": "Source of cash pledged in reserve accounts", "period": "December 1997", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-reserve" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-42", "from": "e47", "to": "e94", "role": "Management-fee payer; funding questioned by committee", "period": "1997–2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-fees" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-43", "from": "e1", "to": "e47", "role": "Repurchased JEDI interest; gross and net amounts distinguished", "period": "March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-buyout" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-44", "from": "e47", "to": "e76", "role": "Held certificates linked to remaining $15 million loan", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chewco-buyout" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-45", "from": "e5", "to": "e80", "role": "Sole and managing member", "period": "1999 LJM1 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-46", "from": "e80", "to": "e77", "role": "General partner", "period": "1999 LJM1 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-47", "from": "e5", "to": "e77", "role": "Limited partner", "period": "1999 LJM1 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-48", "from": "e77", "to": "e41", "role": "General partner", "period": "1999 LJM1 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-49", "from": "e78", "to": "e41", "role": "Limited partner; $7.5 million contribution", "period": "1999 LJM1 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-50", "from": "e79", "to": "e41", "role": "Limited partner; $7.5 million contribution", "period": "1999 LJM1 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-51", "from": "e43", "to": "e78", "role": "Bank affiliated with named investor vehicle", "period": "1999 reported structure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-52", "from": "e244", "to": "e79", "role": "Bank affiliated with named investor vehicle", "period": "1999 reported structure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm1-chain" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-53", "from": "e81", "to": "e42", "role": "General partner", "period": "1999–2001 LJM2 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-54", "from": "e89", "to": "e81", "role": "General partner", "period": "1999–2001 LJM2 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-55", "from": "e5", "to": "e89", "role": "Managing member", "period": "1999–2001 LJM2 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-56", "from": "e5", "to": "e81", "role": "Limited partner", "period": "1999–2001 LJM2 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-57", "from": "e90", "to": "e81", "role": "Limited partner", "period": "1999–2001 LJM2 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-58", "from": "e40", "to": "e90", "role": "Managing member", "period": "1999–2001 LJM2 structure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-59", "from": "e4003", "to": "e42", "role": "Reported limited partner; complete roster unavailable", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-60", "from": "e4004", "to": "e42", "role": "Reported limited partner; complete roster unavailable", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-61", "from": "e4005", "to": "e42", "role": "Reported limited partner; complete roster unavailable", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-62", "from": "e82", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-63", "from": "e83", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-64", "from": "e84", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-65", "from": "e85", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-66", "from": "e268", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-67", "from": "e87", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-68", "from": "e88", "to": "e42", "role": "Affiliated entity reported as investor; direct vehicle unspecified", "period": "LJM2 fundraising", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm2-investors" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-69", "from": "e1", "to": "e117", "role": "Staff and administrative-services agreement", "period": "April and July 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-70", "from": "e40", "to": "e42", "role": "Staff working for LJM under shared-services arrangements", "period": "2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-71", "from": "e71", "to": "e42", "role": "Staff working for LJM under shared-services arrangements", "period": "2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-72", "from": "e72", "to": "e42", "role": "Staff working for LJM under shared-services arrangements", "period": "2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-services" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-73", "from": "e40", "to": "e42", "role": "Acquired Fastow’s LJM2 interest through the general-partner structure; exact transferred legal title not established", "period": "July 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-control-limits" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-74", "from": "e1", "to": "e4006", "role": "Merchant equity investment; lock-up then attempted hedge", "period": "1998–2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-rhythms-purpose" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-75", "from": "e118", "to": "e54", "role": "General partner", "period": "June 1999", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-76", "from": "e41", "to": "e54", "role": "Initial limited partner", "period": "June 1999", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-77", "from": "e5", "to": "e118", "role": "Sole director", "period": "June 1999", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-78", "from": "e54", "to": "e1", "role": "Rhythms put counterparty, backed largely by Enron shares", "period": "1999–2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-rhythms-purpose", "c-swap-sub-structure" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-79", "from": "e223", "to": "e1", "role": "Initial Rhythms exchange valuation fairness opinion", "period": "1999", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-rhythms-review" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-80", "from": "e90", "to": "e53", "role": "General partner", "period": "March–April 2000 documentation", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-81", "from": "e53", "to": "e119", "role": "General partner", "period": "March–April 2000 documentation", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-82", "from": "e119", "to": "e54", "role": "Owner of all limited interests in unwind documentation", "period": "March–April 2000 documentation", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-83", "from": "e119", "to": "e118", "role": "Owner of Swap Sub general partner", "period": "March–April 2000 documentation", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-84", "from": "e58", "to": "e53", "role": "Limited partner in employee investment vehicle", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-85", "from": "e69", "to": "e53", "role": "Limited partner in employee investment vehicle", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-86", "from": "e70", "to": "e53", "role": "Limited partner in employee investment vehicle", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-87", "from": "e71", "to": "e53", "role": "Limited partner in employee investment vehicle", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-88", "from": "e72", "to": "e53", "role": "Limited partner in employee investment vehicle", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-89", "from": "e120", "to": "e53", "role": "Limited partner in employee investment vehicle", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-90", "from": "e5", "to": "e58", "role": "Director signing partnership investment", "period": "March 2000", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-southampton-chain" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-91", "from": "e241", "to": "e244", "role": "Former employee; guilty plea concerned fraud on employer", "period": "November 2007 plea", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-92", "from": "e241", "to": "e119", "role": "Admitted concealed investment", "period": "2000 transaction; 2007 plea", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-93", "from": "e242", "to": "e244", "role": "Former employee; guilty plea concerned fraud on employer", "period": "November 2007 plea", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-94", "from": "e242", "to": "e119", "role": "Admitted concealed investment", "period": "2000 transaction; 2007 plea", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-95", "from": "e243", "to": "e244", "role": "Former employee; guilty plea concerned fraud on employer", "period": "November 2007 plea", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-96", "from": "e243", "to": "e119", "role": "Admitted concealed investment", "period": "2000 transaction; 2007 plea", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-97", "from": "e4007", "to": "e244", "role": "Successor bank named as restitution recipient", "period": "2007 plea agreement", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natwest-pleas" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-98", "from": "e1", "to": "e95", "role": "Enron Raptor participation vehicle", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-99", "from": "e95", "to": "e52", "role": "Member vehicle above Talon / Raptor I", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-100", "from": "e1", "to": "e123", "role": "Enron Raptor participation vehicle", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-101", "from": "e123", "to": "e96", "role": "Parent vehicle listed above Timberwolf / Raptor II", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-102", "from": "e1", "to": "e124", "role": "Enron Raptor participation vehicle", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-103", "from": "e124", "to": "e98", "role": "Member vehicle above Porcupine / Raptor III", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-104", "from": "e1", "to": "e125", "role": "Enron Raptor participation vehicle", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-105", "from": "e125", "to": "e97", "role": "Parent vehicle listed above Bobcat / Raptor IV", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-106", "from": "e42", "to": "e52", "role": "Outside investor and manager in Raptor structure", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-one" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-107", "from": "e1", "to": "e52", "role": "Derivative counterparty / provider of capital and credit capacity", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-rescue" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-108", "from": "e42", "to": "e96", "role": "Outside investor and manager in Raptor structure", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-109", "from": "e1", "to": "e96", "role": "Derivative counterparty / provider of capital and credit capacity", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-rescue" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-110", "from": "e42", "to": "e97", "role": "Outside investor and manager in Raptor structure", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-vehicles" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-111", "from": "e1", "to": "e97", "role": "Derivative counterparty / provider of capital and credit capacity", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-rescue" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-112", "from": "e42", "to": "e98", "role": "Outside investor and manager in Raptor structure", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-three" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-113", "from": "e1", "to": "e98", "role": "Derivative counterparty / provider of capital and credit capacity", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-risk", "c-raptor-rescue" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-114", "from": "e1", "to": "e38", "role": "Investor whose New Power position was placed in the Raptor III hedge", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-three" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-115", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Negotiated Raptor termination for Enron", "period": "September 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-end" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-116", "from": "e40", "to": "e42", "role": "Negotiated Raptor termination for LJM2", "period": "September 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-end" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-117", "from": "e35", "to": "e1", "role": "Advised on Raptor accounting, criticised by the internal inquiry", "period": "2000–2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-raptor-end" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-118", "from": "e41", "to": "e172", "role": "Acquired 13% project stake, later sold back", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cuiaba" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-119", "from": "e1", "to": "e172", "role": "Project investor and repurchaser of LJM1 interest", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cuiaba" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-120", "from": "e68", "to": "e42", "role": "Loan-pool securities sold to LJM2", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-clo" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-121", "from": "e37", "to": "e42", "role": "Whitewing-group affiliate made loan; exact lender unidentified and use of proceeds unconfirmed", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-clo" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-122", "from": "e1", "to": "e42", "role": "Repurchased CLO notes and equity after deterioration", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-clo" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-123", "from": "e42", "to": "e4008", "role": "75% temporary interest in project holding company", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-nowa-sarzyna" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-124", "from": "e37", "to": "e4008", "role": "Participated in repurchase from LJM2", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-nowa-sarzyna" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-125", "from": "e42", "to": "e4009", "role": "90% temporary equity interest and debt investment", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-megs" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-126", "from": "e1", "to": "e4009", "role": "Seller and subsequent repurchaser", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-megs" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-127", "from": "e37", "to": "e4010", "role": "Condor Trust subsidiary as described in Powers report; historical identity qualified", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-128", "from": "e42", "to": "e204", "role": "Temporary certificate holder, not a statement of entire trust ownership", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-129", "from": "e4010", "to": "e42", "role": "Funded and acquired intermediated certificate purchase", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-yosemite-intermediary" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-130", "from": "e175", "to": "e176", "role": "Sponsored and funded prepay intermediary", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-131", "from": "e176", "to": "e1", "role": "Intermediary in circular prepay contracts", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-132", "from": "e175", "to": "e204", "role": "Arranged financing through Yosemite trusts", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-133", "from": "e1", "to": "e182", "role": "General partner; consolidated entity", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-nahanni" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-134", "from": "e183", "to": "e182", "role": "Limited partner; Treasury-bill contribution", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-nahanni" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-135", "from": "e175", "to": "e183", "role": "Arranged financing and third-party participation", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-nahanni" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-136", "from": "e175", "to": "e184", "role": "Lender and bearer of apparent equity risk", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-137", "from": "e219", "to": "e184", "role": "Formal equity contributor through FleetBoston structure", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-138", "from": "e184", "to": "e217", "role": "Acquired class interest in Fishtail structure", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-139", "from": "e1", "to": "e175", "role": "Oral protection against equity loss described by SEC", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-bacchus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-140", "from": "e83", "to": "e173", "role": "Controlled prepay intermediary according to SEC complaint", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-141", "from": "e83", "to": "e174", "role": "Controlled prepay intermediary according to SEC complaint", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-142", "from": "e173", "to": "e1", "role": "Prepay counterparty", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-143", "from": "e174", "to": "e1", "role": "Prepay counterparty in one transaction", "period": "1997–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-prepays" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-144", "from": "e46", "to": "e83", "role": "SEC action settled without admission or denial", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-chase-settlement" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-145", "from": "e46", "to": "e175", "role": "Settled administrative order without admission or denial", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citigroup-settlement" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-146", "from": "e68", "to": "e217", "role": "50% voting interest", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-147", "from": "e218", "to": "e217", "role": "50% voting interest", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-148", "from": "e42", "to": "e4011", "role": "Participating affiliate", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-149", "from": "e4011", "to": "e218", "role": "LJM2 participation vehicle", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-150", "from": "e50", "to": "e218", "role": "$42 million unfunded commitment", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-fishtail" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-151", "from": "e1", "to": "e220", "role": "Joint-venture participant", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-sundance" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-152", "from": "e175", "to": "e220", "role": "Protected joint-venture participant; exited before bankruptcy", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-sundance" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-153", "from": "e171", "to": "e220", "role": "Legal adviser providing contested true-sale opinion", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-sundance" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-154", "from": "e220", "to": "e4012", "role": "Dutch holding-company tier", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-155", "from": "e4012", "to": "e4013", "role": "Dutch holding-company tier", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-156", "from": "e4013", "to": "e221", "role": "Direct owner of Canadian paper business", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-157", "from": "e221", "to": "e4014", "role": "Wholly owned Canadian vehicle", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-158", "from": "e221", "to": "e4015", "role": "Wholly owned Canadian vehicle", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-159", "from": "e50", "to": "e222", "role": "Wholly owned financing vehicle", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-160", "from": "e222", "to": "e4014", "role": "Loan and offsetting obligations in Slapshot", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-161", "from": "e4014", "to": "e221", "role": "On-lending and repayment channel", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-162", "from": "e82", "to": "e1", "role": "Barge and energy transactions challenged by SEC", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-merrill-sec" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-163", "from": "e46", "to": "e82", "role": "$80 million civil settlement without admission or denial", "period": "2000–2003", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-merrill-sec" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-164", "from": "e50", "to": "e222", "role": "Equal member of $375 million lending consortium", "period": "June 2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-165", "from": "e4007", "to": "e222", "role": "Equal member of $375 million lending consortium", "period": "June 2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-166", "from": "e4016", "to": "e222", "role": "Equal member of $375 million lending consortium", "period": "June 2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-167", "from": "e4017", "to": "e222", "role": "Equal member of $375 million lending consortium", "period": "June 2001", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-slapshot" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-168", "from": "e42", "to": "e4018", "role": "Managing member", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-169", "from": "e4018", "to": "e213", "role": "Managing member and guarantor", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-170", "from": "e212", "to": "e213", "role": "Transferred dark-fibre use rights", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-171", "from": "e213", "to": "e4019", "role": "Transferred fibre interests in exit financing", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-172", "from": "e216", "to": "e4019", "role": "Funding vehicle holding Class B beneficial interest", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-173", "from": "e101", "to": "e216", "role": "Sole beneficial interest for $1,000", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-174", "from": "e102", "to": "e101", "role": "Owned and operated service vehicle", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-175", "from": "e4021", "to": "e4019", "role": "Lender alongside Fleet", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-176", "from": "e4022", "to": "e4019", "role": "Lender alongside ABN", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-177", "from": "e4021", "to": "e216", "role": "Lender alongside Fleet", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-178", "from": "e4022", "to": "e216", "role": "Lender alongside ABN", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-179", "from": "e212", "to": "e4020", "role": "Exchanged repurchased dark fibre for lit fibre", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-backbone" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-180", "from": "e1", "to": "e205", "role": "Transferred EOG share block in internal reorganisation", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-181", "from": "e205", "to": "e206", "role": "Transferred EOG share block", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-182", "from": "e206", "to": "e209", "role": "Transferred EOG share block", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-183", "from": "e209", "to": "e4023", "role": "All voting power; 0.01% economics", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-184", "from": "e4024", "to": "e4023", "role": "Initial 99.99% non-voting economic interest", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-185", "from": "e210", "to": "e4023", "role": "Acquired 99.99% non-voting economic interest", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-186", "from": "e4023", "to": "e211", "role": "Held 11.5 million EOG shares", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-187", "from": "e207", "to": "e210", "role": "Ultimate holder of $517.5 million loan", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-188", "from": "e208", "to": "e207", "role": "Swap substituted economic lending exposure", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-189", "from": "e209", "to": "e210", "role": "Total-return swap and asset repurchase support", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-190", "from": "e1", "to": "e209", "role": "Guarantee and demand-note credit support", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-191", "from": "e68", "to": "e208", "role": "Equity-linked swap after restructuring", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cerberus" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-192", "from": "e1", "to": "e36", "role": "36% limited-partner interest package described in Nikita", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-nikita" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-193", "from": "e121", "to": "e37", "role": "Listed parent participation vehicle", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-whitewing-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-194", "from": "e37", "to": "e127", "role": "Listed subsidiary vehicle", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-whitewing-chain" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-195", "from": "e42", "to": "e76", "role": "Certificate investments, not ownership of entire trust structure", "period": "Historical transaction context, 1999–2001; not a continuous tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-whitewing-chain" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-196", "from": "e7", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-197", "from": "e8", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-198", "from": "e20", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-199", "from": "e21", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-200", "from": "e22", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-201", "from": "e23", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-202", "from": "e24", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-203", "from": "e25", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-204", "from": "e26", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-205", "from": "e27", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-206", "from": "e28", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-207", "from": "e29", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-208", "from": "e30", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-209", "from": "e31", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-210", "from": "e32", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-211", "from": "e33", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-212", "from": "e34", "to": "e1", "role": "Director listed in March 2001 annual-report signatures", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-213", "from": "e15", "to": "e1", "role": "Chief accounting officer", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-214", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Chief financial officer", "period": "30 March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-board-snapshot" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-215", "from": "e59", "to": "e1", "role": "5.43% beneficial holding of common class", "period": "15 February 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-216", "from": "e60", "to": "e1", "role": "23.09% beneficial holding of convertible preferred class, reported jointly", "period": "15 February 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-217", "from": "e20", "to": "e1", "role": "17.66% beneficial holding of convertible preferred class", "period": "15 February 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-218", "from": "e61", "to": "e1", "role": "10.24% beneficial holding of convertible preferred class", "period": "15 February 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-219", "from": "e62", "to": "e1", "role": "5.74% of convertible preferred class allocated through plan", "period": "15 February 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ownership-snapshot" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-220", "from": "e32", "to": "e1", "role": "Consulting services additional to director duties", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-221", "from": "e33", "to": "e1", "role": "European consulting services additional to director duties", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-222", "from": "e64", "to": "e63", "role": "50% owner disclosed in proxy", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-223", "from": "e63", "to": "e65", "role": "Travel-services agreement", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-224", "from": "e66", "to": "e1", "role": "Equipment and services supplied to subsidiaries", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-225", "from": "e67", "to": "e68", "role": "Commodity swaps and options counterparty", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-disclosed-business" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-226", "from": "e34", "to": "e253", "role": "Director of NATCO Group, not inferred director of National Tank", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-227", "from": "e34", "to": "e166", "role": "Chairman and CEO", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-228", "from": "e34", "to": "e167", "role": "Managing general partner of investment partnerships", "period": "2001 proxy disclosure; not a full tenure", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-229", "from": "e34", "to": "e168", "role": "Non-executive chairman August 2000–March 2001", "period": "August 2000–March 2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-natco-capricorn" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-230", "from": "e171", "to": "e1", "role": "Conducted limited preliminary review after Watkins warning", "period": "August–October 2001 review", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-watkins-review" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-231", "from": "e4025", "to": "e1", "role": "Employee raising accounting concerns", "period": "August 2001 warning", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "associations", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-watkins-review" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-232", "from": "e4025", "to": "e7", "role": "Presented accounting concerns to chairman", "period": "August 2001 warning", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-watkins-review" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-233", "from": "e233", "to": "e1", "role": "CFO late 2001, then president and COO early 2002", "period": "CFO from late October 2001; president and COO in early 2002", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-leadership-transition" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-234", "from": "e229", "to": "e1", "role": "Interim CEO and restructuring officer", "period": "Early 2002 appointment", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-leadership-transition" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-235", "from": "e245", "to": "e43", "role": "Investor litigation; 2007 class certification reversed", "period": "19 March 2007 appellate decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-class-reversal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-236", "from": "e245", "to": "e82", "role": "Investor litigation; 2007 class certification reversed", "period": "19 March 2007 appellate decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-class-reversal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-237", "from": "e245", "to": "e232", "role": "Investor litigation; 2007 class certification reversed", "period": "19 March 2007 appellate decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-civil-class-reversal" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-238", "from": "e245", "to": "e175", "role": "Lead plaintiff in announced Newby settlement", "period": "10 June 2005 announcement", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-bank-class-settlements" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-239", "from": "e245", "to": "e83", "role": "Lead plaintiff in announced Newby settlement", "period": "14 June 2005 announcement", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-bank-class-settlements" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-240", "from": "e1", "to": "e175", "role": "Estate claims subject to separate 2008 settlement agreement", "period": "March 2008 announcement", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-citi-estate-settlement" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-241", "from": "e237", "to": "e1", "role": "Enron-related claims dismissed in December 2005 ruling", "period": "December 2005 decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-milbank-goldman" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-242", "from": "e238", "to": "e1", "role": "Enron-related claims survived pleading motion", "period": "December 2005 decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-milbank-goldman" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-243", "from": "e239", "to": "e238", "role": "Control-person claim permitted to be amended; not established control finding", "period": "December 2005 decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-milbank-goldman" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-244", "from": "e234", "to": "e1", "role": "Contractual indemnity claims dismissed in April 2009", "period": "April 2009 decision", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-hewitt-indemnity" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-245", "from": "e31", "to": "e161", "role": "Disclosed chairman of Alliance Capital Management International division", "period": "2001", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-alliance-verdict" ], "kind": "directs" }, { "id": "r-246", "from": "e259", "to": "e4026", "role": "Trustee under plan", "period": "Plan effective 17 November 2004; described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-247", "from": "e259", "to": "e4027", "role": "Trustee under plan", "period": "Plan effective 17 November 2004; described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-248", "from": "e4026", "to": "e1", "role": "Holds new common equity under liquidation plan", "period": "Plan effective 17 November 2004; described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-249", "from": "e4027", "to": "e1", "role": "Holds four classes of new preferred equity under plan", "period": "Plan effective 17 November 2004; described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-equity-trusts" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-250", "from": "e257", "to": "e258", "role": "Acquired 100% equity on 17 November 2004", "period": "17 November 2004 completed acquisition", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-251", "from": "e4031", "to": "e257", "role": "GE financing affiliate in CCE joint venture", "period": "November 2004 transaction", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-252", "from": "e4028", "to": "e257", "role": "Joint-venture partner", "period": "November 2004 transaction", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-253", "from": "e258", "to": "e202", "role": "Pipeline interest held within CrossCountry", "period": "Portfolio described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-254", "from": "e258", "to": "e4029", "role": "Pipeline interest held within CrossCountry", "period": "Portfolio described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-255", "from": "e258", "to": "e4030", "role": "Pipeline interest held within CrossCountry", "period": "Portfolio described in July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-crosscountry-sale" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-256", "from": "e1", "to": "e230", "role": "Contributed non-US utility assets to Prisma", "period": "Prisma formation in June 2003", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-prisma-aei" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-257", "from": "e264", "to": "e230", "role": "Acquired remaining stake after first-stage investment in 2006", "period": "2006 completed acquisition", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-prisma-aei" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-258", "from": "e278", "to": "e264", "role": "Formed acquiring company", "period": "2006 acquisition context; formation date not asserted", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-prisma-aei" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-259", "from": "e1", "to": "e129", "role": "All voting securities as reported in July 2005", "period": "As of July 2005 order", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-portland-scope" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-260", "from": "e1", "to": "e113", "role": "Merged into Delaware survivor effective 18 December 2009", "period": "18 December 2009 effective merger", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-merger-survivor" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-261", "from": "e104", "to": "e42", "role": "Replacement general partner following investor action", "period": "January 2002", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute", "c-ljm-remand" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-262", "from": "e326", "to": "e105", "role": "Managing trustee, distinct from Enron director Jerome Meyer", "period": "2004", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-263", "from": "e105", "to": "e42", "role": "Liquidating trust pursuing unpaid investor commitments", "period": "2003–2004", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-ljm-capital-dispute" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-264", "from": "e46", "to": "e40", "role": "Civil settlement without admission or denial, distinct from criminal plea", "period": "2002–2007", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-kopper-radr-civil" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-265", "from": "e46", "to": "e233", "role": "Announced civil settlement subject to approval", "period": "2002–2007", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-266", "from": "e46", "to": "e71", "role": "Final civil judgment by consent without admission or denial", "period": "2002–2007", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-267", "from": "e46", "to": "e4032", "role": "Final civil judgment by consent without admission or denial", "period": "2002–2007", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-staff-civil-settlements" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-268", "from": "e245", "to": "e186", "role": "Lead plaintiff in reported $2.4 billion settlement agreement", "period": "2002–2007", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-cibc-settlement" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-269", "from": "e1", "to": "e180", "role": "Failed-merger litigation followed by reported approved settlement", "period": "2001–2002", "status": "documented", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-dynegy-resolution" ], "kind": "legal" } ], "history": [], "claims": [ { "id": "c-identity", "kind": "fact", "text": "The Enron issuer in the 2000 Form 10-K was an Oregon corporation headquartered in Houston, with IRS employer number 47-0255140. Oregon registry 527549-84 records its names as New Falcon Corp. in July 1996, Enron Oregon Corp. from August 1996, Enron Corp. from July 1997 and Enron Creditors Recovery Corp. from March 2007.", "qualification": "This identifies the historical issuer. A later business or website using the Enron name is not thereby the same legal entity.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3", "s-d47" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1" ] }, { "id": "c-executive-roles", "kind": "fact", "text": "The early-2001 filing identifies Kenneth Lay as chairman and former CEO, Jeffrey Skilling as president and CEO from February 2001, Andrew Fastow as CFO, Richard Causey as chief accounting officer, and Kenneth Rice as chairman and CEO of Enron Broadband Services.", "qualification": "These are dated positions, not present-day appointments. An executive title does not establish responsibility for every transaction.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e8", "e5", "e15", "e13", "e212" ] }, { "id": "c-skilling-verdict", "kind": "fact", "text": "On 25 May 2006, Jeffrey Skilling was convicted on 19 counts: conspiracy, twelve securities-fraud counts, one insider-trading count and five false-statement-to-auditors counts. He was acquitted of nine other insider-trading counts.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "The original 292-month sentence was later replaced by a 168-month sentence in June 2013; the 2010 honest-services ruling did not produce an acquittal on all charges.", "source_ids": [ "s-d125", "s-d129" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-skilling-supreme-court", "kind": "fact", "text": "In June 2010, the Supreme Court held that the honest-services statute covered bribery and kickback schemes and that Skilling’s charged conduct did not fit that theory. It upheld rejection of his fair-trial challenge, vacated the ruling on his conspiracy conviction and remanded for harmless-error analysis.", "qualification": "The Court expressly said the legal defect did not necessarily require reversal of the conspiracy conviction. The later sentencing record confirms that convictions remained, rather than a blanket exoneration.", "response": "", "outcome": "On 21 June 2013, Skilling was resentenced to 168 months and ordered to forfeit approximately $42 million toward victim restitution.", "source_ids": [ "s-d129", "s-d149" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-skilling-resentence", "kind": "fact", "text": "Skilling’s initial 292-month sentence was vacated after the Fifth Circuit found an erroneous financial-institution sentencing enhancement in January 2009. In 2013, the parties agreed to recommend 168–210 months in exchange for waivers of further challenges and agreement not to contest forfeiture and restitution. The judge imposed 168 months on 21 June 2013.", "qualification": "This is a historical sentencing outcome. It does not state that Skilling remains imprisoned at the dossier’s publication date.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d129" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-lay-vacatur", "kind": "fact", "text": "Lay was found guilty in May 2006 on six jury-trial counts and four separate bench-trial counts. After his death on 5 July 2006, his convictions were vacated and the indictment dismissed on 17 October 2006.", "qualification": "The vacatur after death must accompany any account of the verdict. A separately announced civil forfeiture action against his estate is not a surviving criminal conviction or proof of a final civil recovery.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d125", "s-d126", "s-d172" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7" ] }, { "id": "c-fastow-sentence", "kind": "fact", "text": "Andrew Fastow pleaded guilty to two conspiracy counts in January 2004 and was sentenced to six years in prison on 26 September 2006. He admitted manipulating Enron’s results through LJM transactions and enriching himself and others through Southampton.", "qualification": "The six-year sentence supersedes earlier descriptions of a ten-year plea agreement. These admissions concern Fastow and the specified conduct, not every investor or employee connected to LJM.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e41", "e42", "e119" ] }, { "id": "c-fastow-civil", "kind": "fact", "text": "In the separate January 2004 SEC settlement, Fastow accepted a permanent officer-and-director bar and an injunction without admitting or denying the civil allegations. The regulator described coordinated financial relief exceeding $23 million and cooperation with the investigation.", "qualification": "The civil no-admission formulation does not cancel his criminal guilty plea. Early financial-relief figures and later forfeiture descriptions overlap and should not be added as independent recoveries.", "response": "", "outcome": "His actual 2006 prison sentence was six years, despite the earlier settlement announcement’s ten-year headline.", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d133" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-kopper-sentence", "kind": "fact", "text": "Michael Kopper pleaded guilty to conspiracy and money laundering in the Enron investigation. The Justice Department’s closed-case record gives his sentence as three years and one month, with a $50,000 fine, imposed on 17 November 2006.