{ "schema_version": "1.0", "target_id": "e1", "language": "en", "nodes": [ { "id": "e1", "name": "OW Capital Management GmbH", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "subject", "claim_ids": [ "c-accounts", "c-bcl-financing", "c-ena-history", "c-identity", "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-kvbz-confiscation", "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-masz", "c-overview-company", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-portfolio", "c-role-1", "c-role-103", "c-role-19", "c-role-2", "c-role-20", "c-role-26", "c-role-265", "c-role-27", "c-role-28", "c-role-286", "c-role-287", "c-role-288", "c-role-289", "c-role-29", "c-role-291", "c-role-30", "c-role-31", "c-role-32", "c-role-33", "c-role-34", "c-role-387", "c-role-72", "c-role-73", "c-role-74", "c-role-76", "c-role-82", "c-role-86", "c-role-96", "c-ukraine-sanctions", "c-zmk-share-issue", "c-zmk-wagon-contract" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "at" }, { "id": "e3", "name": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-accounts", "c-ena-history", "c-historic-companies", "c-identity", "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-overview-company", "c-role-111", "c-role-13", "c-role-14", "c-role-147", "c-role-15", "c-role-16", "c-role-17", "c-role-2", "c-role-231", "c-role-350", "c-role-53", "c-role-61", "c-role-62", "c-role-63", "c-role-64", "c-role-86", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e5", "name": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "leadership", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-confiscation-grounds", "c-elz-liability", "c-historic-companies", "c-identity", "c-inter-cargo", "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-kvbz-confiscation", "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-overview-company", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-portfolio", "c-railcar-claim", "c-role-1", "c-role-10", "c-role-101", "c-role-103", "c-role-11", "c-role-12", "c-role-153", "c-role-154", "c-role-155", "c-role-18", "c-role-196", "c-role-258", "c-role-263", "c-role-272", "c-role-28", "c-role-286", "c-role-289", "c-role-326", "c-role-35", "c-role-387", "c-role-4", "c-role-408", "c-role-409", "c-role-416", "c-role-5", "c-role-6", "c-role-7", "c-role-8", "c-role-83", "c-role-89", "c-role-90", "c-role-97", "c-ukraine-sanctions", "c-vnv-release", "c-zmk-share-issue", "c-zmk-wagon-contract" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e6", "name": "Negocianttrans LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-role-13", "c-role-15", "c-role-4" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e7", "name": "SK Khiminvest LLC (OGRN 1057746838973)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-5", "c-role-59", "c-role-8" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e8", "name": "Dagmos LLP (liquidated)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-6" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e9", "name": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-confiscation-grounds", "c-elz-sale-and-close", "c-inter-cargo", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-railcar-claim", "c-role-100", "c-role-131", "c-role-203", "c-role-204", "c-role-205", "c-role-220", "c-role-221", "c-role-222", "c-role-223", "c-role-224", "c-role-232", "c-role-240", "c-role-246", "c-role-259", "c-role-326", "c-role-35", "c-role-7", "c-role-85", "c-three-locomotive-entities", "c-ukraine-sanctions" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e10", "name": "Trading House RusUkrVagon CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-10", "c-role-226", "c-role-89" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e11", "name": "Ural Railway Company CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-11", "c-role-228", "c-role-90" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e12", "name": "Tyubing Centrolit LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-12", "c-role-229", "c-role-230" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e13", "name": "New Investments CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-126", "c-role-127", "c-role-128", "c-role-129", "c-role-14", "c-role-315", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e14", "name": "Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-16", "c-role-182", "c-role-184", "c-role-186", "c-role-217", "c-role-61", "c-role-91", "c-role-93", "c-role-94" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e15", "name": "Khimresurs Plus CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-124", "c-role-137", "c-role-138", "c-role-17", "c-role-328", "c-role-329", "c-role-330", "c-role-331", "c-role-62" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e16", "name": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-confiscation-grounds", "c-historic-companies", "c-masz", "c-overview-company", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-portfolio", "c-role-115", "c-role-116", "c-role-117", "c-role-118", "c-role-119", "c-role-173", "c-role-18", "c-role-19", "c-role-21", "c-role-218", "c-role-22", "c-role-23", "c-role-24", "c-role-247", "c-role-25", "c-role-275", "c-role-287", "c-role-288", "c-role-290", "c-role-291", "c-role-30", "c-role-306", "c-role-308", "c-role-40", "c-role-41", "c-role-42", "c-role-43", "c-role-47", "c-role-48", "c-role-49", "c-role-52", "c-role-53", "c-role-54", "c-role-55", "c-role-56", "c-role-70", "c-role-76", "c-role-83", "c-role-84", "c-role-97", "c-role-zmk-mosregiontrans", "c-zmk-business", "c-zmk-share-issue", "c-zmk-wagon-contract" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e17", "name": "MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-masz", "c-overview-company", "c-portfolio", "c-role-142", "c-role-143", "c-role-144", "c-role-145", "c-role-146", "c-role-20", "c-role-234", "c-role-36", "c-role-72", "c-role-82" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "hu" }, { "id": "e18", "name": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-ena-history", "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-professional-services", "c-role-190", "c-role-197", "c-role-21", "c-role-247", "c-role-274", "c-role-275", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e19", "name": "Gorelov Igor Mikhaylovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-22", "c-role-381", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e20", "name": "Krivoshein Mikhail Aleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-23", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e21", "name": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-119", "c-role-120", "c-role-24", "c-role-305", "c-role-47", "c-role-70", "c-role-71", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e22", "name": "Ulyanov Igor Vladimirovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-159", "c-role-25", "c-role-46", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e23", "name": "Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-confiscation-grounds", "c-kvbz-confiscation", "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-overview-company", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-portfolio", "c-role-26", "c-role-260", "c-role-261", "c-role-262", "c-role-263", "c-role-264", "c-role-272", "c-role-274", "c-role-29", "c-role-395", "c-role-400", "c-role-402", "c-role-410", "c-role-415", "c-role-422", "c-role-77", "c-role-80", "c-role-81", "c-role-96", "c-vnv-release" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ua" }, { "id": "e24", "name": "Ministry of Justice of Ukraine", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-confiscation", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-railcar-claim", "c-role-100", "c-role-27" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e25", "name": "ENA JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-confiscation-grounds", "c-ena-history", "c-historic-companies", "c-overview-company", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-portfolio", "c-role-110", "c-role-111", "c-role-112", "c-role-113", "c-role-114", "c-role-141", "c-role-190", "c-role-191", "c-role-192", "c-role-193", "c-role-194", "c-role-195", "c-role-235", "c-role-236", "c-role-237", "c-role-238", "c-role-239", "c-role-250", "c-role-31", "c-role-333", "c-role-335", "c-role-336", "c-role-337", "c-role-338", "c-role-339", "c-role-340", "c-role-341", "c-role-342", "c-role-343", "c-role-344", "c-role-345", "c-role-346", "c-role-347", "c-role-348", "c-role-349", "c-role-350", "c-role-351", "c-role-352", "c-role-353", "c-role-354", "c-role-355", "c-role-360", "c-role-361", "c-role-57", "c-role-64", "c-role-65", "c-role-66", "c-role-67", "c-role-68", "c-role-69", "c-role-73" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e26", "name": "Balakovo-Centrolit JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-confiscation-grounds", "c-overview-company", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-portfolio", "c-role-116", "c-role-139", "c-role-154", "c-role-158", "c-role-230", "c-role-296", "c-role-32", "c-role-33", "c-role-58", "c-role-74", "c-role-bcl-other-half" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e27", "name": "Fofasio Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-offshore-limits", "c-overview-company", "c-portfolio", "c-role-34", "c-role-379", "c-role-380", "c-role-392" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e28", "name": "Gamzalov Dzhakhpar (Hungarian directory identity)", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-masz", "c-professional-services", "c-role-142", "c-role-143", "c-role-234", "c-role-36" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e29", "name": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-319", "c-role-320", "c-role-321", "c-role-322", "c-role-323", "c-role-324", "c-role-336", "c-role-371", "c-role-383", "c-role-40", "c-role-56", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e30", "name": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-professional-services", "c-role-110", "c-role-349", "c-role-351", "c-role-360", "c-role-41", "c-role-49", "c-role-54", "c-role-65", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e31", "name": "Murtazaliev Gadzhi Omarovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-inter-cargo", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-223", "c-role-240", "c-role-241", "c-role-348", "c-role-42", "c-three-locomotive-entities", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e32", "name": "Nersesyan Valentin Robertovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-professional-services", "c-role-198", "c-role-316", "c-role-43", "c-role-55", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e33", "name": "RKK JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-46" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e34", "name": "Rayvel Audit Company LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-195", "c-role-276", "c-role-277", "c-role-278", "c-role-338", "c-role-48", "c-role-69", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e35", "name": "Ageev Andrey Aleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-52", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e36", "name": "Zubov Stepan Sergeevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-professional-services", "c-role-141", "c-role-192", "c-role-354", "c-role-57" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e37", "name": "Mishin Nikita Viktorovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-professional-services", "c-role-139", "c-role-140", "c-role-58" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e38", "name": "Taratenko Aleksandr Aleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-role-59" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e39", "name": "Elit-Trans LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-231", "c-role-63" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e40", "name": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-ena-history", "c-first-locomotive", "c-professional-services", "c-role-113", "c-role-295", "c-role-296", "c-role-297", "c-role-298", "c-role-353", "c-role-66" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e41", "name": "Antropov Anton Gennadevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-role-191", "c-role-67" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e42", "name": "Sheverdov Gleb Vyacheslavovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-role-114", "c-role-193", "c-role-68" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e43", "name": "Privolzhsky Testing Centre LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-120", "c-role-305", "c-role-306", "c-role-71" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e45", "name": "Maksym Viktorovych Kramarenko", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-400", "c-role-401", "c-role-77" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e46", "name": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-264", "c-role-266", "c-role-268", "c-role-271", "c-role-402", "c-role-403", "c-role-404", "c-role-405", "c-role-406", "c-role-411", "c-role-417", "c-role-80" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e47", "name": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-267", "c-role-269", "c-role-270", "c-role-395", "c-role-396", "c-role-397", "c-role-398", "c-role-406", "c-role-412", "c-role-81" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e48", "name": "Viktor Nikitenko", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-290", "c-role-84", "c-zmk-share-issue" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e50", "name": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-122", "c-role-123", "c-role-124", "c-role-186", "c-role-256", "c-role-257", "c-role-328", "c-role-91" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e51", "name": "Savin Evgeniy Aleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-184", "c-role-93" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e52", "name": "Geoplant LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-94" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e55", "name": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-elz-sale-and-close", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-101", "c-role-106", "c-role-107", "c-role-108", "c-role-109", "c-role-196", "c-role-197", "c-role-198", "c-role-199", "c-role-200", "c-role-201", "c-role-202", "c-role-206", "c-role-210", "c-role-232", "c-role-233", "c-role-279", "c-role-280", "c-role-281", "c-role-282", "c-role-283", "c-role-284", "c-role-285", "c-role-85", "c-role-elz-veb-memorandum", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e56", "name": "Gart Marina Gennadievna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-106", "c-zmk-share-issue" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e57", "name": "Volkam Trading Ltd", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-107", "c-role-201", "c-role-233", "c-role-281", "c-role-283" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e58", "name": "Rafelar Holdings Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-108", "c-role-200", "c-role-280", "c-role-282" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e59", "name": "VEB-Leasing Europe S.a.r.l.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-109" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e60", "name": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-112", "c-role-179", "c-role-180", "c-role-189", "c-role-347", "c-role-352" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e61", "name": "ZMK-Trans JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-115", "c-role-169", "c-role-170" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e62", "name": "PESA Saratov CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-117", "c-role-172", "c-role-173", "c-role-175" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e63", "name": "Uralvagonzavod Research and Production Corporation JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-118", "c-zmk-business" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e64", "name": "Maris CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-122", "c-role-257" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e65", "name": "Resurs Invest CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-123", "c-role-256" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e66", "name": "Engels Locomotive Plant LLC (2023)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-126", "c-role-131", "c-role-133", "c-role-134", "c-role-241", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e67", "name": "Innovative Transport Laboratory LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-127" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e68", "name": "Zolotukhina Olga Sergeevna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-128" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e69", "name": "Borisov Sergey Aleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-129" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e70", "name": "Pankov Ivan Anatolevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-133", "c-role-202", "c-role-209", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e71", "name": "Eleeva Olga Vladimirovna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-134", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e72", "name": "Volokhov Vitaliy Andreevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-137", "c-role-329" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e73", "name": "Kazan State Gunpowder Plant", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-138" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e74", "name": "Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-historic-companies", "c-role-140", "c-role-153", "c-role-158", "c-role-159", "c-role-160", "c-role-161", "c-role-162", "c-role-163", "c-role-165", "c-role-258" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e75", "name": "Rasul Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-144", "c-role-166", "c-role-167", "c-role-168", "c-role-303" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e76", "name": "Vladimir Petrovich Martiukov", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-masz", "c-professional-services", "c-role-145" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e77", "name": "Ivan Alekseevich Vasyukov", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-masz", "c-professional-services", "c-role-146" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e78", "name": "Bargo Steel Ltd", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-role-147", "c-role-151", "c-role-177" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "gb" }, { "id": "e80", "name": "First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-first-locomotive", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-246", "c-role-284", "c-role-294", "c-role-295", "c-role-297" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e81", "name": "Juliette Michel Clarisse", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-irina-and-bargo", "c-role-151", "c-role-177" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e83", "name": "Khimresurs CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-155" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e87", "name": "I.T.L. and Finance Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-161" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e88", "name": "Melnichenko Vasiliy Vladimirovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-162" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e89", "name": "Gruzd Boris Dmitrievich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-163", "c-role-208", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e90", "name": "Varnavskiy Aleksandr Nikolaevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-165" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e91", "name": "Rus-Al LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-166", "c-role-303", "c-role-304" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e92", "name": "Stroindustriya JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-167", "c-role-168", "c-role-212" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e93", "name": "Repetek LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-169" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e94", "name": "Korzunov Viktor Valerevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-170" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e95", "name": "Konoplev Sergey Georgievich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-172" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e96", "name": "Rail Vehicles PESA Bydgoszcz SA", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-175" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e97", "name": "Metpromgrupp LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-179", "c-role-215", "c-role-216", "c-role-217", "c-role-218", "c-role-228" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e98", "name": "Lokolizing LLP (Kazakhstan)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-180", "c-role-189" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e99", "name": "Eliseev Konstantin Vasilevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-182" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e100", "name": "GS Finance & Trusts SIA", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-160" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e101", "name": "Gamzalov Roman Askhabovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-187", "c-role-188" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e102", "name": "Irtysh Capital LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-187" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e103", "name": "SKL LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-188" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e104", "name": "Grekov Andrey Sergeevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-194" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e105", "name": "Raydugin Vyacheslav Ivanovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-199" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e106", "name": "Dowden Investments Ltd", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-inter-cargo", "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-203", "c-role-222" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e107", "name": "Reva Sergey Nikolaevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-inter-cargo", "c-role-204", "c-role-221" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e108", "name": "Nemirko Viktor Mikhaylovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-inter-cargo", "c-role-205", "c-role-220", "c-role-243" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e109", "name": "Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-206", "c-role-208", "c-role-209", "c-role-210", "c-role-259", "c-role-309", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e110", "name": "Melnik Denis Evgenevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-212" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e111", "name": "Akhapkina Natalya Valerevna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-215" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e112", "name": "Sultanov Pavel Viktorovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-216", "c-role-333", "c-role-358" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e113", "name": "Sirius LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-224" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e114", "name": "Construction Company Khiminvest LLC (OGRN 1027739156587)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-226" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e115", "name": "Zinovev Aleksey Mikhaylovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-229" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e116", "name": "Gidromash MK CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-235", "c-role-249" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e117", "name": "Remstroyservis LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-236", "c-role-250" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e118", "name": "Trading House Shchelkovo Pumps–ENA CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-237" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e119", "name": "Remservice-ENA CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-238" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e120", "name": "Magnitoprovody ENA CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-239" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e121", "name": "Railtransservice LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-243" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e122", "name": "Karakhanyan Vladimir Karpovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-249" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e123", "name": "Skinest Finants AS", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-260", "c-role-266", "c-role-267" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e124", "name": "Delantina OU", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-261", "c-role-270", "c-role-271" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e125", "name": "Transbuilding Service Limited", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-262", "c-role-268", "c-role-269" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e126", "name": "Vadym Duzyk", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-265" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e127", "name": "Tyutyunnik Nataliya Vitalevna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-276", "c-role-278" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e128", "name": "Dymova Zoya Nikolaevna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-professional-services", "c-role-277" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e129", "name": "VEB-Leasing JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-elz-sale-and-close", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-279", "c-role-285" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e130", "name": "First Locomotive Holding AG (Switzerland)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-first-locomotive", "c-role-294", "c-role-311", "c-role-312" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ch" }, { "id": "e131", "name": "New Industrial Engineering LLC (NPI)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-298", "c-role-315", "c-role-316" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e132", "name": "Gasanov Ali Magomedkamilovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-304" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e133", "name": "Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya JSC (PTP)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-308", "c-role-309", "c-role-310", "c-role-385", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ru" }, { "id": "e134", "name": "Korzhuk Mikhail Valerevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-professional-services", "c-role-310", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e135", "name": "Dr. Thilo Aurel Michel Pachmann", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-first-locomotive", "c-professional-services", "c-role-311" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e136", "name": "OBT AG", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-first-locomotive", "c-professional-services", "c-role-312" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e137", "name": "Transleasing-Alliance CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-319", "c-role-322", "c-role-371", "c-role-373", "c-role-374" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e138", "name": "RusUkrVagon CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-320", "c-role-381", "c-role-382", "c-role-383" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e139", "name": "Spetskompani LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-321", "c-role-324" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e140", "name": "Trading Company RusUkrVagon CJSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-323" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e141", "name": "Astashenkova Alla Vasilevna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-330" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e142", "name": "Solovev Gennadiy Arsentevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-331" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e143", "name": "Pavlyukevich Andrey Anatolevich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-role-335" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e144", "name": "Rusanova Natalya Aleksandrovna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-role-337" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e145", "name": "Kintana Investments Limited (historical ENA shareholder)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-339", "c-role-355" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e146", "name": "Acorient Constructions Ltd", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-340", "c-role-344", "c-role-373", "c-role-392", "c-role-393", "c-role-394" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "cy" }, { "id": "e147", "name": "Omni Eurotrading Ltd", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-role-341", "c-role-343" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e148", "name": "Maltesert Group Inc.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-342", "c-role-345", "c-role-363", "c-role-364", "c-role-365", "c-role-366", "c-role-367" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e149", "name": "Abarkin Denis Aleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-ena-history", "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-346", "c-role-377", "c-role-378" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e150", "name": "Private Security Company NOIS-11 LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-358" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e151", "name": "Ryumina Natalya Vladimirovna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-361" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e153", "name": "Unitrust Corporate Services Ltd.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-363" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e154", "name": "Verter Holdings Ltd", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-364" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e155", "name": "Juan Jose Tenorio Rodriguez", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-365" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e156", "name": "Danette Sandra Tania Athanase", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-366" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e157", "name": "Standard Directors Ltd.", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-367" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e160", "name": "FELEDINO HOLDINGS LIMITED", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-374" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e161", "name": "Vossloh Fastening Systems Rus JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-377" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e162", "name": "Foresight Engineering Centre LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-professional-services", "c-role-378" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e163", "name": "Konstantinos Parmaxis", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-379" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e164", "name": "Maria Michailidou Misailidou", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-380" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e165", "name": "Gorelova Galina Ivanovna", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-historic-companies", "c-role-382" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e166", "name": "Reestr JSC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-professional-services", "c-role-385", "c-three-locomotive-entities" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e167", "name": "Menelaos Sazos", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-393" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e168", "name": "Panagiota Christofi", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-offshore-limits", "c-role-394" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e169", "name": "Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-role-396", "c-role-405", "c-role-408", "c-role-410", "c-role-411", "c-role-412", "c-role-413", "c-vnv-release" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ua" }, { "id": "e170", "name": "Kremenchuk Mechanical Products Plant JSC (KrZMV)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-397", "c-role-403" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e171", "name": "YUTS LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-398" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e172", "name": "PRFD LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-401", "c-role-404" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e173", "name": "V.N.V. LLC", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-overview-ukraine", "c-role-409", "c-role-415", "c-role-416", "c-role-417", "c-role-418", "c-role-422", "c-vnv-release" ], "badges": [], "jurisdiction": "ua" }, { "id": "e174", "name": "Rukavichko Sergiy Mikolayovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "c-role-413" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e175", "name": "Ovchar Igor Oleksandrovich", "type": "person", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-ukraine", "c-role-418", "c-vnv-release" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e3001", "name": "Vnesheconombank (VEB.RF)", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-elz-liability", "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-elz-veb-memorandum" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e3002", "name": "RRR Holdings Limited / Kirk-Investment", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-bcl-financing", "c-role-bcl-other-half" ], "badges": [] }, { "id": "e3003", "name": "MosRegionTrans", "type": "organization", "role": "", "period": "", "group": "counterparties", "claim_ids": [ "c-overview-outcomes", "c-role-zmk-mosregiontrans", "c-zmk-wagon-contract" ], "badges": [] } ], "edges": [ { "id": "r-1", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Sole shareholder (100%)", "period": "Sole-shareholder entry from 28 May 2008; retained record in October 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-1" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-2", "from": "e3", "to": "e1", "role": "Independently authorized managing director", "period": "Managing-director mandate from 21 March 2012; retained record in October 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-2" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-4", "from": "e5", "to": "e6", "role": "Holder of 50%", "period": "50% participant from 16 July 2024 in the retained register", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-4" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-5", "from": "e5", "to": "e7", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Recorded from 2005-05-05; entity ceased 10 November 2009; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-5" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-6", "from": "e5", "to": "e8", "role": "Historic head of the company", "period": "Historical head; company removed on 16 April 2007, which is not a proven appointment date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-6" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-7", "from": "e5", "to": "e9", "role": "General director", "period": "General-director entry from 23 August 2024; retained record in October 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-7" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-8", "from": "e5", "to": "e7", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 10 November 2009; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-8" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-10", "from": "e5", "to": "e10", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 3 million", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 17 May 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-10" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-11", "from": "e5", "to": "e11", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 140,000", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 2 November 2012; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-11" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-12", "from": "e5", "to": "e12", "role": "Historic founder; reported 34.999%", "period": "Source recorded 2024-12-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-12" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-13", "from": "e3", "to": "e6", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-13" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-14", "from": "e3", "to": "e13", "role": "General director", "period": "Historic mandate: one directory says from 16 June 2008, another entry is dated 8 September 2022; appointment-date difference unresolved", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-14" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-15", "from": "e3", "to": "e6", "role": "Holder of 50%", "period": "50% participant from 10 February 2014 in the retained register", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-15" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-16", "from": "e3", "to": "e14", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-16" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-17", "from": "e3", "to": "e15", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-17" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-18", "from": "e5", "to": "e16", "role": "Controlling person; 87.8265% total-capital interest reported for the 2020 transaction", "period": "Related-party transaction disclosure dated 16 November 2020", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-18" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-19", "from": "e1", "to": "e16", "role": "Assignee of ZMK loan claims against MASZ", "period": "Assignment transaction on 16 November 2020 concerning 2017–2018 loans; subsequent repayment not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-19" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-20", "from": "e1", "to": "e17", "role": "Lender through assigned MASZ claims", "period": "Assignment transaction on 16 November 2020 concerning 2017–2018 loans; subsequent repayment not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-20" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-21", "from": "e18", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-21" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-22", "from": "e19", "to": "e16", "role": "Board chair", "period": "Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-22" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-23", "from": "e20", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-23" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-24", "from": "e21", "to": "e16", "role": "General director and board member", "period": "Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-24" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-25", "from": "e22", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Historical board mandate; ended 11 April 2024", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-25" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-26", "from": "e1", "to": "e23", "role": "Third party in the KVBZ share-confiscation proceeding", "period": "January 2026 confiscation proceeding; effective 27 January; transfer recorded April 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-26" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-27", "from": "e1", "to": "e24", "role": "Third party aligned with the defendant in the ministry claim", "period": "January 2026 confiscation proceeding; effective 27 January; transfer recorded April 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-27" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-28", "from": "e1", "to": "e5", "role": "Third-party company in the proceeding against its shareholder", "period": "January 2026 confiscation proceeding; effective 27 January; transfer recorded April 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-28" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-29", "from": "e1", "to": "e23", "role": "Historic holder of the 25% KVBZ stake", "period": "25% acquired in 2012; confiscation effective 27 January 2026 and register transfer reported 17 April 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-29" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-30", "from": "e1", "to": "e16", "role": "Holder of more than 70% of voting rights through the documented shareholding", "period": "Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-30" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-31", "from": "e1", "to": "e25", "role": "Holder of 96.17%", "period": "Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-31" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-32", "from": "e1", "to": "e26", "role": "Holder of 50% of Balakovo-Centrolit shares", "period": "Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-32" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-33", "from": "e1", "to": "e26", "role": "Lender to Balakovo-Centrolit", "period": "Loans advanced in 2015–2016 and assigned claims; multi-lender balance reported at 31 December 2024 with November 2032 repayment limit", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-33" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-34", "from": "e1", "to": "e27", "role": "Assignee of Fofasio claims against Balakovo-Centrolit", "period": "Loans advanced in 2015–2016 and assigned claims; multi-lender balance reported at 31 December 2024 with November 2032 repayment limit", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-34" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-35", "from": "e5", "to": "e9", "role": "Controlling beneficiary and executive identified in the court record", "period": "Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-35" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-36", "from": "e28", "to": "e17", "role": "Manager identified in the Hungarian directory", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-36" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-40", "from": "e29", "to": "e16", "role": "Board chair", "period": "Recorded from 2022-10-06; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-40" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-41", "from": "e30", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-10-06; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-41" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-42", "from": "e31", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Board member in the 2022–2024 rosters; ended 29 November 2024", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-42" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-43", "from": "e32", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-10-06; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-43" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-46", "from": "e22", "to": "e33", "role": "Reported workplace", "period": "Source recorded 2024-05-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-46" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-47", "from": "e21", "to": "e16", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2024-05-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-47" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-48", "from": "e34", "to": "e16", "role": "External auditor", "period": "Source recorded 2023; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-48" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-49", "from": "e30", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Recorded from 2023-05-25; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-49" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-52", "from": "e35", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-04-11; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-52" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-53", "from": "e3", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-53" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-54", "from": "e30", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Source recorded 2024-11-29; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-54" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-55", "from": "e32", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Source recorded 2024-11-29; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-55" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-56", "from": "e29", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Source recorded 2024-11-29; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-56" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-57", "from": "e36", "to": "e25", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-04-27; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-57" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-58", "from": "e37", "to": "e26", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-07-14; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-58" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-59", "from": "e38", "to": "e7", "role": "Liquidator", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 10 November 2009; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-59" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-61", "from": "e3", "to": "e14", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 225,000", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-61" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-62", "from": "e3", "to": "e15", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 285,000", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-62" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-63", "from": "e3", "to": "e39", "role": "Former 50% participant", "period": "Former 50% participation; register replacement recorded 27 June 2017", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-63" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-64", "from": "e3", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-64" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-65", "from": "e30", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-65" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-66", "from": "e40", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-66" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-67", "from": "e41", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-67" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-68", "from": "e42", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-68" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-69", "from": "e34", "to": "e25", "role": "External auditor", "period": "Source recorded 2022-06-02; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-69" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-70", "from": "e21", "to": "e16", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2024-12-11; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-70" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-71", "from": "e21", "to": "e43", "role": "Founder; recorded contribution RUB 2,500", "period": "Source recorded 2024-12-11; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-71" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-72", "from": "e1", "to": "e17", "role": "Historical 74.8% investment in the former BEHAN company", "period": "Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-72" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-73", "from": "e1", "to": "e25", "role": "Holder of 96.17%", "period": "Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-73" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-74", "from": "e1", "to": "e26", "role": "Holder of 50% of Balakovo-Centrolit shares", "period": "Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-74" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-76", "from": "e1", "to": "e16", "role": "Historical 72.435% total-capital investment", "period": "Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-76" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-77", "from": "e45", "to": "e23", "role": "Board chair and director of KVBZ", "period": "Recorded from 2025-04-25; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-77" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-80", "from": "e46", "to": "e23", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; 34.37%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-80" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-81", "from": "e47", "to": "e23", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; 34.37%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-81" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-82", "from": "e17", "to": "e1", "role": "Borrower under claims assigned to OW", "period": "Assignment transaction on 16 November 2020 concerning 2017–2018 loans; subsequent repayment not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-82" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-83", "from": "e5", "to": "e16", "role": "Proposed subscriber to the ZMK additional share issue; completion unconfirmed", "period": "Resolution 28 March 2024; challenge rejected and upheld through April 2025; completed placement