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d150", "s-d160" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e40" ] }, { "id": "c-glisan-sentence", "kind": "fact", "text": "Ben Glisan pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire and securities fraud on 10 September 2003 and was sentenced immediately to 60 months. He agreed to forfeit $938,000 and not seek a refund of approximately $412,000 in taxes.", "qualification": "Glisan admitted that Talon’s supposed outside capital had been returned with profit before the vehicle’s hedging activity, defeating the intended at-risk capital condition.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d128" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e69", "e52", "e42" ] }, { "id": "c-causey-sentence", "kind": "fact", "text": "Richard Causey pleaded guilty to securities fraud in December 2005 and received a 66-month sentence on 15 November 2006. His plea included $1.25 million forfeiture, a $25,000 fine and relinquishment of deferred-compensation claims.", "qualification": "Causey admitted participating in false or misleading filings and public statements about Enron’s financial condition.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d130" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e15" ] }, { "id": "c-lea-misdemeanor", "kind": "fact", "text": "Lea Fastow pleaded guilty to filing a false federal income-tax return, a misdemeanor, and received a one-year custodial sentence in May 2004. Her earlier felony charges were dismissed under the cooperation agreement.", "qualification": "Her admitted conduct concerned unreported RADR-derived income. It is distinct from the financial-reporting crimes admitted by Andrew Fastow; she should not be described as convicted of the dismissed felonies. The plea release names RADR without establishing its exact legal vehicle; this reference is not silently identified as RADR ZWS LLC.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d156" ], "entity_ids": [ "e231", "e4033" ] }, { "id": "c-rice-hannon", "kind": "fact", "text": "Kenneth Rice, former Enron Broadband CEO, was sentenced to 27 months on 18 June 2007 after pleading guilty to securities fraud. The same announcement records a two-year sentence and $125,000 fine for former Broadband COO Kevin Hannon, who had pleaded guilty to conspiracy in August 2004.", "qualification": "Rice admitted false statements about the division’s products, software, network and performance; his approximately $15 million forfeiture was intended for victim compensation.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d252" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e212", "e13", "e313" ] }, { "id": "c-broadband-other-outcomes", "kind": "attributed", "text": "A November 2011 retrospective reports that Enron Broadband defendant Michael Krautz was acquitted and that charges against Scott Yeager were dismissed after appellate proceedings. It reports that Kevin Howard pleaded guilty to falsifying records and served a year of probation.", "qualification": "These reported outcomes concern different defendants. They prevent the existence of the broader Broadband prosecution being treated as a conviction of everyone named in it.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d201" ], "entity_ids": [ "e212", "e199", "e4001", "e4002" ] }, { "id": "c-andersen-reversal", "kind": "fact", "text": "On 31 May 2005, the Supreme Court unanimously reversed Arthur Andersen’s obstruction-of-justice conviction and remanded the case. The jury instructions failed to require the necessary consciousness of wrongdoing and connection to an identifiable official proceeding.", "qualification": "The decision addresses the elements and instructions for this prosecution. It is not a general judicial endorsement of Enron’s accounting or every aspect of the audit.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e35" ] }, { "id": "c-andersen-no-retrial", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The retained chronology reports that prosecutors announced in November 2005 that they would not retry Arthur Andersen. It also records approval of David Duncan’s withdrawal of his guilty plea on 12 December 2005; a later retrospective confirms the withdrawal and a separate SEC settlement.", "qualification": "Duncan’s withdrawn plea should not be presented as a subsisting criminal conviction. The separate securities settlement is a different proceeding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d100", "s-d201" ], "entity_ids": [ "e35", "e263", "e1" ] }, { "id": "c-barge-appeal", "kind": "fact", "text": "In the Nigerian-barge appeal decided in August 2006, the Fifth Circuit reversed conspiracy and wire-fraud convictions of the four appealing Merrill Lynch executives because the honest-services theory did not cover the alleged conduct. It additionally found the evidence insufficient against William Fuhs, while affirming James Brown’s perjury and obstruction convictions.", "qualification": "The majority expressly declined to say no dishonest or criminal conduct occurred. The legal-theory ruling and the separate insufficiency ruling are different outcomes; Brown’s surviving counts are also distinct.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d158" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e82", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226" ] }, { "id": "c-barge-acquittal", "kind": "fact", "text": "Sheila Kahanek was acquitted of all charges in the Nigerian-barge trial. Daniel Boyle was convicted and was not an appellant in the 2006 opinion. The four appellants were James Brown, William Fuhs, Daniel Bayly and Robert Furst.", "qualification": "Their outcomes must be stated separately. A shared transaction does not justify transferring one defendant’s conviction to another.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d158" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e252", "e251", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226", "e82" ] }, { "id": "c-brown-later", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The retained November 2011 retrospective reports that Brown served 47 months on the charges that remained after appeal; it records the reversal of the convictions of Fuhs, Furst and Bayly and Kahanek’s acquittal.", "qualification": "This is a later reported procedural summary, not a new merits finding or a claim that the original conspiracy convictions survived.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d158", "s-d201" ], "entity_ids": [ "e248", "e250", "e226", "e225", "e252" ] }, { "id": "c-committee-scope", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Powers investigation was a private internal inquiry by William Powers, Raymond Troubh and Herbert Winokur, assisted by legal and accounting advisers. It lacked compulsory powers and did not obtain all relevant emails, Andersen workpapers or cooperation from the LJM partnerships and several central participants.", "qualification": "Board and committee assessments were solely Powers and Troubh’s views; assessments of Vinson & Elkins were solely Troubh and Winokur’s. Multiple retained copies reproduce one report, not independent corroboration.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e74", "e115", "e34", "e267" ] }, { "id": "c-spe-test", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Powers report explains that avoiding consolidation required substantive outside capital genuinely at risk and independent control, rather than merely a separate legal entity. It describes 3% as a minimum historical capital benchmark, with adequacy depending on the transaction.", "qualification": "This describes the historical accounting framework applied in the report. A nominal 3% investment or a legal ownership percentage does not by itself establish economic independence or correct accounting.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1" ] }, { "id": "c-jedi-origin", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron and CalPERS established JEDI in 1993 with $250 million each, contributed as Enron stock and cash respectively. Enron was general partner and CalPERS limited partner; joint control supported non-consolidation. Chewco was formed in 1997 to replace CalPERS, whose interest was redeemed for $383 million.", "qualification": "The committee describes successive investments and a later redemption; these are not contemporaneous capital commitments to be added together.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e51", "e48", "e47" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-control", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Kopper initially controlled Chewco through intermediary entities. In December 1997 Chewco became a limited partnership with SONR #1 L.P. as general partner, Big River Funding LLC as limited partner and Little River Funding LLC above Big River. Kopper transferred his interests in Big River and Little River to William Dodson.", "qualification": "The report found uncertainty about whether the changed governance overcame the accounting presumption of control. Kopper remained manager of the general-partner structure and held more than 95% of SONR’s limited-partner interest; Dodson held the remainder.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e40", "e47", "e94", "e91", "e92", "e93" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-approval", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The November 1997 board presentation described Chewco as unaffiliated. The Powers inquiry found no written disclosure or approval of Kopper’s personal participation. Lay said he had not been asked to approve it; Skilling said he approved Kopper’s management role on Fastow’s recommendation and believed he had discussed it with the board.", "qualification": "The committee distinguished these recollections from the written record and said Skilling’s approval did not satisfy the code’s requirement for chairman-and-CEO consent.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e40", "e5", "e7", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-capital", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chewco’s permanent funding comprised a $240 million Barclays loan guaranteed by Enron, a $132 million JEDI advance and about $11.5 million presented as equity. Only $125,000 came from Kopper and Dodson; the remaining approximately $11.4 million was financed through Barclays loans to Big River and Little River.", "qualification": "The figures are the report’s rounded funding description. Debt financed through member entities is not the same as independent loss-bearing capital.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e49", "e48", "e91", "e92", "e40", "e93" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-reserve", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Barclays required $6.58 million cash collateral for the loans supporting Chewco’s apparent equity. JEDI supplied the reserve-account cash. The committee concluded that this protected funding was not genuinely at risk and that Chewco and JEDI should have been consolidated from November 1997.", "qualification": "The report could not establish whether the original failure arose from negligence, poor judgment or self-interest. It could not confirm or disprove Andersen’s account of what its personnel knew.", "response": "Andersen’s CEO said the firm had known the bank supplied the capital but had not known of the reserve-account collateral. Glisan later said he had not known of it at closing.", "outcome": "Enron and Andersen concluded in November 2001 that consolidation was required; Enron announced a restatement.", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e49", "e48" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-fees", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The committee questioned approximately $2 million in Chewco-related fees to Kopper’s structure: $1.6 million management fees and a $400,000 restructuring payment. It also criticised Enron’s immediate recognition of a $10 million guarantee fee and questioned $25.7 million income from capitalising future JEDI management payments.", "qualification": "These are committee assessments of different payment streams, not a single total of stolen funds. The annual management fees were largely funded from the JEDI revolving facility.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e40", "e47", "e94", "e48" ] }, { "id": "c-jedi-own-shares", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The report records $126 million of Enron-stock appreciation recognised through JEDI in the first quarter of 2000, while Enron did not recognise its roughly $90 million share of the subsequent first-quarter 2001 decline. The committee could not reconcile the treatments.", "qualification": "These are the report’s findings on specific periods, not an estimate of all own-share income over JEDI’s life.", "response": "Enron accountants said Andersen advised against recognising the decline because Enron was no longer recognising increases. The committee could not determine the full historic amount of own-share gains.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e48", "e35" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-buyout", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron repurchased Chewco’s JEDI interest in March 2001 for a contractual $35 million. After retained amounts and repayment of JEDI advances, the closing cash retained by Chewco was $3 million, adding to $7.5 million net cash previously received. A $15 million unsecured, non-recourse loan remained linked to Osprey certificates.", "qualification": "Gross purchase price, debt repayment and investors’ cash return are different measures. McMahon described advocating a much lower return; the committee found no direct evidence identifying the final decision-maker.", "response": "Fastow denied participating in the negotiations; other interviews and a memorandum contradicted that account. Skilling denied involvement in or approval of the buyout amount.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e48", "e40", "e93", "e76", "e233", "e5", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-chewco-tax", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The committee questioned an additional $2.6 million tax-indemnity payment to Chewco in September 2001 after lawyers had advised that the agreement did not cover the buyout. Counsel said Fastow relayed Skilling’s approval.", "qualification": "The report presents attributed evidence and could not interview Fastow on the point.", "response": "Skilling said he did not recall communicating with Fastow about the payment. Fastow declined to answer the committee’s questions.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e40", "e5", "e8", "e171" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm1-chain", "kind": "attributed", "text": "LJM Cayman, L.P. (LJM1) was formed in June 1999. Fastow was sole managing member of LJM Partners LLC, which was general partner of LJM Partners LP; that partnership was general partner of LJM1. ERNB Ltd and Campsie Ltd were LJM1 limited partners, associated in the report with CSFB and NatWest.", "qualification": "Each outside limited partner contributed $7.5 million. The named vehicles, rather than the banking groups automatically, are the direct limited partners. Fastow also held the limited-partner interest in LJM Partners LP.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e80", "e77", "e41", "e78", "e79", "e43", "e244" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm2-chain", "kind": "attributed", "text": "LJM2 Co-Investment LP was formed in October 1999 with LJM2 Capital Management LP as general partner. Its general partner was LJM2 Capital Management LLC, managed by Fastow; its limited partners were Fastow and Big Doe LLC, managed by Kopper.", "qualification": "The committee reported about fifty limited partners and $394 million aggregate commitments but lacked cooperation needed to verify the complete roster. A commitment is not proof that the entire amount was contributed.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e42", "e81", "e89", "e5", "e90", "e40" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm2-investors", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The committee identified American Home Assurance, Arkansas Teachers Retirement System and the MacArthur Foundation, together with entities affiliated with Merrill Lynch, J.P. Morgan, Citicorp, First Union, Deutsche Bank, G.E. Capital and Dresdner Kleinwort Benson, among LJM2’s reported investors.", "qualification": "The banking-group associations do not identify each direct legal subscription vehicle. The incomplete roster should not be treated as a complete beneficial-ownership table.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e42", "e82", "e83", "e84", "e85", "e268", "e87", "e88", "e4003", "e4004", "e4005" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm-conflict-controls", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The board authorised Fastow’s LJM roles despite the CFO conflict. LJM2 transactions were to receive Causey and Buy’s approval, with annual audit-committee review. The placement memorandum promoted access to Enron opportunities and named Fastow, Kopper and Glisan in management.", "qualification": "Glisan told the committee that his inclusion in the placement memorandum was a mistake. It is therefore not used as an unqualified LJM management appointment.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e15", "e14", "e34", "e42", "e40", "e69" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm-services", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron and LJM Management LP agreed in April and July 2000 that Enron staff would provide administrative and transaction services, with compensation and costs allocated between the parties. The inquiry could not determine what LJM2 actually paid.", "qualification": "Kopper, Lynn and Yaeger Patel were identified as staff working for LJM while receiving compensation from Enron and LJM. The agreement describes services, not a complete corporate ownership chain.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e117", "e42", "e15", "e5", "e40", "e71", "e72" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm-control-limits", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The report regarded Fastow as the effective general partner but found no clear accounting answer on consolidation solely from control: partnership agreements limited investment authority and gave limited partners removal rights, strengthened during 2000. Kopper bought Fastow’s LJM2 interest after leaving Enron in July 2001.", "qualification": "Managerial control, legal ownership and the accounting consolidation test must remain distinct. The committee did not establish the complete investor governance record. The surrounding account places Fastow’s interests in the general-partner chain; the abbreviated purchase description does not establish a direct LJM2 limited-partner stake held by Kopper.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e40", "e41", "e42" ] }, { "id": "c-rhythms-purpose", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron’s $10 million March 1998 investment in Rhythms appreciated sharply after its 1999 IPO, but a lock-up prevented an immediate sale. Enron used LJM1 and LJM Swap Sub to obtain a hedge whose backing largely consisted of Enron’s own shares.", "qualification": "The committee concluded that this did not transfer risk like an independent creditworthy counterparty: simultaneous declines in Enron and Rhythms would undermine the promised protection.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e41", "e54", "e4006" ] }, { "id": "c-swap-sub-structure", "kind": "attributed", "text": "LJM SwapCo, directed by Fastow, was general partner of LJM Swap Sub; LJM1 was limited partner. The June 1999 structure transferred 3.4 million restricted Enron shares to LJM1 for a $64 million note, then capitalised Swap Sub with 1.6 million of those shares and $3.75 million cash. Swap Sub wrote a put on 5.4 million Rhythms shares.", "qualification": "The prose and earlier structure description establish SwapCo as general partner. A reversed general-partner label in a later retained diagram description is not followed. Share quantities refer to the initial pre-split transaction.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e118", "e54", "e41", "e4006" ] }, { "id": "c-rhythms-review", "kind": "attributed", "text": "PwC supplied a fairness opinion on the initial exchange, but the report questioned Swap Sub’s capital adequacy. Andersen later acknowledged its original 3% assessment had been mistaken; Enron announced retrospective consolidation, reducing 1999 net income by $95 million and 2000 net income by $8 million.", "qualification": "A valuation fairness opinion does not certify every accounting or governance issue in the structure.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e54", "e35", "e223" ] }, { "id": "c-rhythms-unwind", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Rhythms hedge was unwound in spring 2000. The March letter returned 3.1 million post-split Enron shares, terminated the derivatives and provided a $16.7 million net payment to Swap Sub. Causey signed for Enron and Fastow for Swap Sub and Southampton LP.", "qualification": "The $16.7 million net transfer is not inconsistent with the $30 million gross negotiated amount; the report sets out offsets for cash, loan principal, interest and dividends. It found no unwind fairness opinion or board approval record.", "response": "Causey described stabilising the transaction and assessing fairness to Enron. Lay said he was unaware; Skilling said he knew the Rhythms position had been sold but not the unwind terms.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e54", "e5", "e15", "e119" ] }, { "id": "c-southampton-chain", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The March 2000 Southampton Place partnership had Big Doe as general partner and the Fastow Family Foundation, Glisan, Mordaunt, Lynn, Yaeger Patel and Hinds as limited partners. The unwind documentation identified Southampton LP, whose general partner was Southampton Place, as owner of all Swap Sub limited interests and of its general partner.", "qualification": "The committee did not determine how Southampton acquired the interests or what it paid. Southampton Place LP and Southampton LP are retained as separate named vehicles.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e53", "e90", "e58", "e69", "e70", "e71", "e72", "e120", "e119", "e54", "e118", "e40", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-southampton-returns", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The committee found documents showing a $4.5 million payment to the Fastow Family Foundation after a $25,000 investment. Glisan and Mordaunt each reported receiving about $1 million after investing $5,800. The inquiry found no required internal approval for those investments.", "qualification": "These are different investors’ returns and should not be converted into a total attributed to a single person.", "response": "Mordaunt said she believed LJM1 was no longer doing business with Enron and later regarded that judgment as mistaken. Glisan said outside LJM counsel told him the investment was not an Enron related-party transaction. Yaeger Patel’s counsel said she understood it as a bonus with approvals obtained by superiors.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e58", "e5", "e69", "e70", "e40", "e72" ] }, { "id": "c-natwest-pleas", "kind": "fact", "text": "Gary Mulgrew, Giles Darby and David Bermingham pleaded guilty on 28 November 2007 to one wire-fraud count each. They admitted secretly investing in Southampton while selling an asset for their employer, NatWest. Their plea agreements called for 37 months each and approximately $7.3 million repayment to successor Royal Bank of Scotland.", "qualification": "The retained release establishes guilty pleas and agreed sentencing terms, not a later sentencing hearing. Its inconsistent per-person arithmetic is not repeated. The admitted employer deception is not a finding that NatWest itself committed their crime.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d150" ], "entity_ids": [ "e241", "e242", "e243", "e244", "e119", "e5", "e40", "e4007" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-risk", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Powers inquiry concluded that Enron retained the economic risk behind the Raptor hedges: the vehicles were capitalised substantially with Enron shares and share contracts. Falling merchant investments and a falling Enron share price could therefore defeat both sides of the supposed protection.", "qualification": "The report calculates $1.077 billion of pre-tax earnings contributions from the third quarter of 2000 through the third quarter of 2001, excluding the separate $710 million termination charge. This is an accounting comparison, not a sum of cash stolen.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e52", "e96", "e97", "e98", "e35" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-one", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Raptor I was Talon I LLC. Enron participated through its wholly owned Harrier I LLC, contributing a $50 million note and $537 million of Enron stock and contracts in exchange for a $400 million note and membership interests. LJM2 contributed $30 million and managed the vehicle.", "qualification": "The transaction was effective 18 April 2000. A nominal outside contribution did not establish independence where its return was protected and Enron supplied most of the credit capacity.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e52", "e95" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-priority", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Raptor I arrangements gave LJM2 priority over Enron’s hedging activity: the vehicle was not to enter the derivatives until LJM2 had received a $41 million distribution. An Enron put-option transaction produced that payment in August 2000, leaving little outside money exposed before the hedges began.", "qualification": "The $41 million distribution included return of capital and profit; it was not a $41 million profit on top of the $30 million investment. The option transaction also returned $4 million to Enron.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e52" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-dates", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Raptor I recorded $734 million notional derivatives, all dated 3 August 2000 although many were negotiated in September. A hedge of Avici stock at an earlier, higher valuation offset about $75 million of decline. The committee said the earlier date did not reflect when the transactions were actually entered.", "qualification": "The committee found no direct evidence of why 3 August was selected. The board approved Raptor I on 2 May, after its effective date; internal approval signatures followed later, with Skilling’s line blank. Notional derivative value is not equivalent to cash investment.", "response": "Internal lawyer Jordan Zisman raised concerns about transactions involving impaired assets; he later qualified his account and did not say all relevant assets were known to be impaired. Senior lawyers disagreed with his legal assessment.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e52", "e8", "e15", "e14" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-vehicles", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The four Raptor vehicles were Talon I, Timberwolf I, Porcupine I and Bobcat I. The retained subsidiary schedule places them respectively beneath Harrier I, Grizzly I, Pronghorn I and Roadrunner I. Raptor II was created in June 2000, Raptor III in September and Raptor IV also in September.", "qualification": "The report warns that some board materials called the fourth structure Raptor III. The sequence here follows its reconciled naming; an exhibit listing is not a complete contemporaneous percentage-ownership table.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d41" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e52", "e96", "e98", "e97", "e95", "e123", "e124", "e125", "e42" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-three", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Raptor III, Porcupine, was designed to hedge Enron’s investment in The New Power Company using New Power shares themselves. Enron transferred warrants on 24 million shares, through Pronghorn, for a $259 million note; LJM2 contributed $30 million and received $39.5 million about a week later. Enron then used a swap on 18 million New Power shares to support a gain of approximately $370 million.", "qualification": "The warrants had been carried at zero by Enron. The report says the $259 million note was not recorded or deducted from Porcupine’s credit capacity, and found no board approval record. This was a circular exposure to the same investment, not independent insurance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e38", "e98", "e124", "e42", "e122" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-rescue", "kind": "attributed", "text": "A December 2000 cross-guarantee temporarily shared credit capacity among the four Raptors. In the first quarter of 2001 the shortfall reached approximately $504 million. Enron then cross-collateralised the vehicles and supplied further share commitments in a restructuring documented in April but effective 26 March.", "qualification": "The committee questioned whether the restructuring could erase an existing impairment, and noted the inconsistency of a restricted-share discount with price protection. It is not treated here as an independently validated hedge.", "response": "Skilling disputed accounts that he had significant involvement in the December restructuring. Andersen’s initial memorandum supported the temporary cross-guarantee; an amended memorandum in October 2001 recorded objections from its Chicago specialists.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e52", "e96", "e98", "e97", "e35", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-raptor-end", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron terminated the Raptors on 28 September 2001 and paid LJM2 $35 million to unwind its interests. The termination generated a $710 million pre-tax charge, $544 million after tax. The related $1.2 billion equity reduction comprised about $1 billion of previously overstated equity and about $200 million associated with termination.", "qualification": "The charge to earnings and correction to equity measure different accounting effects and must not be added as two cash losses. Fastow negotiated for Enron while Kopper, who had acquired Fastow’s LJM2 interest in July, represented LJM2.", "response": "Enron personnel followed Andersen advice at inception, restructuring and termination according to the committee. The inquiry criticised that advice but could inspect only the workpapers made available to it.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e5", "e40", "e35" ] }, { "id": "c-asset-sales-pattern", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The committee examined nearly twenty other LJM transactions. It found that Enron repurchased five of seven assets sold in the last two quarters of 1999 and that LJM made a profit on every transaction examined. Fastow’s presentation attributed $229 million of second-half 1999 earnings to the transactions, a calculation the inquiry could not confirm.", "qualification": "The report identified evidence of undocumented protection against loss in some transactions, but also acknowledged plausible innocent explanations for some repurchases. Its unverified $229 million presentation figure is not adopted as a measured loss.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e41", "e42", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-cuiaba", "kind": "attributed", "text": "In September 1999 Enron sold LJM1 a 13% interest in the Cuiabá project company, Empresa Productora de Energia, for approximately $11.3 million. Enron used the resulting loss of control to recognise $65 million of mark-to-market income from a gas-supply contract in the second half of 1999. It repurchased LJM1’s interest for $14.4 million in August 2001 despite deterioration in the project.", "qualification": "The price covered the project stake and certain preference shares. The committee could not resolve competing accounts of a prior promise to protect LJM1; such a promise would undermine the claimed risk transfer.", "response": "The buy-back negotiator cited the need to recover a board seat and end quorum problems. Skilling cited misrepresentations to LJM1 and said a buy-back would have been justified for an outside party too. Another employee said Fastow had described an understanding that Enron would repurchase the investment if no buyer emerged.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e41", "e172", "e69", "e5", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-clo", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron North America placed approximately $324 million of loan-backed notes and equity in December 1999. LJM2 bought $32.5 million of the lowest-ranking notes and equity; a Whitewing affiliate bought other low-ranking notes. Another Whitewing affiliate lent LJM2 $38.5 million shortly before its purchase.", "qualification": "The committee could not determine that the Whitewing-affiliate loan funded LJM2’s purchase, although it considered the timing and amount suggestive. The original sale did not create income because the loans were carried at fair value. The lender is not identified as Whitewing Associates itself.", "response": "", "outcome": "After loans deteriorated, Enron supplied a $113 million put option in September 2000 and ultimately repurchased the outstanding notes at par plus interest in May and July 2001, and LJM2’s equity at cost. Part of the put exposure was placed into Raptor I with an earlier effective hedge date.", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e68", "e42", "e37", "e52" ] }, { "id": "c-nowa-sarzyna", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron sold LJM2 a 75% interest in the company holding the Nowa Sarzyna power plant in Poland in December 1999. LJM2 supplied $30 million in loan and equity funding; Enron recorded about $16 million of gain. Enron and Whitewing repurchased the interest and repaid the loan for $31.9 million in March 2000.", "qualification": "This was a temporary holding arrangement: a financing covenant required Enron to retain at least 47.5% until completion, and its waiver expired at the end of March. The committee described a plant malfunction and the inability to find a replacement buyer.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e37", "e4008" ] }, { "id": "c-megs", "kind": "attributed", "text": "LJM2 acquired a 90% interest and a note in MEGS LLC, a Gulf of Mexico gas-gathering business, at the end of 1999. Enron repurchased the interests in March 2000 at a price delivering LJM2 its maximum permitted return. The committee records a later impairment after declining gas-well performance.", "qualification": "The purchase combined a $25.6 million payment for a $23.2 million note with $743,000 of equity. These are not two measures of the same principal. McMahon initially declined to approve the repurchase because its economic rationale had not been demonstrated.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e233", "e4009" ] }, { "id": "c-yosemite-intermediary", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The committee found that LJM2 briefly intermediated Enron’s sale of Yosemite certificates to Whitewing affiliate Condor. Documents dated the two transfers 29 and 30 December 1999, but the actual circular cash-and-certificate transfers appeared to occur on 28 February 2000. LJM2 received $100,000 plus expenses.", "qualification": "Enron sought to reduce a 50% certificate holding to 10% for disclosure purposes. The report could not explain why Condor could not buy directly or how a transfer onward before year-end met that purpose. This certificate transaction is distinct from all Yosemite financing raised over time. The report’s Watkins section names Condor Trust as a Whitewing Associates subsidiary; that fuller description is used for the Condor affiliate identified in this same report, not an independently verified present-day registration.", "response": "McMahon said he challenged Fastow after Fastow pressed an employee negotiating LJM2’s fee. The original lower fee prevailed, rather than the $1 million or more initially sought by LJM2.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e37", "e204", "e4010", "e5", "e233" ] }, { "id": "c-citigroup-prepays", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The SEC’s July 2003 settled order describes ten Citigroup–Enron prepay transactions between December 1998 and June 2001, making $3.8 billion available over that period. Circular commodity swaps returned commodity risk to Enron while providing financing reported as operating cash flow. Delta Energy Corporation was a nominally capitalised Citigroup-sponsored intermediary.", "qualification": "Citigroup settled without admitting or denying the findings. The $3.8 billion is cumulative financing, not simultaneous outstanding debt; approximately $2.3 billion raised through Yosemite financed additional prepays and is not a separate amount to add to that total.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e176", "e204" ] }, { "id": "c-citigroup-nahanni", "kind": "attributed", "text": "In Project Nahanni, Enron was general partner of Marengo and contributed $400 million in unsecured notes plus $100 million of subsidiary preferred stock. Citigroup arranged limited partner Nahanni, capitalised with a $485 million loan and $15 million outside investment, to contribute $500 million of Treasury bills. Their sale appeared in Enron’s consolidated operating cash flow.", "qualification": "These are findings in a settled SEC order, not admissions by Citigroup. The transaction exchanged different forms of financing; the Treasury-bill proceeds were not cash earned from a customer sale.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e182", "e183" ] }, { "id": "c-bacchus", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The SEC found that Project Bacchus was economically a $200 million financing structured as an asset sale, enabling Enron to record $112 million gain. Caymus received $194 million debt and $6 million equity; the equity risk was transferred to Citigroup, which received oral assurances against loss from Enron.", "qualification": "Citigroup neither admitted nor denied the SEC findings. Senate investigators identified Long Lane Master Trust IV as the FleetBoston vehicle supplying the apparent equity, and distinguished formal equity ownership from the ultimate economic risk.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56", "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e184", "e219", "e217" ] }, { "id": "c-citigroup-settlement", "kind": "fact", "text": "Citigroup’s July 2003 SEC settlement required $101.25 million for Enron-related conduct: a $48.5 million penalty and $52.75 million disgorgement and interest. The same order separately addressed Dynegy conduct.", "qualification": "The order was entered without admission or denial of its findings. A larger combined payment including Dynegy must not be presented as an Enron-only amount.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-chase-prepays", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The SEC alleged that Chase provided approximately $2.6 billion through seven Enron prepays between December 1997 and September 2001. Mahonia Limited and Mahonia Natural Gas Limited were the Jersey intermediaries, controlled by Chase according to the complaint. The circular trades returned commodity risk to Enron and left repayment obligations resembling loans.", "qualification": "This is the SEC’s allegation, not a trial finding or an inference from the vehicles’ offshore location. The two Mahonia companies are distinct legal entities.", "response": "", "outcome": "Chase simultaneously settled the SEC action without admitting or denying the allegations, as recorded in the separate retained supplemental release.", "source_ids": [ "s-d55", "s-d9001" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e83", "e50", "e173", "e174" ] }, { "id": "c-chase-settlement", "kind": "fact", "text": "On 28 July 2003 the SEC announced a simultaneous settlement with J.P. Morgan Chase for $135 million and an injunction against future securities-law violations. Chase did not admit or deny the allegations.", "qualification": "This separately retained primary release clarifies the historical outcome of the complaint. It is not an addition of an event after the archive cutoff.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d9001" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e83", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-fishtail", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Senate investigators described Fishtail as a December 2000 joint venture with equal voting interests held by Enron North America and Annapurna. LJM2 participated through LJM2-Ampato; it supplied $8 million cash while Chase supplied a $42 million funding commitment, rather than an immediate $42 million cash investment.", "qualification": "The committee questioned the independence of the capital and the valuation of Enron’s non-cash contribution. Enron and Chase defended the valuation as third-party analysis; the report noted that the analyst was a Chase affiliate.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e68", "e42", "e217", "e218", "e50", "e4011" ] }, { "id": "c-sundance", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sundance combined Enron’s pulp-and-paper assets with Citigroup in June 2001. The Senate report found that contractual safeguards protected Citigroup’s $28.5 million cash-and-share contribution and $160 million contingent commitment. Citigroup terminated the partnership around 30 November 2001, recovered the $28.5 million plus a return and ended the commitment.", "qualification": "The report’s conclusion was an oversight assessment, not a separate criminal conviction. The $160 million was an unfunded commitment, not cash lost. The June transaction also repaid the earlier Bacchus financing; these linked steps should not be totalled as independent losses.", "response": "A Citigroup official said Andersen had approved the accounting and Citigroup had not opined on it. After initially failing to recall the approvals, its risk executive testified that refreshed recollection supported his approval; the report could not establish who gave final management approval. Vinson & Elkins viewed a derivative as sufficient for a true-sale opinion, a position the report criticised.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e220", "e217", "e184", "e171" ] }, { "id": "c-slapshot", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Senate report describes Slapshot as a June 2001 Canadian tax structure surrounding a real $375 million bank-consortium loan to the Stadacona paper business. It distinguished that financing from a same-day $1.039 billion circular transfer and offsetting $1.4 billion obligations used to generate claimed interest deductions.", "qualification": "Chase established Flagstaff; Sundance owned the two-tier Dutch chain above CPS, whose subsidiaries included Hansen and Newman. The lending consortium comprised Chase, RBS, Industrial Bank of Japan and Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi. The report records $124.9 million gross deductions claimed, not tax cash saved of that amount.", "response": "Enron and Chase obtained Canadian legal opinions supporting the structure, but Enron’s opinion warned of likely challenge and litigation. Enron’s counsel later said no further Slapshot tax benefits would be claimed. The projected $60 million benefit was an estimate, not an established refund.