not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-83" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-84", "from": "e48", "to": "e16", "role": "Preferred shareholder challenging the share-issue decision", "period": "Challenge rejected 15 October 2024; upheld 26 December 2024 and April 2025", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-84" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-85", "from": "e9", "to": "e55", "role": "Purchaser of the old ELZ industrial assets", "period": "Auction award 23 January 2023; purchase contract 1 February 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-85" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-86", "from": "e3", "to": "e1", "role": "Managing director who prepared the filed annual accounts", "period": "Prepared the filed 2025 accounts", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-86" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-89", "from": "e5", "to": "e10", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 17 May 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-89" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-90", "from": "e5", "to": "e11", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 2 November 2012; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-90" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-91", "from": "e50", "to": "e14", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-91" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-93", "from": "e51", "to": "e14", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-93" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-94", "from": "e52", "to": "e14", "role": "Successor upon merger by accession", "period": "Accession of Metpromgrupp CJSC completed 23 September 2015", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-94" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-96", "from": "e1", "to": "e23", "role": "Prospective purchaser in the July 2012 announcement", "period": "Announced 11 July 2012; acquisition later reported completed 4 September 2012; 2026 state transfer stated separately", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-96" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-97", "from": "e5", "to": "e16", "role": "Board chair", "period": "Source recorded 2012-07-11; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-97" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-100", "from": "e9", "to": "e24", "role": "Defendant in the ministry request to recover 79 railway wagons", "period": "Ministry claim announced 7 October 2026; final outcome not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-100" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-101", "from": "e5", "to": "e55", "role": "Reported historical controlling interest in ELZ", "period": "Historical position described in retained proceedings; old ELZ liquidated 15 July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-101" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-103", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Controller of the company that held the historic KVBZ interest", "period": "Source recorded 2026-01-27; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-103" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-106", "from": "e56", "to": "e55", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-106" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-107", "from": "e57", "to": "e55", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-107" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-108", "from": "e58", "to": "e55", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-108" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-109", "from": "e59", "to": "e55", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-109" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-110", "from": "e30", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-110" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-111", "from": "e3", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-111" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-112", "from": "e60", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-112" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-113", "from": "e40", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-113" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-114", "from": "e42", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-114" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-115", "from": "e16", "to": "e61", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 14 October 2019; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-115" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-116", "from": "e16", "to": "e26", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-116" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-117", "from": "e16", "to": "e62", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 7 April 2014; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-117" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-118", "from": "e16", "to": "e63", "role": "Supplier in the retained procurement records", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-118" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-119", "from": "e21", "to": "e16", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2015-01-22; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-119" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-120", "from": "e21", "to": "e43", "role": "Registered founder of the testing company", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-120" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-122", "from": "e50", "to": "e64", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-122" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-123", "from": "e50", "to": "e65", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-123" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-124", "from": "e50", "to": "e15", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-124" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-126", "from": "e13", "to": "e66", "role": "10% founder of the short-lived ELZ LLC", "period": "Recorded from 2023-01-30; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-126" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-127", "from": "e13", "to": "e67", "role": "Former participant", "period": "Ended by 2024-12-05", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-127" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-128", "from": "e68", "to": "e13", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-128" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-129", "from": "e69", "to": "e13", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-129" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-131", "from": "e9", "to": "e66", "role": "90% founder of the short-lived ELZ LLC", "period": "Recorded from 2023-01-30; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-131" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-133", "from": "e70", "to": "e66", "role": "Former general director", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-133" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-134", "from": "e71", "to": "e66", "role": "General director, then liquidator", "period": "Recorded from 2023-02-28; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-134" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-137", "from": "e72", "to": "e15", "role": "General director, then liquidator", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-137" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-138", "from": "e15", "to": "e73", "role": "Supplier in the retained procurement records", "period": "Historical procurement records; supplier liquidated 28 December 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-138" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-139", "from": "e37", "to": "e26", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2024-03-05; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-139" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-140", "from": "e37", "to": "e74", "role": "General director", "period": "2023-01-18–2024-03-01", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-140" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-141", "from": "e36", "to": "e25", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2019-06-28; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-141" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-142", "from": "e28", "to": "e17", "role": "Directory-reported owner; percentage and complete shareholder list unresolved", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-142" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-143", "from": "e28", "to": "e17", "role": "Manager identified in the Hungarian directory", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-143" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-144", "from": "e75", "to": "e17", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-144" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-145", "from": "e76", "to": "e17", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-145" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-146", "from": "e77", "to": "e17", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-146" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-147", "from": "e3", "to": "e78", "role": "Person with significant influence or control; share percentage not specified", "period": "Recorded from 2022-02-18; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "associations", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-147" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-151", "from": "e81", "to": "e78", "role": "Director", "period": "Recorded from 2021-02-03; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-151" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-153", "from": "e5", "to": "e74", "role": "Reported ownership or control in secondary reporting; exact direct interest unestablished", "period": "Source recorded 2013-03-13; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-153" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-154", "from": "e5", "to": "e26", "role": "Reported ownership or control in secondary reporting; exact direct interest unestablished", "period": "Source recorded 2013-03-13; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-154" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-155", "from": "e5", "to": "e83", "role": "Adviser to the general director", "period": "Source recorded 2013-03-13; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-155" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-158", "from": "e74", "to": "e26", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-158" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-159", "from": "e22", "to": "e74", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-159" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-160", "from": "e100", "to": "e74", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-160" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-161", "from": "e87", "to": "e74", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-161" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-162", "from": "e88", "to": "e74", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2026-02-06; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-162" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-163", "from": "e89", "to": "e74", "role": "General director during two separate recorded mandates", "period": "30 October 2018–18 January 2023 and 1 March 2024–6 February 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-163" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-165", "from": "e90", "to": "e74", "role": "General director", "period": "Ended by 2018-10-30", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-165" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-166", "from": "e75", "to": "e91", "role": "Former participant", "period": "Ended by 2021-12-06", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-166" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-167", "from": "e75", "to": "e92", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-167" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-168", "from": "e75", "to": "e92", "role": "Former company head", "period": "Ended by 2016-12-15", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-168" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-169", "from": "e93", "to": "e61", "role": "Successor to ZMK-Trans upon accession", "period": "Merger by accession completed 14 October 2019", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-169" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-170", "from": "e94", "to": "e61", "role": "Director", "period": "Director recorded from 16 June 2014; company ended by accession on 14 October 2019", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-170" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-172", "from": "e95", "to": "e62", "role": "Chair of the liquidation commission", "period": "Recorded from 2013-05-22; entity ceased 7 April 2014; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-172" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-173", "from": "e62", "to": "e16", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2014-04-07; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-173" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-175", "from": "e96", "to": "e62", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 7 April 2014; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-175" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-177", "from": "e81", "to": "e78", "role": "Director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-02-28; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-177" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-179", "from": "e60", "to": "e97", "role": "Sole participant (100%)", "period": "Recorded from 2025-02-12; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-179" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-180", "from": "e60", "to": "e98", "role": "Company head recorded in the Kazakhstan directory", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-08; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-180" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-182", "from": "e99", "to": "e14", "role": "General director", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-182" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-184", "from": "e51", "to": "e14", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 250,000", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-184" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-186", "from": "e50", "to": "e14", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 25,000", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-186" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-187", "from": "e101", "to": "e102", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2024-06-13; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-187" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-188", "from": "e101", "to": "e103", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2021-05-19; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-188" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-189", "from": "e60", "to": "e98", "role": "Director", "period": "Recorded from 2025-09-23; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-189" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-190", "from": "e18", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Historical supervisory-board mandate, ended 5 September 2021", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-190" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-191", "from": "e41", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2021-06-15; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-191" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-192", "from": "e36", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Supervisory-board mandate 16 June–5 September 2021; distinct from general-director office", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-192" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-193", "from": "e42", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2021-06-15; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-193" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-194", "from": "e104", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2021-06-15; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-194" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-195", "from": "e34", "to": "e25", "role": "External auditor", "period": "Source recorded 2021-06-15; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-195" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-196", "from": "e5", "to": "e55", "role": "Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-196" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-197", "from": "e18", "to": "e55", "role": "Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-197" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-198", "from": "e32", "to": "e55", "role": "Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-198" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-199", "from": "e105", "to": "e55", "role": "Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-199" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-200", "from": "e58", "to": "e55", "role": "Respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-200" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-201", "from": "e57", "to": "e55", "role": "Respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-201" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-202", "from": "e70", "to": "e55", "role": "Former director and respondent to the rejected liability claim", "period": "Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-202" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-203", "from": "e106", "to": "e9", "role": "Reported holder of 60% in the historical ownership snapshot", "period": "Historical 2009–2017 ownership records; registry-field removal does not establish the disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-203" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-204", "from": "e107", "to": "e9", "role": "Reported holder of 20% in the historical ownership snapshot", "period": "Historical 2009–2017 ownership records; registry-field removal does not establish the disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-204" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-205", "from": "e108", "to": "e9", "role": "Reported holder of 20% in the historical ownership snapshot", "period": "Historical 2009–2017 ownership records; registry-field removal does not establish the disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-205" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-206", "from": "e55", "to": "e109", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2023-03-01; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-206" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-208", "from": "e89", "to": "e109", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2026-02-06; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-208" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-209", "from": "e70", "to": "e109", "role": "General director", "period": "Ended by 2026-02-06", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-209" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-210", "from": "e109", "to": "e55", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-210" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-212", "from": "e110", "to": "e92", "role": "Liquidator and former general director", "period": "Recorded from 2019-07-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-212" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-215", "from": "e111", "to": "e97", "role": "Former participant and general director", "period": "Ended by 2025-02-12", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-215" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-216", "from": "e112", "to": "e97", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2025-02-12; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-216" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-217", "from": "e97", "to": "e14", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2026-09-08; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-217" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-218", "from": "e97", "to": "e16", "role": "Party in a listed economic dispute; merits and outcome unestablished", "period": "Recorded from 2025-12-12; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-218" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-220", "from": "e108", "to": "e9", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-220" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-221", "from": "e107", "to": "e9", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-221" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-222", "from": "e106", "to": "e9", "role": "Historic registered participant", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-222" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-223", "from": "e31", "to": "e9", "role": "General director", "period": "Ended by 2024-08-23", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-223" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-224", "from": "e9", "to": "e113", "role": "Former participant in Sirius", "period": "Ended by 2024-12-23", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-224" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-226", "from": "e114", "to": "e10", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 17 May 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-226" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-228", "from": "e11", "to": "e97", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2022-01-02; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-228" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-229", "from": "e115", "to": "e12", "role": "Sole participant (100%)", "period": "Recorded from 2020-02-14; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-229" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-230", "from": "e12", "to": "e26", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Ended by 2019-05-07", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-230" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-231", "from": "e3", "to": "e39", "role": "Former participant", "period": "Ended by 2017-06-27", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-231" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-232", "from": "e55", "to": "e9", "role": "Bankruptcy debtor; counterparty identified as another case participant", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-232" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-233", "from": "e55", "to": "e57", "role": "Bankruptcy debtor; counterparty identified as another case participant", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-233" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-234", "from": "e28", "to": "e17", "role": "Directory-reported owner; percentage and complete shareholder list unresolved", "period": "Source recorded 2026-03-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-234" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-235", "from": "e25", "to": "e116", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 18 December 2017; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-235" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-236", "from": "e25", "to": "e117", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 April 2003; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-236" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-237", "from": "e25", "to": "e118", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 9 February 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-237" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-238", "from": "e25", "to": "e119", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 25 September 2009; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-238" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-239", "from": "e25", "to": "e120", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 29 April 2011; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-239" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-240", "from": "e31", "to": "e9", "role": "General director", "period": "2021-02-20–2024-08-23", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-240" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-241", "from": "e31", "to": "e66", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2023-01-30; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-241" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-243", "from": "e108", "to": "e121", "role": "Founder