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e50", "e83", "e221", "e222", "e220", "e4007", "e4012", "e4013", "e4014", "e4015", "e4016", "e4017" ] }, { "id": "c-merrill-sec", "kind": "attributed", "text": "In March 2003 the SEC alleged that Merrill Lynch helped Enron inflate results through the Nigerian barge transaction and offsetting energy options. Merrill simultaneously settled for $80 million and an injunction, without admitting or denying the allegations.", "qualification": "The $80 million comprised $37.5 million disgorgement, $5 million interest and $37.5 million penalty. The corporate SEC settlement is separate from individual criminal proceedings and their mixed outcomes.", "response": "", "outcome": "The options were unwound in June 2000 before trading began, for a reduced $8.5 million fee instead of the original $17 million present-value fee. The barge defendants’ acquittals, reversals and surviving convictions are addressed individually on the legal-outcomes page.", "source_ids": [ "s-d120" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e82", "e75", "e46", "e225", "e226", "e227", "e228" ] }, { "id": "c-backbone", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The bankruptcy examiner described three Backbone stages: Enron Broadband transferred rights to use dark fibre to LJM2-Backbone II; a later trust financing allowed LJM2 to exit; Enron subsequently repurchased the rights and exchanged them with Qwest for lit fibre. The examiner found evidence that Enron retained control and substantially all benefits and risks, making loan characterisation plausible.", "qualification": "The examiner’s analysis was not a final recharacterisation judgment. The initial transfer is documented as approximately $100 million, with about $30 million cash and $70 million note; precise execution timing was uncertain. The committee recorded Enron’s $54 million gain and staff’s account that fibre was ultimately sold to substantial customers.", "response": "The EBS negotiators believed they achieved a good result despite Fastow’s intervention. The examiner nevertheless questioned the continuing risk and control. Lord Securities’ $1,000 beneficial-interest structure was a service-provider arrangement, not evidence that unrelated later clients participated in Enron.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e212", "e42", "e213", "e216", "e101", "e102", "e4018", "e4019", "e4020", "e4021", "e4022" ] }, { "id": "c-cerberus", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The examiner traced 11.5 million EOG Resources shares through Enron Finance Partners, Enron Intermediate Holdings and Enron Asset Holdings into Aeneas. Asset Holdings retained all voting power and 0.01% economics; a 99.99% non-voting economic interest passed through Psyche to Heracles Trust, financed with $517.5 million ultimately held by Royal Bank of Canada.", "qualification": "The ownership percentages concern different rights in Aeneas, not Enron or EOG. Enron-supported swaps and puts retained economic exposure, leading the examiner to question true-sale treatment. The January 2001 substitution of Rabobank exposure occurred through swaps rather than a simple assignment of the RBC loan.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e205", "e206", "e209", "e211", "e210", "e207", "e208", "e68", "e4023", "e4024" ] }, { "id": "c-nikita", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The examiner describes Project Nikita as the September 2001 monetisation of Enron’s limited-partnership interests in EOTT Energy Partners, representing 36% of outstanding limited interests. The package included common units, subordinated units and additional partnership interests.", "qualification": "This is a dated asset position and financing project, not a complete ownership chain or a claim that all EOTT units were transferred to one later holder. The report’s conversion-unit arithmetic is not repeated.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e36" ] }, { "id": "c-whitewing-chain", "kind": "fact", "text": "Enron’s retained subsidiary schedule lists Whitewing Associates beneath Peregrine I and Blue Herron I beneath Whitewing. The Powers report separately records LJM investments in Osprey trust and associate certificates linked to Whitewing during 1999–2000.", "qualification": "An exhibit’s indented listing and a certificate investment describe different layers. They do not establish that LJM owned the whole Whitewing group or every listed asset.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d41" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e121", "e37", "e127", "e42", "e76" ] }, { "id": "c-board-snapshot", "kind": "fact", "text": "Enron’s annual filing signed on 30 March 2001 lists Lay as chairman, Skilling as CEO and director, Causey as chief accounting officer and Fastow as CFO. Its director signatures also identify Belfer, Blake, Chan, Duncan, Gramm, Harrison, Jaedicke, LeMaistre, Mendelsohn, Meyer, Ferraz Pereira, Savage, Urquhart, Wakeham and Winokur.", "qualification": "This is a dated governance roster, not evidence that every director knew every transaction or held the same responsibility.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e8", "e15", "e5", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e23", "e24", "e25", "e26", "e27", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e31", "e32", "e33", "e34" ] }, { "id": "c-ownership-snapshot", "kind": "fact", "text": "The February 2001 proxy reported Janus with 5.43% of Enron common stock. Its convertible preferred-stock table reported the Rubens with 23.09%, Belfer with 17.66%, Saltz with 10.24% and the employee savings plan with 5.74% of that class.", "qualification": "Common and convertible preferred percentages have different denominators. Beneficial-ownership figures include specified family, trust, conversion and option interests, with disclaimers in the source; they are not a complete ultimate-owner register or exclusive personal economic ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e59", "e60", "e20", "e61", "e62" ] }, { "id": "c-disclosed-business", "kind": "fact", "text": "The 2001 proxy disclosed consulting payments to Urquhart and Wakeham, travel-agency revenue connected with Enron employee travel, NATCO supplier revenue and Belco–Enron North America commodity dealings. It stated that management believed the relevant commercial arrangements were no less favourable than comparable third-party terms.", "qualification": "A disclosed business relationship is not itself evidence of misconduct. The figures measure different things: $493,914 Urquhart services and expenses, $72,000 Wakeham services, $517,200 travel-agency net revenue, $370,294 NATCO sales, and approximately $32 million Belco settlements plus $1 million option premiums.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e32", "e33", "e63", "e64", "e65", "e34", "e66", "e67", "e68" ] }, { "id": "c-natco-capricorn", "kind": "fact", "text": "The proxy identifies Winokur as chairman and CEO of Capricorn Holdings, managing general partner of Capricorn investment partnerships, a NATCO Group director and a former non-executive Azurix chairman. It explains the National Tank connection through fund management and minority fund interests, not a direct personal ownership percentage.", "qualification": "NATCO Group and National Tank are separate named companies. A NATCO Group directorship must not be silently reassigned as a National Tank directorship.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14" ], "entity_ids": [ "e34", "e166", "e167", "e253", "e66", "e168" ] }, { "id": "c-oversight-controls", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Powers and Troubh board assessment found that extensive LJM controls were insufficiently implemented. Causey and Buy were supposed to approve transactions, committees were to review them and further controls were represented as involving Skilling. The inquiry found incomplete transaction lists, brief reviews, missing approvals and inadequate scrutiny of Fastow’s compensation.", "qualification": "The assessment also says significant information was withheld from directors, found no evidence of their financial interests in the partnerships and recognised legitimate reasons to rely on advisers. LJM3 was proposed but never created.", "response": "Directors described LJM as an optional source of quicker capital with independent checks. Causey described checking business-unit approvals; Buy described reviewing risk; Skilling said he had little transaction-level involvement and compared Fastow’s Enron and LJM stakes rather than his actual compensation.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e15", "e14", "e8", "e5", "e34", "e26", "e35" ] }, { "id": "c-board-response", "kind": "attributed", "text": "In congressional testimony Winokur defended the board’s decision as a good-faith business judgment based on information and professional advice available at the time. He said management concealed transactions and the auditors failed to alert directors that controls were not followed. Jaedicke likewise defended reliance on management and advisers.", "qualification": "These are the directors’ responses to criticism, not findings exonerating them. Winokur did not participate in the Powers report’s assessment of board performance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d241" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e34", "e26", "e35", "e171" ] }, { "id": "c-watkins-review", "kind": "attributed", "text": "After Sherron Watkins raised concerns in August 2001, Lay and Derrick commissioned a preliminary Vinson & Elkins review. Its scope excluded reconsidering Andersen’s accounting advice and detailed transaction examination. V&E concluded that a wider independent investigation was not warranted, while warning of publicity and litigation risk.", "qualification": "The Powers report judged several Watkins concerns well-founded but said she had some underlying facts wrong. Its authors criticised the narrow scope and reliance on senior participants. They did not conduct a complete investigation of the V&E review itself.", "response": "Lay and Derrick said familiar counsel could work quickly and that the purpose was to decide whether independent review was necessary. V&E reported that interviewed personnel could identify no unreasonable transaction or economic harm to Enron, and that Enron and Andersen considered the accounting technically appropriate.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e16", "e171", "e35", "e4025" ] }, { "id": "c-leadership-transition", "kind": "fact", "text": "Enron announced Skilling’s resignation on 14 August 2001, citing his personal reasons, and Lay’s return to president and CEO duties. McMahon later testified that he became CFO in late October 2001 and president and COO in early 2002, when Stephen Cooper became interim CEO and chief restructuring officer.", "qualification": "These roles belong to different dates and stages of the business. A pre-collapse title should not be carried forward to the creditor administration.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166", "s-d241", "s-d245" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8", "e7", "e233", "e229" ] }, { "id": "c-civil-pleadings", "kind": "fact", "text": "The December 2002 Newby ruling allowed pleaded claims against several banks and advisers to proceed but dismissed claims against Deutsche Bank and Kirkland & Ellis, and narrowed claims against Bank of America and Lehman. A June 2006 ruling confirmed dismissal of all Deutsche Bank claims and dismissed Section 12(a)(2) claims without prejudice for lack of a representative with standing.", "qualification": "Surviving a motion to dismiss means the pleading meets the applicable threshold; it is not a liability finding. The later appellate class-certification outcome materially limits the trajectory against the appealing banks.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d131", "s-d151" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e186", "e175", "e83", "e232", "e43", "e82", "e268", "e265", "e270", "e269", "e171", "e35", "e245" ] }, { "id": "c-civil-class-reversal", "kind": "fact", "text": "On 19 March 2007 the Fifth Circuit reversed class certification and remanded the case involving Credit Suisse, Merrill Lynch and Barclays. The majority rejected the asserted classwide presumptions of reliance for the banks’ alleged conduct. Judge Dennis concurred in reversal on narrower class-certification grounds and disagreed with the majority’s broad account of primary liability.", "qualification": "This was an interlocutory certification appeal, not a criminal acquittal or an order dismissing every Enron claim against every bank. The separate retained primary decision clarifies a historical outcome within the archive’s time scope.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d9002" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e43", "e82", "e232", "e245" ] }, { "id": "c-bank-class-settlements", "kind": "fact", "text": "Citigroup announced a $2 billion Newby settlement on 10 June 2005; JPMorgan Chase announced a $2.2 billion agreement in principle four days later. Both releases stated that approvals remained necessary and rejected an admission of wrongdoing.", "qualification": "These source documents establish settlement agreements at announcement, not proof of completed distribution to every investor. The banks cited avoiding uncertainty, burden and expense of litigation.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d152", "s-d157" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e83", "e245" ] }, { "id": "c-citi-estate-settlement", "kind": "fact", "text": "In March 2008 Citi announced an agreement to pay $1.66 billion to the Enron estate, withdraw specified claims and resolve related credit-linked-note disputes. The estate would release its claims and allow specified bankruptcy claims, including those of holders of approximately $2.4 billion of credit-linked notes.", "qualification": "Citi denied wrongdoing and said the agreements required bankruptcy-court approval. The estate settlement differs from the Newby investor settlement; allowed creditor claims are not an additional $2.4 billion cash payment by Citi.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d159" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175" ] }, { "id": "c-director-settlement", "kind": "attributed", "text": "January 2005 reporting described a proposed $168 million settlement involving eighteen former Enron directors, with ten contributing $13 million personally. The report identified Winokur, Mendelsohn and other participants separately from those making personal payments.", "qualification": "The report said court approval remained pending. It does not establish that every one of the eighteen paid personally or that a settlement was a liability verdict.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d206" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e23", "e24", "e25", "e26", "e27", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e31", "e32", "e33", "e34", "e193", "e224" ] }, { "id": "c-milbank-goldman", "kind": "fact", "text": "A December 2005 ruling dismissed claims against Milbank Tweed but denied Goldman Sachs’ motion to dismiss. It permitted amendment of control-person claims involving the Goldman parent and left due-diligence and reliance defences for an appropriate evidentiary stage.", "qualification": "The decision addresses pleading sufficiency and amendment, not a finding that Goldman committed the alleged violations.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d88" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e237", "e238", "e239" ] }, { "id": "c-azurix-dismissal", "kind": "fact", "text": "The Fifth Circuit affirmed dismissal of the Azurix investor action. It found inadequate pleading of scienter for the Exchange Act claims, lack of Section 12 standing and no material misstatements adequately alleged under Section 11.", "qualification": "The decision concerns the particular Azurix investor claims. Recognising the possibility of aftermarket Section 11 standing did not save those claims on their merits.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d242" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e168" ] }, { "id": "c-hewitt-indemnity", "kind": "fact", "text": "In April 2009 the district court dismissed Hewitt’s claims that Enron was obliged to indemnify damages caused by Hewitt’s own conduct under the administration agreement.", "qualification": "The order concerns contractual indemnity pleadings. It is not a dismissal of all pension or ERISA litigation associated with Enron.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e234" ] }, { "id": "c-alliance-verdict", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Contemporaneous reporting records an April 2005 jury verdict rejecting Florida’s negligence, fraud and contract claims against Alliance Capital concerning Enron investments. The jury awarded a $1.1 million management-fee counterclaim, but a pre-verdict agreement meant Florida would not pay it or appeal.", "qualification": "The loss of the Enron investment did not itself establish wrongdoing by the investment manager. Savage’s disclosed Alliance position does not override this reported case outcome.", "response": "Florida’s official disagreed with the verdict; Alliance’s lawyer said the manager had performed the work it was hired to do.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14", "s-d266" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e161", "e31" ] }, { "id": "c-bankruptcy-plan", "kind": "fact", "text": "Enron and certain subsidiaries began Chapter 11 cases on 2 December 2001. The July 2005 SEC order records 180 related entities eventually filing, while Portland General Electric and many operating affiliates did not. The confirmed plan became effective on 17 November 2004 and envisaged asset sales and estate litigation rather than a continuing Enron operating business.", "qualification": "The bankruptcy court’s confirmation order was dated 15 July 2004. The later count of 180 filings is not the number filing on the first day, and an affiliate’s bankruptcy cannot be inferred solely from Enron ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166", "s-d213" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e129", "e68", "e212" ] }, { "id": "c-equity-trusts", "kind": "fact", "text": "The plan cancelled Enron’s old common and four classes of preferred shares. Newly issued stock was held by common and preferred equity trusts with Stephen Forbes Cooper LLC as trustee; former holders received conditional, non-voting and generally non-transferable trust interests.", "qualification": "Distributions to former shareholders depended on assets exceeding allowed claims, an outcome the SEC order described as highly unlikely. The trust interests did not restore the old listed stock or promise recovery.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e259", "e229", "e4026", "e4027" ] }, { "id": "c-crosscountry-sale", "kind": "fact", "text": "On 17 November 2004 Enron and affiliates completed the sale of all CrossCountry Energy LLC equity to CCE Holdings for approximately $2.1 billion net cash. CCE was a Southern Union and GE Commercial Finance Energy Financial Services joint venture.", "qualification": "CrossCountry held pipeline interests including Transwestern, Citrus and Northern Plains. The amount is the stated net cash purchase price, not a valuation of the entire Enron estate.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e257", "e258", "e4031", "e4028", "e202", "e4029", "e4030" ] }, { "id": "c-prisma-aei", "kind": "fact", "text": "Enron formed Prisma in June 2003 to hold principally non-US utility assets. AEI’s later filing records AEIL’s acquisition in two completed stages in 2006: initially 24.26% of votes and 49% economics, then the remainder. AEIL and Prisma were amalgamated in December, with Prisma surviving and changing its name, ultimately to AEI.", "qualification": "Voting and economic percentages differ in the first stage. AEIL, the acquiring vehicle, is distinct from the surviving Prisma/AEI company; a name change does not create an additional independent asset sale.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166", "s-d193" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e230", "e264", "e278" ] }, { "id": "c-portland-scope", "kind": "fact", "text": "The July 2005 SEC order identifies Enron as owner of all Portland General Electric voting securities and expressly states that the utility was not in bankruptcy.", "qualification": "This is the position at that order’s date. Proposed sales or financing authorisations in earlier records are not evidence that a particular sale subsequently closed, and no present-day Enron ownership is asserted.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e129" ] }, { "id": "c-merger-survivor", "kind": "fact", "text": "Oregon’s registry records a merger effective 18 December 2009 from the Enron Creditors Recovery record into Enron Dissolution Corp., a Delaware survivor.", "qualification": "The historical issuer’s former names and merger successor are distinguished from any later business adopting the Enron brand. The registry event is not by itself a complete account of every later estate distribution.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d222", "s-d48" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e113" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm-capital-dispute", "kind": "fact", "text": "After LJM2 defaulted, its creditors invoked a $47 million capital call in December 2001. Limited partners replaced the general partner with Partnership Services and sought to cancel the call. Following LJM2’s own bankruptcy, liquidating Trust B, managed by Edward N. Meyer for bank creditors, made a further $75 million call. In December 2004 the Delaware court denied the limited partners’ motion to dismiss the resulting action.", "qualification": "This was a pleading-stage decision, not a judgment collecting the full requested amounts. The original $120 million credit facility, $47 million call and later $75 million call are distinct measures and must not be summed as an Enron loss.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d25" ], "entity_ids": [ "e42", "e81", "e104", "e105", "e326" ] }, { "id": "c-ljm-remand", "kind": "fact", "text": "The federal Delaware court remanded LJM2’s dispute with former general partner LJM2 Capital Management to Chancery and denied transfer in February 2003. It recorded the prior replacement by Partnership Services and competing claims over the partnership’s management.", "qualification": "Remand decided the forum, not the merits of the competing contract, loyalty, conversion or self-dealing allegations.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d122" ], "entity_ids": [ "e42", "e81", "e104" ] }, { "id": "c-kopper-radr-civil", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The SEC’s August 2002 Kopper action alleged that secretly funded RADR entities retained Enron control over wind farms while appearing independent. Its release records approximately $2.7 million distributions and a later $1.8 million repurchase gain to Kopper and others. Kopper simultaneously agreed to a civil injunction, permanent officer-and-director bar and approximately $12 million disgorgement and forfeiture.", "qualification": "The civil settlement was announced subject to court approval and without admitting or denying the allegations. The related criminal plea and later sentence are separately established; family-member details are unnecessary to the public account.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d303" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e40", "e5", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-staff-civil-settlements", "kind": "fact", "text": "In 2007 the SEC announced McMahon’s agreement to a $300,000 payment and five-year officer-and-director bar over alleged barge and financial-disclosure misconduct, without admission or denial and subject to court approval. Separately, final judgments against Kathleen Lynn and Jerry Castleman concerning Cuiabá were entered in August 2007, also without admission or denial.", "qualification": "Lynn’s judgment required $30,000 penalty and nominal $1 disgorgement. Castleman’s $41,268.29 disgorgement-and-interest amount was waived except for $12,000 based on financial evidence. McMahon’s accountant suspension allowed reapplication after three years; Castleman’s after five. These civil results are not criminal convictions.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d254", "s-d255" ], "entity_ids": [ "e233", "e71", "e4032", "e46", "e1", "e172" ] }, { "id": "c-cibc-settlement", "kind": "attributed", "text": "August 2005 reporting records CIBC’s $2.4 billion agreement to settle Enron investor litigation. CIBC admitted no wrongdoing and said it was ending the uncertainty, burden and expense of prolonged litigation. Its board approved the agreement, while UC Regents and court approval remained pending.", "qualification": "This is a reported settlement agreement and approval posture at that date, not an admission or a trial finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d212" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e186", "e245" ] }, { "id": "c-dynegy-resolution", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Enron sought at least $10 billion after Dynegy terminated the proposed merger, but that was a demand, not an award. September 2002 reporting records bankruptcy-court approval of a $25 million settlement that also released more than $62 million from escrow.", "qualification": "The settlement amount and released escrow are different components. Dynegy had cited breaches of representations, warranties and agreements, and countersued to protect its Northern Natural Gas rights.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d213", "s-d214" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e180", "e179" ] }, { "id": "c-tax-scope", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Joint Committee on Taxation staff reported that Enron’s returns, before audit adjustments, showed approximately $325 million federal income tax for 1990–1995, none for 1996–1999 and approximately $63 million for 2000–2001. Its December 2001 structure included 441 Cayman entities, mostly inactive and largely irrelevant for tax purposes according to the testimony.", "qualification": "Different dates and definitions yield different affiliate counts. An offshore address or zero tax in a specified period does not itself establish an unlawful transaction, and these figures are not an audited calculation of taxes evaded.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d301" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-97691077c2ef9380dc025f4e", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Jeffrey Skilling’s May 2006 verdict covered nineteen counts, while nine insider-trading counts ended in acquittal. His appeals changed important parts of the case. In 2010, the Supreme Court confined honest-services fraud to bribery and kickback schemes and held that his charged conduct did not meet that theory. It rejected his fair-trial challenge but sent the conspiracy issue back for harmless-error analysis. The opinion explicitly left open whether the defect required the conviction to fall.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d125", "s-d129", "s-d149" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-431e527c39cecf4681f672c6", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The sentence changed on a separate track. The original 292-month term included an enhancement that the Fifth Circuit found erroneous in 2009. Under a 2013 agreement, Skilling waived further challenges and did not contest forfeiture and restitution; the judge imposed 168 months and approximately $42 million forfeiture for victims. The retained final sentencing record establishes a reduced sentence, not an acquittal or erasure of all convictions.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d129" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-5e0aa0b85c362920c1a029c4", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Kenneth Lay was found guilty on six counts by a jury and four more in a separate bench trial. He died before sentencing. On October 17, 2006, his convictions were vacated and the indictment dismissed. That is the indispensable outcome when recounting the earlier verdict. The government’s separately announced civil forfeiture claim against his estate does not restore the criminal conviction or establish that the claimed recovery was finally awarded.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d125", "s-d126", "s-d172" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-0d3baff31f4615aea89ac135", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Andrew Fastow admitted using LJM transactions to manipulate Enron’s results and participating in the self-enrichment associated with Southampton. His January 2004 guilty plea was followed by a six-year sentence in September 2006. Earlier announcements describing a ten-year agreement are therefore not the final sentencing result. His separate SEC settlement imposed a permanent officer-and-director bar without admission or denial of the civil allegations; that formulation does not negate the criminal admissions.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d133" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e41", "e42", "e119", "e46" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-82a829a0012a999fecb24f6b", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Michael Kopper received a 37-month sentence and $50,000 fine in November 2006. Ben Glisan had pleaded guilty in September 2003 and received 60 months, with forfeiture and a tax-refund waiver. Glisan admitted that Talon’s apparent outside investment was returned with a prearranged profit before its hedging activity. Richard Causey’s securities-fraud plea led to a 66-month sentence in November 2006, together with forfeiture, a fine and abandonment of deferred-compensation claims.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d150", "s-d160", "s-d128", "s-d130" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e40", "e69", "e52", "e42", "e15" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-de347cdbdae7b48f5b569368", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Lea Fastow’s case concerned a false income-tax return and RADR-derived income. The disposition was a misdemeanor plea and one year of custody; the earlier felony charges were dismissed under her cooperation agreement. It should not be conflated with the financial-reporting conspiracy admitted by Andrew Fastow.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d156" ], "entity_ids": [ "e231", "e4033" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-0162664ca5cd29464af207aa", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Kenneth Rice admitted misrepresentations about Enron Broadband’s products, software and performance and received a 27-month sentence in June 2007. Kevin Hannon, the former COO, received two years after a conspiracy plea. Those outcomes do not describe every defendant in the broader Broadband case: the retained retrospective records Michael Krautz’s acquittal, dismissal of Scott Yeager’s charges after appeal, and Kevin Howard’s separate records-falsification plea and probation.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d252", "s-d201" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e212", "e13", "e313", "e199", "e4001", "e4002" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-b647061000e046b838d61dd1", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Kopper’s civil case also concerned the RADR wind-farm structures. The SEC alleged hidden funding and nominee investment rather than an independent divestment; the announced civil agreement combined forfeiture and disgorgement with an officer-and-director bar. It was without admission or denial on the civil allegations. His criminal plea and sentence remain separate outcomes, and the sums received by a group of participants are not assigned entirely to one person.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d303" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e40", "e5", "e46" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-f6761b2e02f97342b62fa7e2", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Arthur Andersen’s obstruction prosecution arose from document destruction as Enron’s difficulties became public. On May 31, 2005, the Supreme Court held that the instructions had failed to convey the required consciousness of wrongdoing. They could permit conviction even if the defendant believed its conduct lawful. The Court also found that the instructions did not require the necessary connection between persuasion to destroy records and a particular contemplated official proceeding.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e35" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-49f7b08aa020265fcc61fe3c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The judgment was unanimously reversed and remanded. The ruling should neither disappear behind the earlier guilty verdict nor be enlarged into approval of Enron’s financial statements. It decided the legal requirements and defective instructions in this obstruction case, leaving separate questions about audit work and accounting outside that disposition.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e35" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-206381e2c0945936da0e7cba", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The retained chronology reports that prosecutors said in November 2005 that they would not retry Andersen. It records the court’s December 12 approval of audit partner David Duncan’s withdrawal of his guilty plea; a later retrospective confirms that withdrawal and a separate securities settlement. The firm’s reversed conviction and Duncan’s withdrawn plea therefore cannot be displayed as continuing criminal convictions.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d100", "s-d201" ], "entity_ids": [ "e35", "e263", "e1" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-ab60f542da66e1b2ecf2eaed", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Nigerian-barge prosecution concerned the claim that a temporary placement of Enron’s barge interest with Merrill Lynch had been reported as a genuine sale. In the appeal, the Fifth Circuit addressed the legal theory used to convict four Merrill executives. It reversed their conspiracy and wire-fraud convictions because the honest-services theory did not reach the conduct charged. The majority expressly cautioned that its decision did not establish that no dishonest, fraudulent or criminal act had occurred.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d158" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e82", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-7e2a882b3e633b2d7d5c83e9", "kind": "analysis", "text": "William Fuhs also prevailed on a separate ground: the government’s evidence did not adequately prove his knowledge and intent. The court rejected inferences that depended on assuming he knew of a concealed oral guarantee. James Brown’s result was different. Although his fraud counts were reversed with the others, his perjury and obstruction convictions were affirmed. The later retained retrospective reports 47 months served on the remaining charges.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d158", "s-d201" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e82", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226", "e252" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-09368519631854fed24bf379", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Sheila Kahanek, an Enron accountant, was acquitted of all charges. Daniel Boyle was convicted but did not join the appeal described in this opinion. Daniel Bayly and Robert Furst were among the four Merrill appellants whose fraud convictions were reversed. Neither employment at the same bank nor participation in the same transaction supplies a reason to replace these individual results with a collective label.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d158" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e252", "e251", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226", "e82" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-6b45041f8e1393d83c136b2f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Legal entities, deal mechanics and individual procedural outcomes are reconciled instead of treating every connection as shared culpability.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3", "s-d47", "s-d129", "s-d125", "s-d126", "s-d172", "s-d127", "s-d100", "s-d201", "s-d158" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e8", "e5", "e15", "e13", "e212", "e35", "e263", "e82", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226", "e252", "e251" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-2559e271828bb6002d2ce93c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The issuer identified in Enron’s 2000 annual filing was an Oregon corporation headquartered in Houston. Its registry history runs from New Falcon Corp. and Enron Oregon Corp. to Enron Corp. and, in 2007, Enron Creditors Recovery Corp. These identifiers anchor the historical case; they do not establish continuity with a later business using the same brand.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3", "s-d47" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-7ae797d0105d325f53b0d393", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The early-2001 executive roster places Kenneth Lay in the chair, Jeffrey Skilling as president and CEO, Andrew Fastow as CFO and Richard Causey as chief accounting officer. Kenneth Rice led Enron Broadband Services. The graph dates such positions and keeps them separate from the conduct and procedural outcomes attributed to each person.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e8", "e5", "e15", "e13", "e212" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-4e8c5abb4204e496a8fc18de", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The later proceedings cannot be reduced to a list of names linked to Enron. Skilling’s sentence was reduced while convictions remained; Lay’s convictions were vacated after his death. Andersen’s obstruction conviction was reversed and no retrial was reported. In the barge litigation, an insufficiency ruling for Fuhs, Kahanek’s acquittal and Brown’s surviving counts require different descriptions. The detailed pages explain those distinctions beside the events they qualify.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d129", "s-d125", "s-d126", "s-d172", "s-d127", "s-d100", "s-d201", "s-d158" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e8", "e7", "e35", "e263", "e82", "e248", "e250", "e225", "e226", "e252", "e251" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-f1799af339f55c6368f9ac63", "kind": "analysis", "text": "LJM1 began in June 1999. Fastow controlled LJM Partners LLC, the general partner of LJM Partners LP, which in turn was LJM1’s general partner. ERNB and Campsie supplied $7.5 million each as direct limited partners. The report associates them with CSFB and NatWest, but those banking-group connections should not replace the named legal vehicles in the ownership chain.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e80", "e77", "e41", "e78", "e79", "e43", "e244" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-1c4200e729099654080bbea3", "kind": "analysis", "text": "LJM2 followed in October with a separate general-partner chain: LJM2 Capital Management LP and its general partner, LJM2 Capital Management LLC. Fastow managed the LLC and held a limited interest in the LP alongside Kopper-managed Big Doe. The committee reported about fifty investors and $394 million in commitments, while warning that LJM2 had not supplied its records. Its list includes institutional investors and bank-affiliated entities; it does not establish a complete direct-investor or beneficial-ownership table.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e42", "e81", "e89", "e5", "e90", "e40", "e82", "e83", "e84", "e85", "e268", "e87", "e88", "e4003", "e4004", "e4005" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-7198b70ed7dc29a12ae2d47b", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The board authorised Fastow’s participation despite the tension between his duty as CFO and his partnership interests. Causey and Buy were to approve LJM2 transactions, and the audit committee was to review them annually. The fundraising document marketed Fastow’s access to Enron opportunities. Its inclusion of Glisan among day-to-day managers was disputed by Glisan, so it is not treated here as an uncontested appointment.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e15", "e14", "e34", "e42", "e40", "e69" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-d4a70360e99cd789211d56ae", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Formal separation did not eliminate operational overlap. Services agreements used Enron staff for administrative and investment tasks, with LJM paying compensation or allocated costs. The inquiry could not establish what was actually paid. At the same time, limited partners had investment-approval and removal rights. The committee therefore found no clear answer on consolidation based on managerial control alone. Kopper’s acquisition of Fastow’s interest in July 2001 also means the ownership picture changed over time.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e117", "e42", "e15", "e5", "e40", "e71", "e72", "e41" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-bd12efd360fddf1c22f2c683", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Powers report was a private inquiry, not a judgment obtained after compulsory discovery and trial. It lacked complete emails, workpapers and participation by several principal actors. Powers and Troubh alone assessed the board’s conduct; Troubh and Winokur alone assessed Vinson & Elkins. These limits matter when the report identifies deficiencies or describes disputed recollections. Multiple copies in the archive remain copies of the same investigation.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e74", "e115", "e34", "e267" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-53f4b7ca87e54c8c55cc9c77", "kind": "analysis", "text": "LJM2’s failure generated its own litigation. Creditors invoked a $47 million call, investors replaced the general partner and attempted to stop further calls, and the liquidating trust later sought $75 million. The 2004 Delaware decision allowed the claim past a motion to dismiss; it did not award those amounts. A separate 2003 remand returned a management dispute to Chancery without resolving the alleged misconduct. These proceedings should not be confused with Enron investors’ claims or an individual criminal conviction.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d25", "s-d122" ], "entity_ids": [ "e42", "e81", "e104", "e105", "e326" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-cb8e60c0a0cd3b451b8f23dc", "kind": "analysis", "text": "JEDI began as a jointly controlled partnership of Enron and CalPERS. When CalPERS exited for $383 million in 1997, Chewco became the replacement limited partner. Kopper controlled its original structure. The later arrangement placed SONR #1 above Chewco as general partner, Big River as limited partner and Little River above Big River; interests in the latter companies were transferred to Dodson. The report could not resolve every implication of those governance changes for accounting control.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e51", "e48", "e47", "e40", "e94", "e91", "e92", "e93" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-907f0500f6b75dd0206b3a4f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The written board presentation described an unaffiliated vehicle. The inquiry found no recorded disclosure of Kopper’s personal interest. Lay denied having been asked to approve it; Skilling said he had approved Kopper’s role and believed he had discussed it with the board. The committee distinguished these accounts from the missing written approval and from the code’s requirement for chairman-and-CEO consent.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e40", "e5", "e7", "e8" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-14032c06af435cdc806e5bfe", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The permanent structure used a $240 million Barclays loan guaranteed by Enron, a $132 million JEDI advance and about $11.5 million presented as equity. Almost all the apparent equity was itself financed by Barclays through Big River and Little River. JEDI then supplied $6.58 million of cash reserves pledged to support that financing. On the committee’s analysis, the capital was protected rather than genuinely exposed to loss, defeating the historical non-consolidation condition.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e49", "e48", "e91", "e92", "e40", "e93" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-b0dbc5ee4b9d91fbabc0a0b1", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The report did not establish why the defect had been missed. Andersen said it had not known of the collateral; Glisan likewise said he was unaware at closing. The committee could not confirm or disprove the auditor’s account. Once the collateral documents were reviewed in autumn 2001, Enron and Andersen agreed that Chewco and JEDI should have been consolidated from November 1997, prompting a restatement.