during the recorded 2014–2016 period", "period": "2014-08-08–2016-11-10", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-243" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-246", "from": "e9", "to": "e80", "role": "Participant in the same ELZ bankruptcy as PLK", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-246" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-247", "from": "e18", "to": "e16", "role": "Former deputy general director for commercial and economic affairs", "period": "Former capacity expressly described in the retained source; exact end date not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-247" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-249", "from": "e122", "to": "e116", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2003-01-20; entity ceased 18 December 2017; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-249" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-250", "from": "e25", "to": "e117", "role": "Historic participant; recorded contribution RUB 2,100", "period": "Recorded from 2003-04-17; entity ceased 28 April 2003; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-250" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-256", "from": "e50", "to": "e65", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 25,000", "period": "Historic founder entry; field deletion is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-256" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-257", "from": "e50", "to": "e64", "role": "Historic founder; reported 4.9%", "period": "Historic founder entry; field deletion is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-257" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-258", "from": "e5", "to": "e74", "role": "Reported ownership or control in secondary reporting; exact direct interest unestablished", "period": "Source recorded 2024-06-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-258" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-259", "from": "e109", "to": "e9", "role": "Operator at the industrial site reportedly acquired by IKK", "period": "Source recorded 2024-06-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-259" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-260", "from": "e123", "to": "e23", "role": "Holder of 25% in the September 2021 snapshot", "period": "Shareholding snapshot 30 September 2021; subsequent control records have separate dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-260" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-261", "from": "e124", "to": "e23", "role": "Holder of 25% in the September 2021 snapshot", "period": "Shareholding snapshot 30 September 2021; subsequent control records have separate dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-261" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-262", "from": "e125", "to": "e23", "role": "Holder of 20% in the September 2021 snapshot", "period": "Shareholding snapshot 30 September 2021; subsequent control records have separate dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-262" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-263", "from": "e5", "to": "e23", "role": "Historical indirect KVBZ beneficiary through OW; not personally 90%", "period": "Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-263" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-264", "from": "e46", "to": "e23", "role": "Reported beneficiary and supervisory-board chair", "period": "Source recorded 2021-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-264" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-265", "from": "e1", "to": "e126", "role": "Company represented by Duzyk on the KVBZ supervisory board", "period": "Representative from September 2021; mandate ended 6 June 2022", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-265" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-266", "from": "e46", "to": "e123", "role": "Reported direct beneficial interest", "period": "Recorded from 2018-10-26; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-266" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-267", "from": "e47", "to": "e123", "role": "Reported direct beneficial interest", "period": "Recorded from 2018-10-26; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-267" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-268", "from": "e46", "to": "e125", "role": "Person with significant control; reported 25–50% band", "period": "Recorded from 2022-09-01; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-268" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-269", "from": "e47", "to": "e125", "role": "Person with significant control; reported 25–50% band", "period": "Recorded from 2022-09-01; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-269" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-270", "from": "e47", "to": "e124", "role": "Holder of 50% in the September 2023 register entry", "period": "Recorded from 2023-09-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-270" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-271", "from": "e46", "to": "e124", "role": "Holder of 50% in the September 2023 register entry", "period": "Recorded from 2023-09-02; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-271" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-272", "from": "e5", "to": "e23", "role": "Historical indirect beneficiary through OW", "period": "Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-272" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-274", "from": "e18", "to": "e23", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "2021-04-22–2021-09", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-274" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-275", "from": "e18", "to": "e16", "role": "Board member", "period": "Recorded from 2008; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-275" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-276", "from": "e127", "to": "e34", "role": "Holder of 50%", "period": "Recorded from 2003-01-30; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-276" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-277", "from": "e128", "to": "e34", "role": "Holder of 50%", "period": "Recorded from 2003-01-30; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-277" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-278", "from": "e127", "to": "e34", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2011-10-11; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-278" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-279", "from": "e55", "to": "e129", "role": "Bankruptcy debtor in the proceeding initiated by VEB-Leasing", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-279" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-280", "from": "e55", "to": "e58", "role": "Bankrupt company whose shareholder faced a rejected liability claim", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-280" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-281", "from": "e55", "to": "e57", "role": "Bankrupt company whose shareholder faced a rejected liability claim", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-281" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-282", "from": "e58", "to": "e55", "role": "Holder of 42.55% of voting shares in the historical court account", "period": "Historical position described in retained proceedings; old ELZ liquidated 15 July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-282" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-283", "from": "e57", "to": "e55", "role": "Holder of 42.55% of voting shares in the historical court account", "period": "Historical position described in retained proceedings; old ELZ liquidated 15 July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-283" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-284", "from": "e55", "to": "e80", "role": "Lender to PLK for the locomotive investment project", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-284" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-285", "from": "e55", "to": "e129", "role": "Borrower from VEB-Leasing under the documented project loans", "period": "Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-285" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-286", "from": "e1", "to": "e5", "role": "Co-plaintiff in the ZMK grain-wagon contract action", "period": "Grain-wagon contract litigation; dismissal reported February 2025 with appeals pending at that report", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-286" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-287", "from": "e1", "to": "e16", "role": "Shareholder bringing a claim in ZMK’s interest", "period": "Grain-wagon contract litigation; dismissal reported February 2025 with appeals pending at that report", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-287" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-288", "from": "e1", "to": "e16", "role": "Combined holding with Gamzalov reported above 74.2%; individual split unstated", "period": "Combined ownership described in the February 2025 contract-case report; direct split not supplied", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-288" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-289", "from": "e1", "to": "e5", "role": "Co-shareholder in ZMK in the reported combined holding", "period": "Combined ownership described in the February 2025 contract-case report; direct split not supplied", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "associations", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-289" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-290", "from": "e16", "to": "e48", "role": "Issuer defending the preferred shareholder’s issue challenge", "period": "Challenge rejected 15 October 2024; upheld 26 December 2024 and April 2025", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-290" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-291", "from": "e1", "to": "e16", "role": "Holder of 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary shares; approximately 96.58% of that class", "period": "Ordinary-voting-share count described in the April 2025 judgment; denominator differs from total capital", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-291" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-294", "from": "e130", "to": "e80", "role": "Sole parent (100%) of PLK", "period": "Sole parent from 12 August 2014; PLK liquidated 24 November 2025", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-294" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-295", "from": "e40", "to": "e80", "role": "General director", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 24 November 2025; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-295" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-296", "from": "e40", "to": "e26", "role": "General director", "period": "2015-10-12–2016-09-16", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-296" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-297", "from": "e40", "to": "e80", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2016-10-12; entity ceased 24 November 2025; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-297" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-298", "from": "e40", "to": "e131", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2022-11-03; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-298" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-303", "from": "e75", "to": "e91", "role": "Former 50% participant; recorded contribution RUB 5,000", "period": "2014-04-23–2021-12-06", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-303" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-304", "from": "e132", "to": "e91", "role": "50% participant and general director", "period": "Recorded from 2014-04-23; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-304" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-305", "from": "e21", "to": "e43", "role": "Holder of 25%; recorded contribution RUB 2,500", "period": "Recorded from 2011-04-15; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-305" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-306", "from": "e43", "to": "e16", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2016-02-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-306" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-308", "from": "e133", "to": "e16", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2024-11-05; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-308" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-309", "from": "e133", "to": "e109", "role": "Reported investment project at the newer locomotive plant’s site", "period": "Source recorded 2024-11-05; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "associations", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-309" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-310", "from": "e134", "to": "e133", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2024-04-18; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-310" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-311", "from": "e135", "to": "e130", "role": "Sole board member with individual signature", "period": "Board member recorded March 2014; holding company bankrupt September 2023 and removed January 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-311" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-312", "from": "e136", "to": "e130", "role": "Historic audit appointment", "period": "Audit appointment in March 2014 incorporation publication; later mandate not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-312" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-315", "from": "e131", "to": "e13", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Ended by 2023-03-30", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-315" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-316", "from": "e32", "to": "e131", "role": "Sole participant (100%)", "period": "Recorded from 2022-11-03; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-316" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-319", "from": "e29", "to": "e137", "role": "Chair of the liquidation commission", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-319" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-320", "from": "e29", "to": "e138", "role": "Liquidator", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-320" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-321", "from": "e29", "to": "e139", "role": "Company head during the recorded 2016–2021 mandate", "period": "2016-12-16–2021-12-21", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-321" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-322", "from": "e29", "to": "e137", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-322" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-323", "from": "e29", "to": "e140", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-323" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-324", "from": "e29", "to": "e139", "role": "Founder during the recorded 2011–2021 period", "period": "2011-12-09–2021-12-21", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-324" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-326", "from": "e9", "to": "e5", "role": "Co-defendant in the pending ministry wagon claim", "period": "Ministry claim announced 7 October 2026; final outcome not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "legal", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-326" ], "kind": "legal" }, { "id": "r-328", "from": "e50", "to": "e15", "role": "Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 15,000", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-328" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-329", "from": "e72", "to": "e15", "role": "General director", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-329" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-330", "from": "e141", "to": "e15", "role": "Former general director", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-330" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-331", "from": "e142", "to": "e15", "role": "Former general director", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-331" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-333", "from": "e112", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-333" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-335", "from": "e143", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-335" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-336", "from": "e29", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-336" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-337", "from": "e144", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-337" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-338", "from": "e34", "to": "e25", "role": "External auditor", "period": "Source recorded 2011-06-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-338" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-339", "from": "e145", "to": "e25", "role": "Proposed subscriber for 267,661 new shares under the 2011 resolution", "period": "Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-339" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-340", "from": "e146", "to": "e25", "role": "Proposed subscriber for 475,287 new shares under the 2011 resolution", "period": "Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-340" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-341", "from": "e147", "to": "e25", "role": "Proposed subscriber for 394,847 new shares under the 2011 resolution", "period": "Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-341" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-342", "from": "e148", "to": "e25", "role": "Proposed subscriber for 462,205 new shares under the 2011 resolution", "period": "Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-342" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-343", "from": "e147", "to": "e25", "role": "Holder of 22.54% in the May–June 2012 disclosure", "period": "Shareholding disclosed from 4 May 2012 in the June 2012 issuer record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-343" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-344", "from": "e146", "to": "e25", "role": "Holder of 24.9% in the May–June 2012 disclosure", "period": "Shareholding disclosed from 4 May 2012 in the June 2012 issuer record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-344" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-345", "from": "e148", "to": "e25", "role": "Holder of 24.9% in the May–June 2012 disclosure", "period": "Shareholding disclosed from 4 May 2012 in the June 2012 issuer record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-345" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-346", "from": "e149", "to": "e25", "role": "General director", "period": "Recorded from 2012-06-29; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-346" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-347", "from": "e60", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Board roster during 1 January–28 November 2024; reporting-period start is not an appointment date", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-347" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-348", "from": "e31", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Supervisory-board roster through 28 November 2024", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-348" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-349", "from": "e30", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Source recorded 2024-11-28; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-349" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-350", "from": "e3", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-350" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-351", "from": "e30", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-351" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-352", "from": "e60", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-352" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-353", "from": "e40", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-353" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-354", "from": "e36", "to": "e25", "role": "General director", "period": "Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-354" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-355", "from": "e145", "to": "e25", "role": "Holding reduced to 19.69% from 23.69% on 24 January 2012", "period": "Reduction reported effective 24 January 2012; no termination of the remaining 19.69% established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-355" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-358", "from": "e112", "to": "e150", "role": "Historic founder and general director", "period": "Source recorded 2025-02-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-358" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-360", "from": "e30", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Recorded from 2021-09-06; later status not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-360" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-361", "from": "e151", "to": "e25", "role": "Supervisory-board member", "period": "Ended by 2021-06-15", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-361" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-363", "from": "e148", "to": "e153", "role": "Company for which Unitrust was the recorded intermediary", "period": "Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-363" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-364", "from": "e154", "to": "e148", "role": "Historic shareholder in the ICIJ record", "period": "Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-364" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-365", "from": "e155", "to": "e148", "role": "Director", "period": "18 November 2005–15 October 2009", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-365" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-366", "from": "e156", "to": "e148", "role": "Director", "period": "Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-366" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-367", "from": "e157", "to": "e148", "role": "Incorporation director", "period": "Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-367" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-371", "from": "e29", "to": "e137", "role": "Chair of the liquidation commission", "period": "Recorded from 2009-11-23; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-371" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-373", "from": "e146", "to": "e137", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-373" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-374", "from": "e160", "to": "e137", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-374" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-377", "from": "e149", "to": "e161", "role": "General director", "period": "2019-02-15–2022-02-17", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-377" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-378", "from": "e149", "to": "e162", "role": "General director", "period": "2025-10-03–2026-01-30", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-378" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-379", "from": "e163", "to": "e27", "role": "Director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-379" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-380", "from": "e164", "to": "e27", "role": "Secretary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-380" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-381", "from": "e19", "to": "e138", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-381" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-382", "from": "e165", "to": "e138", "role": "Historic registered founder", "period": "Historical capacity; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-382" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-383", "from": "e29", "to": "e138", "role": "Liquidator", "period": "Recorded from 2009-11-27; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-383" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-385", "from": "e166", "to": "e133", "role": "Shareholder registrar; not an equity owner", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-385" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-387", "from": "e5", "to": "e1", "role": "Controller of the company that held the historic KVBZ interest", "period": "Source recorded 2021-10-18; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-387" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-392", "from": "e146", "to": "e27", "role": "Recorded shared business site", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "infrastructure", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-392" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-393", "from": "e167", "to": "e146", "role": "Director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-393" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-394", "from": "e168", "to": "e146", "role": "Secretary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-394" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-395", "from": "e47", "to": "e23", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; rounded 34.4%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-395" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-396", "from": "e47", "to": "e169", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; 34.37%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-396" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-397", "from": "e47", "to": "e170", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; 35.6%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-397" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-398", "from": "e47", "to": "e171", "role": "Holder of 75%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-398" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-400", "from": "e45", "to": "e23", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-400" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-401", "from": "e45", "to": "e172", "role": "Former owner or beneficiary; exact former interest unstated", "period": "Former capacity expressly described in the retained source; exact end date not established", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-401" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-402", "from": "e46", "to": "e23", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-402" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-403", "from": "e46", "to": "e170", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; 35.6%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-403" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-404", "from": "e46", "to": "e172", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary; 12%", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-404" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-405", "from": "e46", "to": "e169", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-405" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-406", "from": "e46", "to": "e47", "role": "Parallel disclosed corporate interests; no family relationship inferred", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "undirected", "role_group": "associations", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-406" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-408", "from": "e5", "to": "e169", "role": "Historical indirect interest through KVBZ and OW", "period": "Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-408" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-409", "from": "e5", "to": "e173", "role": "Historical indirect interest through KVBZ and OW", "period": "Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-409" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-410", "from": "e23", "to": "e169", "role": "Sole parent (100%)", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-410" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-411", "from": "e46", "to": "e169", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-411" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-412", "from": "e47", "to": "e169", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-412" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-413", "from": "e174", "to": "e169", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-413" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-415", "from": "e23", "to": "e173", "role": "Sole parent (100%)", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-415" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-416", "from": "e5", "to": "e173", "role": "Stale beneficiary entry; historical chain ended after the 2026 parent-stake transfer", "period": "Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-416" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-417", "from": "e46", "to": "e173", "role": "Reported indirect beneficiary", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-417" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-418", "from": "e175", "to": "e173", "role": "General director", "period": "Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "people", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-418" ], "kind": "other" }, { "id": "r-422", "from": "e23", "to": "e173", "role": "Sole parent (100%)", "period": "Source recorded 2026-09-17; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-422" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-elz-veb-memorandum", "from": "e55", "to": "e3001", "role": "Participant with Vnesheconombank in the project-cooperation memorandum", "period": "Memorandum signed 4 June 2013; separate VEB-Leasing loans described in the judgment", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-elz-veb-memorandum" ], "kind": "business" }, { "id": "r-bcl-other-half", "from": "e3002", "to": "e26", "role": "Holder of the other 50% in the documented 2024 capital structure", "period": "2024 position reconstructed in the January 2026 judgment", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "ownership", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-bcl-other-half" ], "kind": "owns" }, { "id": "r-zmk-mosregiontrans", "from": "e16", "to": "e3003", "role": "Supplier under the contested contract for 1,000 grain wagons", "period": "June 2022 contract; renewed dismissal reported February 2025 with appeals pending", "status": "reported", "direction": "directed", "role_group": "business", "temporal_status": "historical", "claim_ids": [ "c-role-zmk-mosregiontrans" ], "kind": "business" } ], "history": [], "claims": [ { "id": "c-identity", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH is the Austrian holding company registered as FN 278008k, with EUID ATBRA.278008-000 and VAT number ATU62706735. The retained registry-derived records identify Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov as its sole shareholder, entered on 28 May 2008, and Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova as its independently authorized managing director from 21 March 2012. Its registered capital grew from €35,000 to €335,000 in 2007 and to €735,000 in 2008. The company was entered in the register on 14 July 2006.", "qualification": "A separate record’s 14 April 2006 legal-form date is not silently substituted for the July registration date. Changes of address and personal name in the filing history do not establish changes of ownership. The identically named German company with Munich number HRB 138024 is a separate entity. The subject is Austrian even though its shareholder and many industrial interests are connected to Russia.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3", "s-d6", "s-d23", "s-d68", "s-d85", "s-d131", "s-d170" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-accounts", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW’s filed 2025 small-company accounts report assets of €70,349,859.90, including €41,647,014.87 of financial investments and €12,356,017.38 cash. Liabilities were €119,829,335.72 and equity was negative €49,490,876.82. The investment schedule records acquisition cost of €86,612,040.87 and accumulated impairment of €44,965,026.00. The accounts report no employees. These figures describe the Austrian holding company, not consolidated revenue or assets of every industrial investment.", "qualification": "Carrying values are not current sale values. The small-company filing does not identify every investment or reconstruct the present capitalization of each subsidiary. Its maturity table puts the liabilities within one year, while the narrative discusses creditor extensions; that presentation difference remains visible rather than being silently reconciled.", "response": "Management expressly states that there is no over-indebtedness within the meaning of insolvency law. It relies on expected recovery in investments after the Russia–Ukraine crisis and extensions individually agreed with creditors. Negative accounting equity alone is not presented here as a court declaration of insolvency.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d85", "s-d86" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3" ] }, { "id": "c-portfolio", "kind": "attributed", "text": "A description based on OW’s 2016 balance sheet listed interests of 72.435% in Zavod Metallokonstruktsy (ZMK), 96.17% in ENA, 50% in Balakovo-Centrolit, 74.8% in BEHAN, now identified as MASZ, and 25% in Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Later evidence has to be read investment by investment. The 2026 Ukrainian judgment retained the 96.17% ENA and 50% Balakovo-Centrolit positions, while the KVBZ interest passed to the Ukrainian state.", "qualification": "The historical portfolio is not a current ownership certificate. ZMK’s total-capital percentage and the 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary voting shares described by the Russian court use different denominators. The 2020 related-party disclosure’s 87.8265% concerns the controlling individual at the transaction date, not necessarily OW’s direct fraction. A 2012 proposal referred to 25% plus one KVBZ share; the later confiscation identifies exactly 28,669,889 shares as 25%.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d19", "s-d68", "s-d89", "s-d90", "s-d344" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e16", "e17", "e23", "e25", "e26", "e27" ] }, { "id": "c-ukraine-sanctions", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The retained sanctions records identify OW by the same FN 278008k and identify Stanislav Gamzalov separately. They report Ukrainian restrictions under decree 279/2023 from 12 May 2023 for five years, including asset blocking. The subsequent Ukrainian confiscation judgment expressly applies the sanctions framework to the identified shareholder and the OW-held KVBZ stake.", "qualification": "Aggregator candidate warnings and control-based tags are screening leads, not separate convictions or proof of a designation by every jurisdiction. This dossier does not certify the absence of sanctions elsewhere. A sanction, a civil confiscation decision and a criminal finding of guilt are different legal events.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d7", "s-d8", "s-d9", "s-d19", "s-d27", "s-d67", "s-d444" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "c-kvbz-confiscation", "kind": "attributed", "text": "On 14 January 2026 the High Anti-Corruption Court of Ukraine ordered 28,669,889 KVBZ shares held by OW, representing 25% of capital and nominal value UAH 21,502,416.75, recovered for the state. The full decision was prepared on 16 January. The issuer’s 17 April disclosure says the judgment took effect on 27 January and that the register received on 15 April changed OW’s interest from 25% to zero and the state’s from zero to 25% of capital, or 25.0717% of voting shares. The earlier 2022 ARMA arrangement was management of the arrested securities account, not a transfer of ownership.", "qualification": "The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d19", "s-d70", "s-d130", "s-d360", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e23", "e24" ] }, { "id": "c-confiscation-grounds", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Ukrainian court found that Gamzalov controlled Inter Cargo Company and, through OW, held the documented interests in ZMK, ENA and Balakovo-Centrolit. It relied on Russian tax payments and specified industrial contracts when applying the statutory grounds for recovery. The judgment discusses ZMK rail-related supply contracts and ENA pump contracts, including a 2017 shipyard contract as well as civil and nuclear-sector customers.", "qualification": "These are the court’s findings and reasoning in that sanctions case. Historic contracts are not proof of new shipments in 2026. The court’s aggregate tax calculation is not a payment made by OW itself, nor does the ownership chain establish that every director personally participated in each industrial transaction. The judgment is not generalized here into a criminal conviction of the network.", "response": "The court records nonappearance and no substantive explanations from OW or the individual, while KVBZ supported the claim. The separate Russian ELZ liability litigation reached a favorable result for its defendants on different claims and must not be conflated with this sanctions proceeding.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d19", "s-d129" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9", "e16", "e23", "e25", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-vnv-release", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The retained company records identify Instrumentalnyi Zavod (IZ, registration 21073227) and V.N.V. (39564144) as wholly owned KVBZ subsidiaries. Gamzalov’s recorded relationship was an indirect interest through the parent, not an independently established personal holding of all their shares. On 17 September 2026 the Holosiivskyi district court granted V.N.V.’s application to lift the arrest of 100% of its capital. The order explains that the OW-held KVBZ stake had already passed to the state.", "qualification": "An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e23", "e169", "e173", "e175" ] }, { "id": "c-railcar-claim", "kind": "attributed", "text": "On 7 October 2026 Ukraine’s Ministry of Justice announced a new High Anti-Corruption Court claim against Stanislav Gamzalov and Inter Cargo Company seeking recovery of 79 railway wagons. Its announcement alleged that the enterprises materially supported Russia’s armed aggression and referred to the earlier KVBZ recovery.", "qualification": "The ministry is a party stating its case. The retained announcement establishes a filed request, not a judgment transferring these 79 wagons or a conviction. This October proceeding must remain separate from the completed January KVBZ judgment and April register transfer.", "response": "No substantive response to this new claim, or final ruling on it, is established by the retained October announcement.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d30", "s-d127", "s-d388" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9", "e24" ] }, { "id": "c-zmk-share-issue", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ZMK’s 28 March 2024 extraordinary meeting approved a proposed private placement of 5,055,201 additional ordinary shares at RUB 10 nominal value. The Russian cassation judgment records 17,333 OW votes out of 17,947 ordinary shares, about 96.58% of that voting class. A holder of 519 preferred shares challenged the issue, alleging an improper price, dilution, lack of investment need and an impermissible foreign-controlled vote. The court rejected the claim; the 15 October 2024 decision was upheld on 26 December 2024 and in April 2025.", "qualification": "The court’s meeting date is 28 March, correcting a secondary account’s 28 April. The full April judgment is dated 18 April, following the operative ruling on 8 April; a mirror header has a different date. Judicial approval of the resolution is not proof that all proposed new shares were issued to Gamzalov. The retained 2025 accounts still report RUB 239,290 registered capital. The record does not establish a completed 99.9% direct personal holding.", "response": "ZMK said the funds would finance foundry capacity and reduce dependence on suppliers. The courts found no proven bad faith or impairment of the protected dividend rights and accepted disclosed Russian control when rejecting the foreign-state restriction argument. Appeals by later purchasers were terminated on standing grounds. A separate 2025 regulator-instruction challenge concerned placement disclosures and pre-emption periods; the retained report says interim relief was refused but does not establish a final merits result in that separate case.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d75", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d387" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e16", "e48", "e56" ] }, { "id": "c-zmk-wagon-contract", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW and Gamzalov also sued in ZMK’s interest to invalidate a June 2022 contract with MosRegionTrans for 1,000 grain wagons worth RUB 4.5 billion. The February 2025 report describes a renewed dismissal after remand, with appeals accepted and a hearing then scheduled for 5 March. This contract dispute is distinct from the shareholder challenge to ZMK’s additional share issue.", "qualification": "The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e16", "e3003" ] }, { "id": "c-zmk-business", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ZMK’s issuer reports document changing boards and a continuing general-director role for Maxim Stolbun. The 2020 board included Igor Gorelov, Dzhakhpar Gamzalov, Mikhail Krivoshein, Stolbun and Igor Ulyanov. Later boards introduced Evgeny Chabrov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Gadzhi Murtazaliev, Valentin Nersesyan and Andrey Ageev. Irina Gamzalova joined the disclosed board from 29 November 2024. The company reported RUB 26.192 billion revenue and RUB 3.285 billion net profit in 2025, compared with RUB 33.691 billion and RUB 5.433 billion in 2024.", "qualification": "Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d53", "s-d56", "s-d136", "s-d387" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e16", "e18", "e19", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e29", "e30", "e31", "e32", "e34", "e35", "e63" ] }, { "id": "c-elz-liability", "kind": "attributed", "text": "In the bankruptcy of the original Engels Locomotive Plant JSC, a request sought RUB 27.293 billion of subsidiary liability from former controlling persons. The application was rejected on 28 November 2022, and that result was upheld on 14 February and 13 April 2023. The April judgment describes Rafelar Holdings and Volkam Trading each holding 42.55% of the voting shares from December 2013. It distinguishes Vnesheconombank’s participation in the June 2013 cooperation memorandum from VEB-Leasing’s direct loans to ELZ. ELZ in turn lent to First Locomotive Company for the Bombardier project.", "qualification": "The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e18", "e32", "e55", "e57", "e58", "e59", "e70", "e80", "e105", "e129", "e3001" ] }, { "id": "c-elz-sale-and-close", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company won the auction for the original ELZ industrial complex on 23 January 2023; a three-party purchase contract followed on 1 February. The reported RUB 2.85 billion price concerned the combined lot, while RUB 2.124 billion described the debtor’s pledged-property portion. The later fee litigation records different creditor-recovery percentages at different dates. The bankruptcy was completed by a 12 May 2026 order despite the creditors’ earlier opposition, and the company was subsequently recorded as liquidated on 15 July 2026.", "qualification": "Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d82", "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d399" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e55", "e129" ] }, { "id": "c-three-locomotive-entities", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The archive contains three different locomotive-plant identities: the old bankrupt JSC, OGRN 1116449006123; a Moscow LLC formed on 30 January 2023, OGRN 1237700072015; and Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC, OGRN 1236400002431, formed on 1 March 2023. The short-lived LLC was owned 90% by Inter Cargo Company and 10% by New Investments, and was liquidated on 29 September 2023. The newer JSC operated at the old industrial site; its directory history records Boris Gruzd replacing Ivan Pankov as general director in February 2026.", "qualification": "A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e13", "e31", "e55", "e66", "e70", "e71", "e89", "e109", "e133", "e134", "e166" ] }, { "id": "c-first-locomotive", "kind": "attributed", "text": "First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK, OGRN 1127747221161) had Swiss First Locomotive Holding AG, CHE-380.001.522, as its sole participant from August 2014. The Russian company entered bankruptcy in November 2022 and was liquidated on 24 November 2025. The retained Swiss publication history separately records the holding company’s bankruptcy on 8 September 2023 and removal on 8 January 2026. Roman Meshkov’s historic management positions in PLK, Balakovo-Centrolit and ENA link professional roles without making those companies identical.", "qualification": "The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e40", "e80", "e130", "e135", "e136" ] }, { "id": "c-ena-history", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA’s disclosures show an older ownership layer before the 96.17% OW holding described in the Ukrainian judgment. A 2011 resolution named Kintana, Acorient, Omni and Maltesert in a private share placement. By the June 2012 affiliated-person list, Omni held 22.54%, Acorient 24.9% and Maltesert 24.9%; a January 2012 disclosure had reduced Kintana’s interest from 23.69% to 19.69%. These are dated ownership events, not a simultaneous current cap table.", "qualification": "The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d63", "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3", "e18", "e25", "e30", "e36", "e38", "e40", "e41", "e42", "e60", "e112", "e143", "e144", "e145", "e146", "e147", "e148", "e149" ] }, { "id": "c-bcl-financing", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Ukrainian judgment describes Balakovo-Centrolit as owned 50% by OW and 50% by RRR Holdings, later redomiciled as Kirk-Investment, in 2024. OW advanced US$10.635 million under 2015–2016 loan contracts, and also received claims assigned by Fofasio. The US$81.3563 million loan balance at 31 December 2024 was owed to several lenders, including OW, with repayment due no later than November 2032.", "qualification": "The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d19", "s-d58", "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d290" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e26", "e27", "e37", "e40", "e74", "e3002" ] }, { "id": "c-masz", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The Hungarian company is MASZ Csoport Kft., registration 07-09-028907 and tax number 12390652-2-07; the retained company-history directory identifies its earlier BEHAN name. The 74.8% OW interest belongs to the 2016 portfolio description. On 16 November 2020 ZMK assigned OW its claims under five MASZ loans originating in 2017 and 2018. Contemporary directories identify Gamzalov Dzhakhpar as a manager, and one calls him an owner, while another counts three owners without naming them.", "qualification": "The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74", "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d248", "s-d292" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16", "e17", "e28", "e76", "e77" ] }, { "id": "c-irina-and-bargo", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Gamzalova’s former Mitrakhova name is connected by retained register histories, including the same Companies House person-with-significant-control record for Bargo Steel Ltd, number 13176974. That UK record describes significant influence or control, not a disclosed 100% shareholding. Bargo was incorporated in February 2021, and Juliette Michel Clarisse is its recorded director. Its February 2026 accounts report no fixed assets, cash of £2,487 and net assets of £277. New Investments’ 2025 directory accounts report RUB 45.5 million revenue, RUB 16.6 million net profit and RUB 116.1 million assets. Its property and transport tax payments indicate taxable assets but do not identify individual properties or vehicles.", "qualification": "Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d62", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3", "e5", "e6", "e13", "e78", "e81" ] }, { "id": "c-inter-cargo", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company is the Russian transport-leasing company OGRN 1097746377530. Registry history records Gadzhi Murtazaliev’s general-director mandate from February 2021 to August 2024, followed by Stanislav Gamzalov. The 2026 Ukrainian judgment identifies Gamzalov as its beneficiary and controlling executive. Older public records described Dowden Investments at 60% and Sergey Reva and Viktor Nemirko at 20% each in a 2017 ownership snapshot.", "qualification": "Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d19", "s-d27", "s-d87", "s-d120", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d353" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9", "e31", "e106", "e107", "e108" ] }, { "id": "c-historic-companies", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The