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e49", "e48" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-bc9211f770d503ce3edc73b0", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Separate accounting questions concerned fees and Enron’s own shares. The committee questioned management and restructuring fees paid through Kopper’s structure, accelerated recognition of guarantee and management payments, and inconsistent recognition of gains and losses on Enron stock held by JEDI. The payment streams had different recipients and purposes; combining them into one undifferentiated loss would obscure the transactions.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e40", "e47", "e94", "e48", "e35" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-fc5ddecad3d68586805794ef", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The March 2001 buyout had a $35 million contractual price, but offsets and debt repayment left $3 million retained at closing, in addition to $7.5 million previously received. A $15 million unsecured loan remained linked to Osprey certificates. McMahon described proposing a much lower return; Fastow disputed involvement, and Skilling denied approving the amount. The committee could not identify the final decision-maker from direct evidence.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e48", "e40", "e93", "e76", "e233", "e5", "e8" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-1149d1ac6da97a92fc35b0f6", "kind": "analysis", "text": "An additional $2.6 million tax-indemnity payment in September raised a distinct concern because counsel said the agreement did not cover the buyout. Counsel attributed approval to a message from Fastow invoking Skilling. Skilling said he did not recall that discussion, and Fastow did not answer the committee’s questions. The contested attribution remains alongside the payment, rather than being converted into an unqualified finding against each person.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e47", "e40", "e5", "e8", "e171" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-47d81aafb005cf9036da9085", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Enron’s early Rhythms investment appreciated sharply after the IPO, but a lock-up limited its ability to sell. The solution put restricted Enron shares into a structure involving LJM1 and LJM Swap Sub, which wrote a put on the Rhythms holding. SwapCo was the general partner and LJM1 the limited partner. Because the protection depended substantially on Enron stock, a simultaneous fall in both companies’ shares could undermine it.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e41", "e54", "e4006", "e5", "e118" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-bfde94938bd586dc98726c23", "kind": "analysis", "text": "PwC provided a valuation fairness opinion on the initial exchange. That did not answer every accounting question. Andersen later acknowledged its capital-adequacy assessment was mistaken, and Enron announced retrospective consolidation that reduced its reported 1999 and 2000 income. The committee treated the economic weakness of the hedge and the failure of the outside-capital test as related but distinct issues.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e54", "e35", "e223" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-eceac49f308d3ab22efc388f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "In spring 2000 the parties ended the derivatives and returned Enron shares. The $16.7 million net transfer in the March letter reflected offsets against the $30 million negotiated amount. Causey signed for Enron and Fastow for Swap Sub and Southampton. The report found no fairness opinion for this unwind or record of board approval; Causey described a fairness assessment, Lay said he was unaware, and Skilling said he knew the Rhythms position was sold but not the unwind terms.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e54", "e5", "e15", "e119" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-a76334116e4642e2b0e680ac", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Southampton Place and Southampton LP are separate named vehicles in the documentation. Big Doe was general partner of Southampton Place; employee investors and the Fastow Family Foundation were limited partners. Southampton Place was in turn general partner of Southampton LP, identified as owner of Swap Sub’s limited interests and its general partner. The committee could not reconstruct the acquisition consideration. It did identify very large returns to the foundation, Glisan and Mordaunt, while preserving the employees’ explanations about their understanding of approvals and the investment.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e53", "e90", "e58", "e69", "e70", "e71", "e72", "e120", "e119", "e54", "e118", "e40", "e5", "e1" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-1757038428b3321c2bdceaef", "kind": "analysis", "text": "In November 2007, Mulgrew, Darby and Bermingham each pleaded guilty to wire fraud. They admitted secretly investing in Southampton while disposing of an asset for NatWest, concealing a personal interest from their employer. Their agreements called for 37 months each and approximately $7.3 million repayment to Royal Bank of Scotland. The retained announcement reports pleas and agreed terms, rather than a subsequent sentencing hearing. Their admissions do not make NatWest the perpetrator of the fraud against it.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d150" ], "entity_ids": [ "e241", "e242", "e243", "e244", "e119", "e5", "e40", "e4007" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-39195782f99e0f74c0a5bb7c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Talon, the first Raptor, joined Enron’s Harrier vehicle with a $30 million LJM2 contribution. Enron supplied far more of its financial capacity through a note and its own shares or share contracts. The arrangement placed a $41 million distribution to LJM2 ahead of the hedging activity. Once that distribution occurred, little independent capital remained exposed to losses. A separate legal company and a nominal outside contribution did not make the protection economically independent.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e52", "e95" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-5118f5130aa41fe383204016", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The committee also traced the dates of the trades. Derivatives negotiated in September were recorded as 3 August transactions, including an Avici hedge that offset a substantial intervening decline. It found no direct proof of why that date had been chosen. Zisman’s internal concerns are evidence of a disagreement among Enron lawyers; his qualified recollection should not become a claim that he knew every asset was impaired.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e52", "e8", "e15", "e14" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-54f239e02d9fc22504c3a594", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The legal names matter: Talon was Raptor I, Timberwolf Raptor II, Porcupine Raptor III and Bobcat Raptor IV. The retained subsidiary schedule identifies Harrier, Grizzly, Pronghorn and Roadrunner above them. Some board papers used a different numbering convention, so a reference to “Raptor III” cannot automatically be attached to Porcupine without checking the transaction.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d41" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e52", "e96", "e98", "e97", "e95", "e123", "e124", "e125", "e42" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-aa12802dcfbfcadce351e84c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Porcupine concentrated the circularity. It was supposed to hedge Enron’s investment in The New Power Company, yet its capacity depended on New Power warrants. LJM2 received $39.5 million shortly after contributing $30 million. Enron used a New Power swap to support roughly $370 million of gain, while the report says the $259 million note owed to Enron was omitted from both its books and the calculation of Porcupine’s available capacity.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e38", "e98", "e124", "e42", "e122" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-7bbe717090a04d04bda0a3aa", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The December cross-guarantee moved capacity between Raptors rather than importing a new independent source of value. A first-quarter 2001 shortfall of approximately $504 million led to a further restructuring. The committee questioned the retrospective effect of that transaction and the accounting for share restrictions and collars. Skilling disputed significant involvement in the December arrangements, and the record of Andersen advice itself changed when an October memorandum recorded earlier Chicago objections.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e52", "e96", "e98", "e97", "e35", "e8" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-cfa89bda46de9662dd17e05f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The September 2001 termination produced a $710 million pre-tax charge and a separate correction to equity. The $1.2 billion equity reduction included an earlier $1 billion overstatement, not just termination costs. Similarly, the report’s $1.077 billion comparison of earnings with and without the Raptors excludes the termination charge. These figures describe different accounting measurements; combining them as cash lost would misstate the evidence.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e5", "e40", "e35", "e52", "e96", "e97", "e98" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-3b679c3ba115a323925c0888", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Responsibility must be described at the level the evidence supports. Fastow negotiated the termination for Enron and Kopper for LJM2. The committee criticised Enron’s decisions and Andersen’s advice but was an internal inquiry with restricted access. Andersen’s separate obstruction conviction and its eventual reversal are addressed on the auditor page; that criminal outcome is not a ruling approving the Raptor accounting.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d127" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e5", "e40", "e35", "e74", "e115", "e34", "e267" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-0e37d3200e5d570e2ad66079", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Powers inquiry did not treat every LJM purchase as identical. It identified five repurchases among seven assets sold in late 1999 and profits for LJM in every transaction it examined. It also acknowledged that some repurchases had plausible innocent explanations. Fastow’s presentation claimed $229 million of resulting earnings, but the committee could not verify that calculation. The useful test is therefore the actual risk and commitments in each transaction.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e41", "e42", "e5" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-112b28179f2b6fffec1c6545", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Cuiabá illustrates why an unwritten promise would matter. Selling 13% of the project company to LJM1 allowed Enron to treat the project as outside its control and recognise gas-contract income. The later $14.4 million repurchase delivered LJM1 its maximum return despite project difficulties. One employee described a prior understanding that Enron would buy it back. Others pointed to board-quorum problems or misrepresentations in the original sale. The inquiry could not resolve those accounts; a proven make-whole undertaking would defeat the claimed independent risk.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e41", "e172", "e69", "e5", "e8" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-f3fdd320b5da774db34c8cb7", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The loan pool sold by Enron North America involved approximately $324 million of notes and equity. LJM2 took difficult-to-sell lower-ranking securities. A nearby loan from an unidentified Whitewing affiliate raised a question about whether LJM2 supplied independent funding, but the report could not establish that use of proceeds. The later record is clearer: Enron supplied a put option and ultimately repurchased notes and equity after the loans performed badly. The initial sale itself generated no accounting income because the loans were carried at fair value.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e68", "e42", "e37", "e52" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-27d035df415306ddd9ee9391", "kind": "analysis", "text": "At Nowa Sarzyna, a lender covenant made LJM2’s role temporary. A waiver of Enron’s minimum holding expired in March 2000; a plant malfunction and failure to find another buyer preceded the repurchase. MEGS also returned to Enron within months. McMahon’s recorded objection to the MEGS repurchase concerned its unproven economics, not a finding that every component of the original sale was fictitious.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e37", "e4008", "e233", "e4009" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-b05b050fde42457aa4e48d81", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Yosemite certificate transaction placed LJM2 briefly between Enron and Condor. The documents used December dates, while the committee identified an actual February circular transfer funded by Condor itself. That supported a $100,000 fee without lasting LJM2 exposure. Fastow’s intervention in the fee negotiation shows the conflict between his Enron and LJM roles; McMahon’s response and the lower final fee are also part of the record. This small transfer of certificates must not be confused with the much larger Yosemite financing programmes.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e42", "e37", "e204", "e4010", "e5", "e233" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-089c75f47e35593317055874", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The SEC described a repeating pattern in the prepays: commodity contracts appeared to move price risk between separate companies, but the combined swaps returned that risk to Enron. The economic result was an advance followed by repayment with a negotiated return. Citigroup’s ten transactions supplied $3.8 billion over time, while Chase’s seven supplied approximately $2.6 billion. Neither number is the amount outstanding on one balance-sheet date.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56", "s-d55", "s-d9001" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e176", "e204", "e83", "e50", "e173", "e174" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-1efbfcafff6a8ea5dad99e10", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The intermediaries had specific roles. Delta was a Citigroup-sponsored vehicle; the SEC complaint described two distinct Mahonia companies controlled by Chase. Yosemite financing helped fund Citigroup prepays and should not be added again as unrelated borrowing. In Nahanni, selling Treasury bills contributed through a financed partnership produced operating cash in Enron’s consolidated statements, even though the arrangement was a financing structure.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56", "s-d55", "s-d9001" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e176", "e204", "e182", "e183", "e83", "e50", "e173", "e174" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-3213eb569d9b8cf596c99a46", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The SEC cases did not remain unresolved complaints. Chase agreed to $135 million and an injunction in July 2003 without admitting or denying the allegations. Citigroup’s settled order required $101.25 million specifically for Enron conduct, also without admission or denial; its separate Dynegy component must not be assigned to Enron. Those outcomes qualify the description of the underlying conduct.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d9001", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e83", "e46", "e175" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-2f72961307d2478d8367c997", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Fishtail paired Enron North America with Annapurna in equal voting interests. Annapurna’s side combined $8 million of LJM2 cash and a $42 million Chase commitment. That commitment was not immediate paid-in cash. The Senate inquiry also questioned the valuation of Enron’s contribution, including intangible assets valued by a Chase affiliate. The parties’ claim of third-party valuation is preserved alongside that criticism.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e68", "e42", "e217", "e218", "e50", "e4011" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-8154b0c987552da4e7eecf07", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Bacchus then placed an interest in the paper assets with Caymus. Its $194 million debt and $6 million apparent outside equity produced $200 million for Enron and a $112 million accounting gain. The SEC found that Enron’s oral protection and the swaps left the economic risk with Enron. FleetBoston’s Long Lane vehicle held the apparent equity while Citigroup bore that exposure. Formal ownership and economic risk were different.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d56", "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e184", "e219", "e217" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-bcc4d34a7e19ff6b758a52ea", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Sundance later combined the paper assets in a larger joint venture and repaid the earlier financing. The Senate report criticised contractual safeguards that protected Citigroup and described internal disagreement about the accounting and approvals. Citigroup’s termination shortly before Enron’s bankruptcy recovered its $28.5 million cash-and-share contribution plus a return and cancelled an unfunded $160 million commitment. The report’s findings are not a separate criminal judgment against the bank or its advisers.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e220", "e217", "e184", "e171" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-e1b84956c82723d87a61ba9f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Slapshot surrounded a real $375 million syndicated loan with circular transfers and offsetting obligations that supported larger claimed Canadian interest deductions. The chain ran through Flagstaff, Dutch holding companies, CPS and Canadian subsidiaries. The report records $124.9 million gross deductions claimed, not that amount of tax saved. Counsel’s supporting opinions also warned about challenge and litigation, and Enron later stopped claiming further benefits.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d79" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e50", "e83", "e221", "e222", "e220", "e4007", "e4012", "e4013", "e4014", "e4015", "e4016", "e4017" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-204acdd069f46b8ae903428f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Merrill’s SEC case concerned the Nigerian barges and energy options. Its $80 million corporate settlement was entered without admission or denial. The options were unwound before scheduled trading began for a reduced fee. Individual barge defendants had different criminal outcomes, including acquittals, reversals and surviving counts; the corporate settlement cannot stand in for any individual’s result.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d120" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e82", "e75", "e46", "e225", "e226", "e227", "e228" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-d4523f5cb4ecd1ca5fe3c915", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Backbone involved more than one sale. The first transfer placed dark-fibre rights with an LJM2-controlled company; later trust financing allowed LJM2 to exit; Enron then repurchased the rights and exchanged them with Qwest. The examiner saw evidence of continuing Enron control and risk and considered a loan characterisation possible. That was an examiner’s analysis, not a final court order recovering the stated proceeds.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e212", "e42", "e213", "e216", "e101", "e102", "e4018", "e4019", "e4020", "e4021", "e4022" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-66ad10db2dce9e3f29ee628b", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The funding chain also explains the role of a nominal service-provider investment. Backbone Trust II’s sole beneficial interest was issued for $1,000 to BSCS XXIII, owned and operated by Lord Securities. ABN and Fleet provided the substantial debt financing. The small beneficial interest does not justify treating Lord’s unrelated later clients as participants in Enron, nor does the business-service relationship itself establish wrongdoing.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117", "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e212", "e42", "e213", "e216", "e101", "e102", "e4018", "e4019", "e4020", "e4021", "e4022" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-077f638aa8ea81a4b7f31740", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Cerberus monetised an EOG share block while separating control from economics. Asset Holdings kept all Aeneas voting power and a tiny economic interest; Heracles acquired nearly all economic rights through Psyche. RBC was the ultimate holder of the $517.5 million financing. Swaps, puts and Enron guarantees then kept substantial risk within the Enron group, which is why the examiner questioned whether a true sale had occurred.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e205", "e206", "e209", "e211", "e210", "e207", "e208", "e68", "e4023", "e4024" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-05aad05c6e97437d3918f148", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The January restructuring changed the economic exposure through Rabobank–RBC and Rabobank–Enron arrangements. It was not simply a registered assignment of a loan, and it did not by itself prove the earlier accounting was valid. The 99.99% and 0.01% figures describe Aeneas economic interests, while the transferred asset was an 11.5 million-share EOG block. Keeping those denominators separate prevents a misleading ownership graph.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d59" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e205", "e206", "e209", "e211", "e210", "e207", "e208", "e68", "e4023", "e4024" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-fd0a52632ce487102952ca85", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Nikita concerned Enron’s package of EOTT limited interests, described as 36% of outstanding limited-partnership interests. That dated position should not be converted into an undated claim about complete EOTT control. Whitewing likewise needs separate layers: Peregrine and Blue Herron appear in the subsidiary schedule, while LJM’s Osprey certificates represent investments linked to that structure. Certificate ownership is not equivalent to owning every underlying company.