wider register preserves historical founders, officers, successors and commercial connections around the industrial companies. Several named companies had already ceased operating long before a 2021 or 2022 database deletion of their founder fields. The old Metpromgrupp closed joint-stock company merged into Geoplant in 2015; the similarly named LLC is a separate legal entity whose 2025 record names Magomed Magomedov as sole participant and Pavel Sultanov as director. ZMK-Trans ended through accession to Repetek in 2019. Other ENA-linked companies were liquidated in 2003, 2009, 2010 or 2011.", "qualification": "A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d9", "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e5", "e6", "e7", "e8", "e10", "e11", "e12", "e13", "e14", "e15", "e16", "e25", "e43", "e50", "e51", "e52", "e60", "e61", "e62", "e64", "e65", "e74", "e75", "e83", "e87", "e88", "e89", "e90", "e91", "e92", "e93", "e94", "e95", "e96", "e97", "e98", "e99", "e100", "e101", "e102", "e103", "e104", "e106", "e107", "e108", "e110", "e111", "e112", "e113", "e114", "e115", "e116", "e117", "e118", "e119", "e120", "e121", "e131", "e132", "e137", "e138", "e139", "e140", "e141", "e142", "e149", "e160", "e161", "e162", "e165" ] }, { "id": "c-offshore-limits", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The archive traces corporate-service and historic officer records around Fofasio, Acorient and Maltesert, and a separately identified Latvian GS Finance & Trusts company. The ICIJ data describe a historic Maltesert shareholder and service-provider chain; they do not themselves prove a link to OW’s ultimate owner. The exact Acorient Cyprus registration HE 187773 is corroborated by issuer and directory identity data.", "qualification": "The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e27", "e100", "e106", "e145", "e146", "e148", "e153", "e154", "e155", "e156", "e157", "e163", "e164", "e167", "e168" ] }, { "id": "c-kvbz-other-shareholders", "kind": "attributed", "text": "KVBZ’s September 2021 disclosure identified OW at 25%, Skinest Finants at 25%, Delantina at 25% and Transbuilding Service at 20%. Later Estonian, UK and Ukrainian records connect Volodymyr and Nataliia Prykhodko with interests through other holdings. Dzhakhpar Gamzalov represented OW on the supervisory board until September 2021, and Vadym Duzyk’s OW representative mandate ended in June 2022. The parent’s 2025 directory financials report UAH 2.617 billion revenue and a UAH 124.57 million net loss.", "qualification": "Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d70", "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e18", "e23", "e45", "e46", "e47", "e123", "e124", "e125", "e126", "e169", "e170", "e171", "e172", "e173", "e174" ] }, { "id": "c-professional-services", "kind": "attributed", "text": "The professional network includes directors, managers, the Rayvel audit company, registrars and former officers with assignments in more than one industrial enterprise. Rayvel’s records identify Nataliia Tiutiunnyk and Zoya Dymova as equal participants and Tiutiunnyk as general director. ENA and ZMK issuer materials establish the audit and governance roles independently of mere name similarity. Registry histories distinguish completed outside mandates from ongoing source-date entries.", "qualification": "Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d64", "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e18", "e19", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e32", "e34", "e36", "e37", "e40", "e43", "e60", "e76", "e77", "e112", "e127", "e128", "e131", "e134", "e135", "e136", "e149", "e161", "e162", "e166" ] }, { "id": "c-role-1", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — OW Capital Management GmbH. Capacity: Sole shareholder (100%). Period: Sole-shareholder entry from 28 May 2008; retained record in October 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance. A separate record’s 14 April 2006 legal-form date is not silently substituted for the July registration date. Changes of address and personal name in the filing history do not establish changes of ownership. The identically named German company with Munich number HRB 138024 is a separate entity. The subject is Austrian even though its shareholder and many industrial interests are connected to Russia.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d131", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d170", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d183", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d23", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d3", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d6", "s-d62", "s-d68", "s-d8", "s-d85", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-role-2", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — OW Capital Management GmbH. Capacity: Independently authorized managing director. Period: Managing-director mandate from 21 March 2012; retained record in October 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance. A separate record’s 14 April 2006 legal-form date is not silently substituted for the July registration date. Changes of address and personal name in the filing history do not establish changes of ownership. The identically named German company with Munich number HRB 138024 is a separate entity. The subject is Austrian even though its shareholder and many industrial interests are connected to Russia.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d131", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d170", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d23", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d24", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d3", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d6", "s-d62", "s-d68", "s-d85", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3" ] }, { "id": "c-role-4", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Negocianttrans LLC. Capacity: Holder of 50%. Period: 50% participant from 16 July 2024 in the retained register.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d120", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d139", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d19", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d204", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d242", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d353", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e6" ] }, { "id": "c-role-5", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — SK Khiminvest LLC (OGRN 1057746838973). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Recorded from 2005-05-05; entity ceased 10 November 2009; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e7" ] }, { "id": "c-role-6", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Dagmos LLP (liquidated). Capacity: Historic head of the company. Period: Historical head; company removed on 16 April 2007, which is not a proven appointment date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e8" ] }, { "id": "c-role-7", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: General director. Period: General-director entry from 23 August 2024; retained record in October 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "c-role-8", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — SK Khiminvest LLC (OGRN 1057746838973). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 10 November 2009; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e7" ] }, { "id": "c-role-10", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Trading House RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 3 million. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 17 May 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e10" ] }, { "id": "c-role-11", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Ural Railway Company CJSC. Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 140,000. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 2 November 2012; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e11" ] }, { "id": "c-role-12", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Tyubing Centrolit LLC. Capacity: Historic founder; reported 34.999%. Period: Source recorded 2024-12-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e12" ] }, { "id": "c-role-13", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Negocianttrans LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285", "s-d62" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e6" ] }, { "id": "c-role-14", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — New Investments CJSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Historic mandate: one directory says from 16 June 2008, another entry is dated 8 September 2022; appointment-date difference unresolved.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285", "s-d62" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e13" ] }, { "id": "c-role-15", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Negocianttrans LLC. Capacity: Holder of 50%. Period: 50% participant from 10 February 2014 in the retained register.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285", "s-d62" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e6" ] }, { "id": "c-role-16", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e14" ] }, { "id": "c-role-17", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e15" ] }, { "id": "c-role-18", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Controlling person; 87.8265% total-capital interest reported for the 2020 transaction. Period: Related-party transaction disclosure dated 16 November 2020.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The historical portfolio is not a current ownership certificate. ZMK’s total-capital percentage and the 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary voting shares described by the Russian court use different denominators. The 2020 related-party disclosure’s 87.8265% concerns the controlling individual at the transaction date, not necessarily OW’s direct fraction. A 2012 proposal referred to 25% plus one KVBZ share; the later confiscation identifies exactly 28,669,889 shares as 25%.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d19", "s-d344", "s-d68", "s-d89", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-19", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Assignee of ZMK loan claims against MASZ. Period: Assignment transaction on 16 November 2020 concerning 2017–2018 loans; subsequent repayment not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-20", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Lender through assigned MASZ claims. Period: Assignment transaction on 16 November 2020 concerning 2017–2018 loans; subsequent repayment not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e17" ] }, { "id": "c-role-21", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e18" ] }, { "id": "c-role-22", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gorelov Igor Mikhaylovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board chair. Period: Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e19" ] }, { "id": "c-role-23", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Krivoshein Mikhail Aleksandrovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e20" ] }, { "id": "c-role-24", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: General director and board member. Period: Source recorded 2020-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e21" ] }, { "id": "c-role-25", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ulyanov Igor Vladimirovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Historical board mandate; ended 11 April 2024.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d387", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d53", "s-d56", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e22" ] }, { "id": "c-role-26", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Third party in the KVBZ share-confiscation proceeding. Period: January 2026 confiscation proceeding; effective 27 January; transfer recorded April 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e23" ] }, { "id": "c-role-27", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Ministry of Justice of Ukraine. Capacity: Third party aligned with the defendant in the ministry claim. Period: January 2026 confiscation proceeding; effective 27 January; transfer recorded April 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e24" ] }, { "id": "c-role-28", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov. Capacity: Third-party company in the proceeding against its shareholder. Period: January 2026 confiscation proceeding; effective 27 January; transfer recorded April 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-role-29", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Historic holder of the 25% KVBZ stake. Period: 25% acquired in 2012; confiscation effective 27 January 2026 and register transfer reported 17 April 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d301", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d68", "s-d70", "s-d89" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e23" ] }, { "id": "c-role-30", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Holder of more than 70% of voting rights through the documented shareholding. Period: Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The historical portfolio is not a current ownership certificate. ZMK’s total-capital percentage and the 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary voting shares described by the Russian court use different denominators. The 2020 related-party disclosure’s 87.8265% concerns the controlling individual at the transaction date, not necessarily OW’s direct fraction. A 2012 proposal referred to 25% plus one KVBZ share; the later confiscation identifies exactly 28,669,889 shares as 25%.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d19", "s-d344", "s-d68", "s-d89", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-31", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — ENA JSC. Capacity: Holder of 96.17%. Period: Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The historical portfolio is not a current ownership certificate. ZMK’s total-capital percentage and the 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary voting shares described by the Russian court use different denominators. The 2020 related-party disclosure’s 87.8265% concerns the controlling individual at the transaction date, not necessarily OW’s direct fraction. A 2012 proposal referred to 25% plus one KVBZ share; the later confiscation identifies exactly 28,669,889 shares as 25%.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d19", "s-d344", "s-d68", "s-d89", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e25" ] }, { "id": "c-role-32", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Holder of 50% of Balakovo-Centrolit shares. Period: Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-role-33", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Lender to Balakovo-Centrolit. Period: Loans advanced in 2015–2016 and assigned claims; multi-lender balance reported at 31 December 2024 with November 2032 repayment limit.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-role-34", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Fofasio Limited. Capacity: Assignee of Fofasio claims against Balakovo-Centrolit. Period: Loans advanced in 2015–2016 and assigned claims; multi-lender balance reported at 31 December 2024 with November 2032 repayment limit.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e27" ] }, { "id": "c-role-35", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Controlling beneficiary and executive identified in the court record. Period: Court reconstruction of the 2024–2025 position, decided January 2026; later ownership not reconstructed here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d120", "s-d127", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d19", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d204", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d242", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d353", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "c-role-36", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gamzalov Dzhakhpar (Hungarian directory identity) — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Manager identified in the Hungarian directory. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e28" ] }, { "id": "c-role-40", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board chair. Period: Recorded from 2022-10-06; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e29" ] }, { "id": "c-role-41", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-10-06; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-42", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Murtazaliev Gadzhi Omarovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Board member in the 2022–2024 rosters; ended 29 November 2024.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e31" ] }, { "id": "c-role-43", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nersesyan Valentin Robertovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-10-06; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e32" ] }, { "id": "c-role-46", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ulyanov Igor Vladimirovich — RKK JSC. Capacity: Reported workplace. Period: Source recorded 2024-05-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e22", "e33" ] }, { "id": "c-role-47", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2024-05-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e21" ] }, { "id": "c-role-48", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rayvel Audit Company LLC — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: External auditor. Period: Source recorded 2023; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e34" ] }, { "id": "c-role-49", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Recorded from 2023-05-25; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-52", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ageev Andrey Aleksandrovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-04-11; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e35" ] }, { "id": "c-role-53", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-54", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Source recorded 2024-11-29; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-55", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nersesyan Valentin Robertovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Source recorded 2024-11-29; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e32" ] }, { "id": "c-role-56", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Source recorded 2024-11-29; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e29" ] }, { "id": "c-role-57", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zubov Stepan Sergeevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2026-04-27; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d57", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e36" ] }, { "id": "c-role-58", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mishin Nikita Viktorovich — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2026-07-14; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e26", "e37" ] }, { "id": "c-role-59", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Taratenko Aleksandr Aleksandrovich — SK Khiminvest LLC (OGRN 1057746838973). Capacity: Liquidator. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 10 November 2009; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e7", "e38" ] }, { "id": "c-role-61", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 225,000. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e14" ] }, { "id": "c-role-62", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 285,000. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e15" ] }, { "id": "c-role-63", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Elit-Trans LLC. Capacity: Former 50% participant. Period: Former 50% participation; register replacement recorded 27 June 2017.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e39" ] }, { "id": "c-role-64", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e25" ] }, { "id": "c-role-65", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-66", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e40" ] }, { "id": "c-role-67", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Antropov Anton Gennadevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e41" ] }, { "id": "c-role-68", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sheverdov Gleb Vyacheslavovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2022-06-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e42" ] }, { "id": "c-role-69", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rayvel Audit Company LLC — ENA JSC. Capacity: External auditor. Period: Source recorded 2022-06-02; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e34" ] }, { "id": "c-role-70", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2024-12-11; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e21" ] }, { "id": "c-role-71", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Privolzhsky Testing Centre LLC. Capacity: Founder; recorded contribution RUB 2,500. Period: Source recorded 2024-12-11; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e21", "e43" ] }, { "id": "c-role-72", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Historical 74.8% investment in the former BEHAN company. Period: Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e17" ] }, { "id": "c-role-73", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — ENA JSC. Capacity: Holder of 96.17%. Period: Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e25" ] }, { "id": "c-role-74", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Holder of 50% of Balakovo-Centrolit shares. Period: Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-role-76", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Historical 72.435% total-capital investment. Period: Portfolio description based on the 2016 balance sheet; current position requires separate evidence.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-77", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maksym Viktorovych Kramarenko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Board chair and director of KVBZ. Period: Recorded from 2025-04-25; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e45" ] }, { "id": "c-role-80", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; 34.37%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-role-81", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; 34.37%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e47" ] }, { "id": "c-role-82", "kind": "attributed", "text": "MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN) — OW Capital Management GmbH. Capacity: Borrower under claims assigned to OW. Period: Assignment transaction on 16 November 2020 concerning 2017–2018 loans; subsequent repayment not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e17" ] }, { "id": "c-role-83", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Proposed subscriber to the ZMK additional share issue; completion unconfirmed. Period: Resolution 28 March 2024; challenge rejected and upheld through April 2025; completed placement not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The court’s meeting date is 28 March, correcting a secondary account’s 28 April. The full April judgment is dated 18 April, following the operative ruling on 8 April; a mirror header has a different date. Judicial approval of the resolution is not proof that all proposed new shares were issued to Gamzalov. The retained 2025 accounts still report RUB 239,290 registered capital. The record does not establish a completed 99.9% direct personal holding.", "response": "ZMK said the funds would finance foundry capacity and reduce dependence on suppliers. The courts found no proven bad faith or impairment of the protected dividend rights and accepted disclosed Russian control when rejecting the foreign-state restriction argument. Appeals by later purchasers were terminated on standing grounds. A separate 2025 regulator-instruction challenge concerned placement disclosures and pre-emption periods; the retained report says interim relief was refused but does not establish a final merits result in that separate case.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d387", "s-d75" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-84", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Viktor Nikitenko — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Preferred shareholder challenging the share-issue decision. Period: Challenge rejected 15 October 2024; upheld 26 December 2024 and April 2025.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The court’s meeting date is 28 March, correcting a secondary account’s 28 April. The full April judgment is dated 18 April, following the operative ruling on 8 April; a mirror header has a different date. Judicial approval of the resolution is not proof that all proposed new shares were issued to Gamzalov. The retained 2025 accounts still report RUB 239,290 registered capital. The record does not establish a completed 99.9% direct personal holding.", "response": "ZMK said the funds would finance foundry capacity and reduce dependence on suppliers. The courts found no proven bad faith or impairment of the protected dividend rights and accepted disclosed Russian control when rejecting the foreign-state restriction argument. Appeals by later purchasers were terminated on standing grounds. A separate 2025 regulator-instruction challenge concerned placement disclosures and pre-emption periods; the retained report says interim relief was refused but does not establish a final merits result in that separate case.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d387", "s-d75" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e48" ] }, { "id": "c-role-85", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK) — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Purchaser of the old ELZ industrial assets. Period: Auction award 23 January 2023; purchase contract 1 February 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d399", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e55" ] }, { "id": "c-role-86", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — OW Capital Management GmbH. Capacity: Managing director who prepared the filed annual accounts. Period: Prepared the filed 2025 accounts.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Carrying values are not current sale values. The small-company filing does not identify every investment or reconstruct the present capitalization of each subsidiary. Its maturity table puts the liabilities within one year, while the narrative discusses creditor extensions; that presentation difference remains visible rather than being silently reconciled.", "response": "Management expressly states that there is no over-indebtedness within the meaning of insolvency law. It relies on expected recovery in investments after the Russia–Ukraine crisis and extensions individually agreed with creditors. Negative accounting equity alone is not presented here as a court declaration of insolvency.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d85", "s-d86" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3" ] }, { "id": "c-role-89", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Trading House RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 17 May 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e10" ] }, { "id": "c-role-90", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Ural Railway Company CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 2 November 2012; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e11" ] }, { "id": "c-role-91", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e50" ] }, { "id": "c-role-93", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Savin Evgeniy Aleksandrovich — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e51" ] }, { "id": "c-role-94", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Geoplant LLC — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Successor upon merger by accession. Period: Accession of Metpromgrupp CJSC completed 23 September 2015.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e52" ] }, { "id": "c-role-96", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Prospective purchaser in the July 2012 announcement. Period: Announced 11 July 2012; acquisition later reported completed 4 September 2012; 2026 state transfer stated separately.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d70", "s-d89", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e23" ] }, { "id": "c-role-97", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board chair. Period: Source recorded 2012-07-11; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-100", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK) — Ministry of Justice of Ukraine. Capacity: Defendant in the ministry request to recover 79 railway wagons. Period: Ministry claim announced 7 October 2026; final outcome not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ministry is a party stating its case. The retained announcement establishes a filed request, not a judgment transferring these 79 wagons or a conviction. This October proceeding must remain separate from the completed January KVBZ judgment and April register transfer.", "response": "No substantive response to this new claim, or final ruling on it, is established by the retained October announcement.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127", "s-d30", "s-d388" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e24" ] }, { "id": "c-role-101", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Reported historical controlling interest in ELZ. Period: Historical position described in retained proceedings; old ELZ liquidated 15 July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d129", "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e55" ] }, { "id": "c-role-103", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — OW Capital Management GmbH. Capacity: Controller of the company that held the historic KVBZ interest. Period: Source recorded 2026-01-27; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-role-106", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gart Marina Gennadievna — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e56" ] }, { "id": "c-role-107", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volkam Trading Ltd — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e57" ] }, { "id": "c-role-108", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rafelar Holdings Limited — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e58" ] }, { "id": "c-role-109", "kind": "attributed", "text": "VEB-Leasing Europe S.a.r.l. — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 15 July 2026; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e59" ] }, { "id": "c-role-110", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-111", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e25" ] }, { "id": "c-role-112", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e60" ] }, { "id": "c-role-113", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e40" ] }, { "id": "c-role-114", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sheverdov Gleb Vyacheslavovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2024-11-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e42" ] }, { "id": "c-role-115", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK) — ZMK-Trans JSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 14 October 2019; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e61" ] }, { "id": "c-role-116", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK) — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-role-117", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK) — PESA Saratov CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 7 April 2014; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e62" ] }, { "id": "c-role-118", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK) — Uralvagonzavod Research and Production Corporation JSC. Capacity: Supplier in the retained procurement records. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e63" ] }, { "id": "c-role-119", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2015-01-22; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e21" ] }, { "id": "c-role-120", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Privolzhsky Testing Centre LLC. Capacity: Registered founder of the testing company. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d136", "s-d15", "s-d387", "s-d53", "s-d56" ], "entity_ids": [ "e21", "e43" ] }, { "id": "c-role-122", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Maris CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e50", "e64" ] }, { "id": "c-role-123", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Resurs Invest CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e50", "e65" ] }, { "id": "c-role-124", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e50" ] }, { "id": "c-role-126", "kind": "attributed", "text": "New Investments CJSC — Engels Locomotive Plant LLC (2023). Capacity: 10% founder of the short-lived ELZ LLC. Period: Recorded from 2023-01-30; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e13", "e66" ] }, { "id": "c-role-127", "kind": "attributed", "text": "New Investments CJSC — Innovative Transport Laboratory LLC. Capacity: Former participant. Period: Ended by 2024-12-05.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e13", "e67" ] }, { "id": "c-role-128", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zolotukhina Olga Sergeevna — New Investments CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e13", "e68" ] }, { "id": "c-role-129", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Borisov Sergey Aleksandrovich — New Investments CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e13", "e69" ] }, { "id": "c-role-131", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK) — Engels Locomotive Plant LLC (2023). Capacity: 90% founder of the short-lived ELZ LLC. Period: Recorded from 2023-01-30; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e66" ] }, { "id": "c-role-133", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Pankov Ivan Anatolevich — Engels Locomotive Plant LLC (2023). Capacity: Former general director. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e66", "e70" ] }, { "id": "c-role-134", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Eleeva Olga Vladimirovna — Engels Locomotive Plant LLC (2023). Capacity: General director, then liquidator. Period: Recorded from 2023-02-28; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e66", "e71" ] }, { "id": "c-role-137", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volokhov Vitaliy Andreevich — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: General director, then liquidator. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e72" ] }, { "id": "c-role-138", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Khimresurs Plus CJSC — Kazan State Gunpowder Plant. Capacity: Supplier in the retained procurement records. Period: Historical procurement records; supplier liquidated 28 December 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e73" ] }, { "id": "c-role-139", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mishin Nikita Viktorovich — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2024-03-05; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e26", "e37" ] }, { "id": "c-role-140", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mishin Nikita Viktorovich — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: General director. Period: 2023-01-18–2024-03-01.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d19", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d290", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d58", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e37", "e74" ] }, { "id": "c-role-141", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zubov Stepan Sergeevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2019-06-28; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e36" ] }, { "id": "c-role-142", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gamzalov Dzhakhpar (Hungarian directory identity) — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Directory-reported owner; percentage and complete shareholder list unresolved. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e28" ] }, { "id": "c-role-143", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gamzalov Dzhakhpar (Hungarian directory identity) — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Manager identified in the Hungarian directory. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e28" ] }, { "id": "c-role-144", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rasul Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e75" ] }, { "id": "c-role-145", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Vladimir Petrovich Martiukov — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e76" ] }, { "id": "c-role-146", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ivan Alekseevich Vasyukov — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e77" ] }, { "id": "c-role-147", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Bargo Steel Ltd. Capacity: Person with significant influence or control; share percentage not specified. Period: Recorded from 2022-02-18; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285", "s-d62" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e78" ] }, { "id": "c-role-151", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Juliette Michel Clarisse — Bargo Steel Ltd. Capacity: Director. Period: Recorded from 2021-02-03; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285", "s-d62" ], "entity_ids": [ "e78", "e81" ] }, { "id": "c-role-153", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: Reported ownership or control in secondary reporting; exact direct interest unestablished. Period: Source recorded 2013-03-13; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e74" ] }, { "id": "c-role-154", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Reported ownership or control in secondary reporting; exact direct interest unestablished. Period: Source recorded 2013-03-13; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-role-155", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Khimresurs CJSC. Capacity: Adviser to the general director. Period: Source recorded 2013-03-13; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e83" ] }, { "id": "c-role-158", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ) — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e26", "e74" ] }, { "id": "c-role-159", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ulyanov Igor Vladimirovich — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e22", "e74" ] }, { "id": "c-role-160", "kind": "attributed", "text": "GS Finance & Trusts SIA — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e74", "e100" ] }, { "id": "c-role-161", "kind": "attributed", "text": "I.T.L. and Finance Limited — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e74", "e87" ] }, { "id": "c-role-162", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Melnichenko Vasiliy Vladimirovich — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2026-02-06; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e74", "e88" ] }, { "id": "c-role-163", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gruzd Boris Dmitrievich — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: General director during two separate recorded mandates. Period: 30 October 2018–18 January 2023 and 1 March 2024–6 February 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e74", "e89" ] }, { "id": "c-role-165", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Varnavskiy Aleksandr Nikolaevich — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: General director. Period: Ended by 2018-10-30.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e74", "e90" ] }, { "id": "c-role-166", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rasul Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Rus-Al LLC. Capacity: Former participant. Period: Ended by 2021-12-06.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e75", "e91" ] }, { "id": "c-role-167", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rasul Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Stroindustriya JSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e75", "e92" ] }, { "id": "c-role-168", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rasul Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Stroindustriya JSC. Capacity: Former company head. Period: Ended by 2016-12-15.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e75", "e92" ] }, { "id": "c-role-169", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Repetek LLC — ZMK-Trans JSC. Capacity: Successor to ZMK-Trans upon accession. Period: Merger by accession completed 14 October 2019.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e61", "e93" ] }, { "id": "c-role-170", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Korzunov Viktor Valerevich — ZMK-Trans JSC. Capacity: Director. Period: Director recorded from 16 June 2014; company ended by accession on 14 October 2019.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e61", "e94" ] }, { "id": "c-role-172", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Konoplev Sergey Georgievich — PESA Saratov CJSC. Capacity: Chair of the liquidation commission. Period: Recorded from 2013-05-22; entity ceased 7 April 2014; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e62", "e95" ] }, { "id": "c-role-173", "kind": "attributed", "text": "PESA Saratov CJSC — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2014-04-07; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e62" ] }, { "id": "c-role-175", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rail Vehicles PESA Bydgoszcz SA — PESA Saratov CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 7 April 2014; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e62", "e96" ] }, { "id": "c-role-177", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Juliette Michel Clarisse — Bargo Steel Ltd. Capacity: Director. Period: Source recorded 2026-02-28; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285", "s-d62" ], "entity_ids": [ "e78", "e81" ] }, { "id": "c-role-179", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich — Metpromgrupp LLC. Capacity: Sole participant (100%). Period: Recorded from 2025-02-12; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e60", "e97" ] }, { "id": "c-role-180", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich — Lokolizing LLP (Kazakhstan). Capacity: Company head recorded in the Kazakhstan directory. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-08; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e60", "e98" ] }, { "id": "c-role-182", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Eliseev Konstantin Vasilevich — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: General director. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e99" ] }, { "id": "c-role-184", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Savin Evgeniy Aleksandrovich — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 250,000. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e51" ] }, { "id": "c-role-186", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 25,000. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 23 September 2015; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e50" ] }, { "id": "c-role-187", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gamzalov Roman Askhabovich — Irtysh Capital LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2024-06-13; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e101", "e102" ] }, { "id": "c-role-188", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gamzalov Roman Askhabovich — SKL LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2021-05-19; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e101", "e103" ] }, { "id": "c-role-189", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich — Lokolizing LLP (Kazakhstan). Capacity: Director. Period: Recorded from 2025-09-23; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e60", "e98" ] }, { "id": "c-role-190", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Historical supervisory-board mandate, ended 5 September 2021.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e18", "e25" ] }, { "id": "c-role-191", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Antropov Anton Gennadevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2021-06-15; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e41" ] }, { "id": "c-role-192", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zubov Stepan Sergeevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Supervisory-board mandate 16 June–5 September 2021; distinct from general-director office.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e36" ] }, { "id": "c-role-193", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sheverdov Gleb Vyacheslavovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2021-06-15; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e42" ] }, { "id": "c-role-194", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Grekov Andrey Sergeevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2021-06-15; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e104" ] }, { "id": "c-role-195", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rayvel Audit Company LLC — ENA JSC. Capacity: External auditor. Period: Source recorded 2021-06-15; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e34" ] }, { "id": "c-role-196", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e55" ] }, { "id": "c-role-197", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e18", "e55" ] }, { "id": "c-role-198", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nersesyan Valentin Robertovich — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e32", "e55" ] }, { "id": "c-role-199", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Raydugin Vyacheslav Ivanovich — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Reported former co-owner and respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e105" ] }, { "id": "c-role-200", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rafelar Holdings Limited — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e58" ] }, { "id": "c-role-201", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volkam Trading Ltd — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Respondent to the rejected subsidiary-liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e57" ] }, { "id": "c-role-202", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Pankov Ivan Anatolevich — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Former director and respondent to the rejected liability claim. Period: Liability application in 2022; rejected 28 November 2022, upheld February and April 2023.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e70" ] }, { "id": "c-role-203", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dowden Investments Ltd — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Reported holder of 60% in the historical ownership snapshot. Period: Historical 2009–2017 ownership records; registry-field removal does not establish the disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d204", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e106" ] }, { "id": "c-role-204", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Reva Sergey Nikolaevich — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Reported holder of 20% in the historical ownership snapshot. Period: Historical 2009–2017 ownership records; registry-field removal does not establish the disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e107" ] }, { "id": "c-role-205", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nemirko Viktor Mikhaylovich — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Reported holder of 20% in the historical ownership snapshot. Period: Historical 2009–2017 ownership records; registry-field removal does not establish the disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e108" ] }, { "id": "c-role-206", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL). Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2023-03-01; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e109" ] }, { "id": "c-role-208", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gruzd Boris Dmitrievich — Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2026-02-06; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e89", "e109" ] }, { "id": "c-role-209", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Pankov Ivan Anatolevich — Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL). Capacity: General director. Period: Ended by 2026-02-06.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e70", "e109" ] }, { "id": "c-role-210", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL) — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e109" ] }, { "id": "c-role-212", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Melnik Denis Evgenevich — Stroindustriya JSC. Capacity: Liquidator and former general director. Period: Recorded from 2019-07-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e92", "e110" ] }, { "id": "c-role-215", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Akhapkina Natalya Valerevna — Metpromgrupp LLC. Capacity: Former participant and general director. Period: Ended by 2025-02-12.