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d59", "s-d117", "s-d41" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e36", "e121", "e37", "e127", "e42", "e76" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-cdae7a0dbfd8e5b0cedd98c7", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The tax staff’s testimony distinguished operating foreign businesses from inactive shells and described most Cayman entities as largely irrelevant for tax purposes. Its tax-return totals were before audit adjustments and applied to specified periods. Those limits prevent a company count, offshore address or zero-tax year from becoming a substitute for evidence about a particular transaction.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d301" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-b097a0256ce1c3126eb25237", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The March 2001 signatures identify the board and financial officers, but do not assign equal knowledge or culpability to everyone listed. Leadership changed during the collapse: Skilling resigned in August, Lay resumed CEO duties, and the subsequent restructuring brought McMahon and Cooper into different roles. The graph keeps those periods visible.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3", "s-d166", "s-d241", "s-d245" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e8", "e15", "e5", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e23", "e24", "e25", "e26", "e27", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e31", "e32", "e33", "e34", "e233", "e229" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-3f610077bf6be98b85568cf7", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Ownership figures also need their class labels. Janus’s 5.43% concerned common shares; the larger percentages shown for several individuals concerned convertible preferred stock and included specified family, trust or conversion interests. The filing is a dated beneficial-ownership disclosure, not a complete map of personal wealth or ultimate control.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e59", "e60", "e20", "e61", "e62" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-85f8eb442f41d402096e9846", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The proxy disclosed consulting, travel, equipment and commodity relationships, while asserting that commercial terms were comparable to outside arrangements. Those connections explain potential governance questions but do not prove misconduct. Winokur’s NATCO Group directorship, fund-management role and National Tank affiliation must not be collapsed into a fictitious directorship of the operating supplier.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e32", "e33", "e63", "e64", "e65", "e34", "e66", "e67", "e68", "e166", "e167", "e253", "e168" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-b17e2f3c5727a2863409bce4", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Powers and Troubh concluded that the LJM conflict overwhelmed controls that were both extensive and inadequately applied. Causey and Buy were assigned reviews; committees were given oversight duties; later representations added Skilling and audit trails. The inquiry found incomplete lists, brief reviews and missing signatures. It also said significant information was withheld, found no director financial interest in the partnerships and recognised the board’s entitlement to rely on competent advisers.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e15", "e14", "e8", "e5", "e34", "e26", "e35" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-d795c619f539ce5e2a0bdd0e", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The directors disputed the resulting governance judgment. Winokur described a good-faith decision intended to provide flexible capital, supported by management and outside advice. He blamed concealment and failures to report noncompliance; Jaedicke likewise defended reliance on advisers. Those responses do not erase the criticism, but neither should the criticism be presented as an uncontested criminal finding about every director.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d241", "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e34", "e26", "e35", "e171", "e15", "e14", "e8", "e5" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-9b48e1b7d11f737e0d918dbd", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Watkins’s August warning led to a preliminary V&E review. Its scope deliberately excluded reassessing Andersen’s accounting and detailed examination of individual transactions. V&E saw no need for a wider independent inquiry on the facts it gathered, while recognising serious publicity and litigation risk. Lay and Derrick said familiar lawyers could work quickly and determine whether further investigation was necessary.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e16", "e171", "e35", "e4025" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-f2bdd1a45b732348dc9a6141", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The later Powers report considered several of Watkins’s concerns justified, while distinguishing them from errors in some underlying details. It criticised the review’s narrow design and reliance on senior people involved in the matters under examination. That is a more precise conclusion than saying the warning was ignored altogether or that a limited legal review conclusively cleared the transactions.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d117" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e7", "e16", "e171", "e35", "e4025" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-7d920ab2b3227e809bf7642d", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The early Newby rulings let several investor claims proceed, dismissed others and differentiated statutory theories. By June 2006 all Deutsche Bank claims had been dismissed and Section 12 claims failed for want of a representative with standing. These are meaningful outcomes, while the claims that survived still needed proof.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d131", "s-d151" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e186", "e175", "e83", "e232", "e43", "e82", "e268", "e265", "e270", "e269", "e171", "e35", "e245" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-20c02014adbc3d29e2f6acb2", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The 2007 Fifth Circuit decision changed the class case against Credit Suisse, Merrill and Barclays. It reversed certification and remanded because the majority rejected the asserted presumptions of market reliance. Judge Dennis agreed with reversal for different class-certification reasons and disputed the majority’s restrictive liability analysis. This was not a criminal acquittal, nor a ruling that every transaction was sound or every claim against every bank disappeared.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d9002" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e43", "e82", "e232", "e245" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-4d4f4cf9ecc6bd9621a7e002", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Citigroup’s $2 billion and JPMorgan’s $2.2 billion Newby announcements concerned investor claims and still required approvals when issued. Both denied wrongdoing or admitted none, explaining the agreements as a way to end prolonged litigation. Their public announcements alone should not be described as proof that every investor had already received money.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d152", "s-d157" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175", "e83", "e245" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-9a4c563abd71b4f6b333d924", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Citi’s later $1.66 billion agreement was with the bankruptcy estate, accompanied by releases and treatment of credit-linked-note claims. Allowing approximately $2.4 billion of creditor claims is not another cash payment of that size. The estate agreement was separate from the investor case and, according to Citi’s announcement, required bankruptcy approval.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d159" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e175" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-eb7f708f6e878302ba48a88c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The reported outside-director settlement also needs its allocation: eighteen participants, but ten described as making personal payments totalling $13 million within a $168 million proposed resolution. It would be wrong to assign a personal payment to every named director or treat the agreement as an adjudicated finding of guilt.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d206" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e23", "e24", "e25", "e26", "e27", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e31", "e32", "e33", "e34", "e193", "e224" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-43650104b01962c97cc43b2c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Other retained decisions are narrower than their case titles suggest. Milbank obtained dismissal while Goldman’s pleading motion failed and amendment was allowed. Azurix investors lost their appeal on the particular pleading and statutory deficiencies identified by the court. Hewitt lost claims for contractual indemnification of its own conduct; that did not dispose of every pension case.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d88", "s-d242", "s-d135" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e237", "e238", "e239", "e168", "e234" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-49dff0281c0f5a271c472e33", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Alliance Capital’s case illustrates why a network connection must carry its outcome. Reporting records a jury rejecting Florida’s claims concerning its Enron investment losses. Florida disagreed, Alliance claimed vindication, and a prior agreement removed payment on the counterclaim and appeal. A disclosed Alliance role held by an Enron director is context, not grounds to suppress that result.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d14", "s-d266" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e161", "e31" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-ec3296704d4c99c6dcd61cb0", "kind": "analysis", "text": "CIBC’s reported $2.4 billion investor agreement is an essential qualification to earlier descriptions of the claims against it. The bank admitted no wrongdoing, and the report specified approvals still needed. The same care applies to the staff cases: McMahon’s announced settlement remained subject to approval, while the Lynn and Castleman consent judgments had been entered. Their payment amounts, waivers and bars differ, and none is converted here into a criminal conviction.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d212", "s-d254", "s-d255" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e186", "e245", "e233", "e71", "e4032", "e46", "e172" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-25cc651ebd1fa13f77b21213", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Chapter 11 began in December 2001 and later encompassed 180 related entities according to the SEC’s 2005 order. That count should not be assigned to the first filing day. Portland General Electric and many operating businesses did not file simply because the parent did. The plan confirmed in July 2004 and effective that November called for Enron to hold and sell assets and manage litigation, not resume its former operating business.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166", "s-d213" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e129", "e68", "e212" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-513e72967d45cb4a7ec8cf9a", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The old common and four preferred-share classes were cancelled. The new equity was placed into trusts, with former investors receiving conditional non-voting interests. A distribution depended on assets exceeding allowed claims, described as highly unlikely in the order. This structure did not preserve the old listed shares or guarantee shareholders a recovery.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e259", "e229", "e4026", "e4027" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-d3928388216f9bff9bf76f34", "kind": "analysis", "text": "CrossCountry’s sale is documented as completed: CCE acquired all equity in November 2004 for approximately $2.1 billion net cash. Its pipeline portfolio included interests in Transwestern, Citrus and Northern Plains. The CCE partnership linked Southern Union with GE’s energy-financing business; the transaction price was not a valuation of everything Enron owned.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e257", "e258", "e4031", "e4028", "e202", "e4029", "e4030" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-99666673584654dfe7c7f528", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Prisma’s non-US utility portfolio left Enron in stages during 2006. The first stage transferred 24.26% of votes but 49% of economics; the second transferred the remainder. Prisma survived the later amalgamation with AEIL and ultimately became AEI. Distinguishing the buyer from the surviving company avoids an invented extra ownership tier or duplicated sale.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166", "s-d193" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e230", "e264", "e278" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-194e20f0103b239644ac66de", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The July 2005 order still placed all Portland General Electric voting shares with Enron and said the utility was outside bankruptcy. This dossier presents that dated fact without converting earlier proposed sales into completed deals or asserting present ownership. The retained Oregon registry then records a December 2009 merger into Enron Dissolution Corp. That is a specific legal succession, not proof that a later reuse of the Enron name revived the historical issuer.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d166", "s-d222", "s-d48" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e129", "e113" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-c1d8580d0a5d733ba8e3127c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The $10 billion figure in the initial Dynegy dispute was Enron’s demand. The later reported court-approved resolution was $25 million plus release of escrow funds. Dynegy had asserted contractual breaches and defended its pipeline rights. Describing only the original claim would leave the reader with the wrong scale and procedural outcome.", "qualification": "", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d213", "s-d214" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e180", "e179" ] } ], "sources": [ { "id": "s-d3", "title": "Company statement source · s-d3", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d14", "title": "Company statement source · s-d14", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d25", "title": "Court record source · s-d25", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d41", "title": "Company statement source · s-d41", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d47", "title": "Corporate registry concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "Oregon Secretary of State", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://egov.sos.state.or.us/br/pkg_web_name_srch_inq.show_detl?p_be_rsn=695848&p_srce=BR_INQ&p_print=FALSE" }, { "id": "s-d48", "title": "Corporate registry concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "Oregon Secretary of State", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://egov.sos.state.or.us/br/pkg_web_name_srch_inq_merger.login?p_btr_rsn=4223704&p_srce=BR_INQ&p_print=FALSE" }, { "id": "s-d55", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/comp18252.htm" }, { "id": "s-d56", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/administrative-proceedings/34-48230" }, { "id": "s-d59", "title": "Court record source · s-d59", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d79", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Government Publishing Office", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CPRT-107SPRT83559/html/CPRT-107SPRT83559.htm" }, { "id": "s-d88", "title": "Court record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Government Publishing Office", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txsd-4_04-cv-00088/pdf/USCOURTS-txsd-4_04-cv-00088-1.pdf" }, { "id": "s-d100", "title": "Media source · s-d100", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d117", "title": "Company statement source · s-d117", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d120", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2003-32-sec-charges-merrill-lynch-four-merrill-lynch-executives-aiding-abetting-enron-accounting-fraud" }, { "id": "s-d122", "title": "Court record source · s-d122", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d123", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2006/September/06_crm_647.html" }, { "id": "s-d125", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2006/May/06_crm_328.html" }, { "id": "s-d126", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2006/October/06_crm_723.html" }, { "id": "s-d127", "title": "Court record source · s-d127", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d128", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2003/September/03_crm_492.htm" }, { "id": "s-d129", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/former-enron-ceo-jeffrey-skilling-resentenced-168-months-fraud-conspiracy-charges" }, { "id": "s-d130", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2006/November/06_crm_763.html" }, { "id": "s-d131", "title": "Court record source · s-d131", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d133", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/news/press/2004-6.htm" }, { "id": "s-d135", "title": "Court record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Government Publishing Office", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txsd-4_01-cv-03913/pdf/USCOURTS-txsd-4_01-cv-03913-8.pdf" }, { "id": "s-d149", "title": "Court record source · s-d149", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d150", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2007/November/07_crm_949.html" }, { "id": "s-d151", "title": "Court record source · s-d151", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d152", "title": "Company statement source · s-d152", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d156", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2004/May/04_crm_306.htm" }, { "id": "s-d157", "title": "Company statement source · s-d157", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d158", "title": "Court record source · s-d158", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d159", "title": "Company statement source · s-d159", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d160", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/criminal/criminal-vns/case/united-states-v-michael-kopper" }, { "id": "s-d166", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/files/divisions/investment/opur/filing/35-28009.pdf" }, { "id": "s-d172", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/criminal/criminal-vns/case/united-states-v-kenneth-l-lay" }, { "id": "s-d193", "title": "Company statement source · s-d193", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d201", "title": "Media source · s-d201", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d206", "title": "Media source · s-d206", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d212", "title": "Media source · s-d212", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d213", "title": "Company statement source · s-d213", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d214", "title": "Media source · s-d214", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d222", "title": "Corporate registry concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "Oregon Secretary of State", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://egov.sos.state.or.us/br/pkg_web_name_srch_inq_merger.login?p_btr_rsn=11495047&p_srce=BR_INQ&p_print=FALSE" }, { "id": "s-d241", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Government Publishing Office", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-107hhrg77987/pdf/CHRG-107hhrg77987.pdf" }, { "id": "s-d242", "title": "Court record source · s-d242", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d245", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/enron/exhibit/02-02/BBC-0001/ocr/EXH023-00160^FullText.TXT" }, { "id": "s-d252", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Department of Justice", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2007/June/07_crm_433.html" }, { "id": "s-d254", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr-20225" }, { "id": "s-d255", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-20159" }, { "id": "s-d266", "title": "Media source · s-d266", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d301", "title": "Other source · s-d301", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d303", "title": "Other source · s-d303", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d9001", "title": "Regulatory record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Securities and Exchange Commission", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-18252" }, { "id": "s-d9002", "title": "Court record concerning Enron or an identified participant", "publisher": "US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original passage", "basis": "Original retained privately. Allegations, party accounts and procedural decisions retain their specific evidentiary status.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/06/06-20856-CV0.wpd.pdf" } ], "atlas": { "version": "1.0", "reference": "dudil-report-assembler/2.19.0", "default_view": "target_overview", "hypotheses_default": true, "path_policy": "evidence_first", "context_entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e7", "e8", "e35", "e40" ] }, "case_id": "enron", "version": "2026-10-14", "as_of": "2026-10-08" }