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e97", "e111" ] }, { "id": "c-role-216", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sultanov Pavel Viktorovich — Metpromgrupp LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2025-02-12; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d265", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d456", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d64", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e97", "e112" ] }, { "id": "c-role-217", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Metpromgrupp LLC — Metpromgrupp CJSC (ceased 2015). Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2026-09-08; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e14", "e97" ] }, { "id": "c-role-218", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Metpromgrupp LLC — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Party in a listed economic dispute; merits and outcome unestablished. Period: Recorded from 2025-12-12; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e97" ] }, { "id": "c-role-220", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nemirko Viktor Mikhaylovich — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e108" ] }, { "id": "c-role-221", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Reva Sergey Nikolaevich — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e107" ] }, { "id": "c-role-222", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dowden Investments Ltd — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Historic registered participant. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e106" ] }, { "id": "c-role-223", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Murtazaliev Gadzhi Omarovich — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: General director. Period: Ended by 2024-08-23.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e31" ] }, { "id": "c-role-224", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK) — Sirius LLC. Capacity: Former participant in Sirius. Period: Ended by 2024-12-23.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e113" ] }, { "id": "c-role-226", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Construction Company Khiminvest LLC (OGRN 1027739156587) — Trading House RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 17 May 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e10", "e114" ] }, { "id": "c-role-228", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ural Railway Company CJSC — Metpromgrupp LLC. Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2022-01-02; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e11", "e97" ] }, { "id": "c-role-229", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zinovev Aleksey Mikhaylovich — Tyubing Centrolit LLC. Capacity: Sole participant (100%). Period: Recorded from 2020-02-14; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e12", "e115" ] }, { "id": "c-role-230", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Tyubing Centrolit LLC — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Ended by 2019-05-07.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e12", "e26" ] }, { "id": "c-role-231", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — Elit-Trans LLC. Capacity: Former participant. Period: Ended by 2017-06-27.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e39" ] }, { "id": "c-role-232", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Bankruptcy debtor; counterparty identified as another case participant. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d399", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e55" ] }, { "id": "c-role-233", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — Volkam Trading Ltd. Capacity: Bankruptcy debtor; counterparty identified as another case participant. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d399", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e57" ] }, { "id": "c-role-234", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gamzalov Dzhakhpar (Hungarian directory identity) — MASZ Csoport Kft. (formerly BEHAN). Capacity: Directory-reported owner; percentage and complete shareholder list unresolved. Period: Source recorded 2026-03-09; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d248", "s-d292", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74" ], "entity_ids": [ "e17", "e28" ] }, { "id": "c-role-235", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA JSC — Gidromash MK CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 18 December 2017; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d135", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d143", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d202", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d63", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e116" ] }, { "id": "c-role-236", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA JSC — Remstroyservis LLC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 April 2003; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e117" ] }, { "id": "c-role-237", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA JSC — Trading House Shchelkovo Pumps–ENA CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 9 February 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d135", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d143", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d202", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d63", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e118" ] }, { "id": "c-role-238", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA JSC — Remservice-ENA CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 25 September 2009; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d135", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d143", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d202", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d63", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e119" ] }, { "id": "c-role-239", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA JSC — Magnitoprovody ENA CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 29 April 2011; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d135", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d143", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d202", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d63", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e120" ] }, { "id": "c-role-240", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Murtazaliev Gadzhi Omarovich — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: General director. Period: 2021-02-20–2024-08-23.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e31" ] }, { "id": "c-role-241", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Murtazaliev Gadzhi Omarovich — Engels Locomotive Plant LLC (2023). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2023-01-30; entity ceased 29 September 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e31", "e66" ] }, { "id": "c-role-243", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nemirko Viktor Mikhaylovich — Railtransservice LLC. Capacity: Founder during the recorded 2014–2016 period. Period: 2014-08-08–2016-11-10.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d120", "s-d19", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d27", "s-d353", "s-d87" ], "entity_ids": [ "e108", "e121" ] }, { "id": "c-role-246", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK) — First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK). Capacity: Participant in the same ELZ bankruptcy as PLK. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d399", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e80" ] }, { "id": "c-role-247", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Former deputy general director for commercial and economic affairs. Period: Former capacity expressly described in the retained source; exact end date not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e18" ] }, { "id": "c-role-249", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Karakhanyan Vladimir Karpovich — Gidromash MK CJSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2003-01-20; entity ceased 18 December 2017; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e116", "e122" ] }, { "id": "c-role-250", "kind": "attributed", "text": "ENA JSC — Remstroyservis LLC. Capacity: Historic participant; recorded contribution RUB 2,100. Period: Recorded from 2003-04-17; entity ceased 28 April 2003; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e117" ] }, { "id": "c-role-256", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Resurs Invest CJSC. Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 25,000. Period: Historic founder entry; field deletion is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e50", "e65" ] }, { "id": "c-role-257", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Maris CJSC. Capacity: Historic founder; reported 4.9%. Period: Historic founder entry; field deletion is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e50", "e64" ] }, { "id": "c-role-258", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Wagon Building Plant JSC (VSZ). Capacity: Reported ownership or control in secondary reporting; exact direct interest unestablished. Period: Source recorded 2024-06-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e74" ] }, { "id": "c-role-259", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL) — Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK). Capacity: Operator at the industrial site reportedly acquired by IKK. Period: Source recorded 2024-06-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e109" ] }, { "id": "c-role-260", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Skinest Finants AS — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Holder of 25% in the September 2021 snapshot. Period: Shareholding snapshot 30 September 2021; subsequent control records have separate dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e123" ] }, { "id": "c-role-261", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Delantina OU — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Holder of 25% in the September 2021 snapshot. Period: Shareholding snapshot 30 September 2021; subsequent control records have separate dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e124" ] }, { "id": "c-role-262", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Transbuilding Service Limited — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Holder of 20% in the September 2021 snapshot. Period: Shareholding snapshot 30 September 2021; subsequent control records have separate dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e125" ] }, { "id": "c-role-263", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Historical indirect KVBZ beneficiary through OW; not personally 90%. Period: Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d297", "s-d360", "s-d491", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e23" ] }, { "id": "c-role-264", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Reported beneficiary and supervisory-board chair. Period: Source recorded 2021-09-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-role-265", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Vadym Duzyk. Capacity: Company represented by Duzyk on the KVBZ supervisory board. Period: Representative from September 2021; mandate ended 6 June 2022.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e126" ] }, { "id": "c-role-266", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Skinest Finants AS. Capacity: Reported direct beneficial interest. Period: Recorded from 2018-10-26; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e123" ] }, { "id": "c-role-267", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Skinest Finants AS. Capacity: Reported direct beneficial interest. Period: Recorded from 2018-10-26; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e123" ] }, { "id": "c-role-268", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Transbuilding Service Limited. Capacity: Person with significant control; reported 25–50% band. Period: Recorded from 2022-09-01; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e125" ] }, { "id": "c-role-269", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Transbuilding Service Limited. Capacity: Person with significant control; reported 25–50% band. Period: Recorded from 2022-09-01; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e125" ] }, { "id": "c-role-270", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Delantina OU. Capacity: Holder of 50% in the September 2023 register entry. Period: Recorded from 2023-09-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e124" ] }, { "id": "c-role-271", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Delantina OU. Capacity: Holder of 50% in the September 2023 register entry. Period: Recorded from 2023-09-02; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e124" ] }, { "id": "c-role-272", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Historical indirect beneficiary through OW. Period: Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d301", "s-d360", "s-d487", "s-d491", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e23" ] }, { "id": "c-role-274", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: 2021-04-22–2021-09.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e18", "e23" ] }, { "id": "c-role-275", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dzhakhpar Askhabovich Gamzalov — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Board member. Period: Recorded from 2008; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e18" ] }, { "id": "c-role-276", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Tyutyunnik Nataliya Vitalevna — Rayvel Audit Company LLC. Capacity: Holder of 50%. Period: Recorded from 2003-01-30; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e34", "e127" ] }, { "id": "c-role-277", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dymova Zoya Nikolaevna — Rayvel Audit Company LLC. Capacity: Holder of 50%. Period: Recorded from 2003-01-30; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e34", "e128" ] }, { "id": "c-role-278", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Tyutyunnik Nataliya Vitalevna — Rayvel Audit Company LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2011-10-11; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e34", "e127" ] }, { "id": "c-role-279", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — VEB-Leasing JSC. Capacity: Bankruptcy debtor in the proceeding initiated by VEB-Leasing. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d307", "s-d399", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e129" ] }, { "id": "c-role-280", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — Rafelar Holdings Limited. Capacity: Bankrupt company whose shareholder faced a rejected liability claim. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e58" ] }, { "id": "c-role-281", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — Volkam Trading Ltd. Capacity: Bankrupt company whose shareholder faced a rejected liability claim. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e57" ] }, { "id": "c-role-282", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rafelar Holdings Limited — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Holder of 42.55% of voting shares in the historical court account. Period: Historical position described in retained proceedings; old ELZ liquidated 15 July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e58" ] }, { "id": "c-role-283", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volkam Trading Ltd — Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ). Capacity: Holder of 42.55% of voting shares in the historical court account. Period: Historical position described in retained proceedings; old ELZ liquidated 15 July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e57" ] }, { "id": "c-role-284", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK). Capacity: Lender to PLK for the locomotive investment project. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e80" ] }, { "id": "c-role-285", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — VEB-Leasing JSC. Capacity: Borrower from VEB-Leasing under the documented project loans. Period: Historical ELZ bankruptcy or project-financing capacity; bankruptcy completed May 2026 and debtor liquidated July 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e129" ] }, { "id": "c-role-286", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov. Capacity: Co-plaintiff in the ZMK grain-wagon contract action. Period: Grain-wagon contract litigation; dismissal reported February 2025 with appeals pending at that report.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-role-287", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Shareholder bringing a claim in ZMK’s interest. Period: Grain-wagon contract litigation; dismissal reported February 2025 with appeals pending at that report.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-288", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Combined holding with Gamzalov reported above 74.2%; individual split unstated. Period: Combined ownership described in the February 2025 contract-case report; direct split not supplied.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-289", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov. Capacity: Co-shareholder in ZMK in the reported combined holding. Period: Combined ownership described in the February 2025 contract-case report; direct split not supplied.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-role-290", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK) — Viktor Nikitenko. Capacity: Issuer defending the preferred shareholder’s issue challenge. Period: Challenge rejected 15 October 2024; upheld 26 December 2024 and April 2025.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The court’s meeting date is 28 March, correcting a secondary account’s 28 April. The full April judgment is dated 18 April, following the operative ruling on 8 April; a mirror header has a different date. Judicial approval of the resolution is not proof that all proposed new shares were issued to Gamzalov. The retained 2025 accounts still report RUB 239,290 registered capital. The record does not establish a completed 99.9% direct personal holding.", "response": "ZMK said the funds would finance foundry capacity and reduce dependence on suppliers. The courts found no proven bad faith or impairment of the protected dividend rights and accepted disclosed Russian control when rejecting the foreign-state restriction argument. Appeals by later purchasers were terminated on standing grounds. A separate 2025 regulator-instruction challenge concerned placement disclosures and pre-emption periods; the retained report says interim relief was refused but does not establish a final merits result in that separate case.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d387", "s-d75" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e48" ] }, { "id": "c-role-291", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Holder of 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary shares; approximately 96.58% of that class. Period: Ordinary-voting-share count described in the April 2025 judgment; denominator differs from total capital.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The court’s meeting date is 28 March, correcting a secondary account’s 28 April. The full April judgment is dated 18 April, following the operative ruling on 8 April; a mirror header has a different date. Judicial approval of the resolution is not proof that all proposed new shares were issued to Gamzalov. The retained 2025 accounts still report RUB 239,290 registered capital. The record does not establish a completed 99.9% direct personal holding.", "response": "ZMK said the funds would finance foundry capacity and reduce dependence on suppliers. The courts found no proven bad faith or impairment of the protected dividend rights and accepted disclosed Russian control when rejecting the foreign-state restriction argument. Appeals by later purchasers were terminated on standing grounds. A separate 2025 regulator-instruction challenge concerned placement disclosures and pre-emption periods; the retained report says interim relief was refused but does not establish a final merits result in that separate case.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d387", "s-d75" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16" ] }, { "id": "c-role-294", "kind": "attributed", "text": "First Locomotive Holding AG (Switzerland) — First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK). Capacity: Sole parent (100%) of PLK. Period: Sole parent from 12 August 2014; PLK liquidated 24 November 2025.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e80", "e130" ] }, { "id": "c-role-295", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK). Capacity: General director. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 24 November 2025; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e40", "e80" ] }, { "id": "c-role-296", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: 2015-10-12–2016-09-16.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e26", "e40" ] }, { "id": "c-role-297", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2016-10-12; entity ceased 24 November 2025; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e40", "e80" ] }, { "id": "c-role-298", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — New Industrial Engineering LLC (NPI). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2022-11-03; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d452", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e40", "e131" ] }, { "id": "c-role-303", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rasul Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Rus-Al LLC. Capacity: Former 50% participant; recorded contribution RUB 5,000. Period: 2014-04-23–2021-12-06.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e75", "e91" ] }, { "id": "c-role-304", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gasanov Ali Magomedkamilovich — Rus-Al LLC. Capacity: 50% participant and general director. Period: Recorded from 2014-04-23; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e91", "e132" ] }, { "id": "c-role-305", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stolbun Maksim Leonidovich — Privolzhsky Testing Centre LLC. Capacity: Holder of 25%; recorded contribution RUB 2,500. Period: Recorded from 2011-04-15; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e21", "e43" ] }, { "id": "c-role-306", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Privolzhsky Testing Centre LLC — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2016-02-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e43" ] }, { "id": "c-role-308", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya JSC (PTP) — Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK). Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2024-11-05; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e133" ] }, { "id": "c-role-309", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya JSC (PTP) — Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC (new EZL). Capacity: Reported investment project at the newer locomotive plant’s site. Period: Source recorded 2024-11-05; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e109", "e133" ] }, { "id": "c-role-310", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Korzhuk Mikhail Valerevich — Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya JSC (PTP). Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2024-04-18; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e133", "e134" ] }, { "id": "c-role-311", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Dr. Thilo Aurel Michel Pachmann — First Locomotive Holding AG (Switzerland). Capacity: Sole board member with individual signature. Period: Board member recorded March 2014; holding company bankrupt September 2023 and removed January 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e130", "e135" ] }, { "id": "c-role-312", "kind": "attributed", "text": "OBT AG — First Locomotive Holding AG (Switzerland). Capacity: Historic audit appointment. Period: Audit appointment in March 2014 incorporation publication; later mandate not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e130", "e136" ] }, { "id": "c-role-315", "kind": "attributed", "text": "New Industrial Engineering LLC (NPI) — New Investments CJSC. Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Ended by 2023-03-30.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e13", "e131" ] }, { "id": "c-role-316", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nersesyan Valentin Robertovich — New Industrial Engineering LLC (NPI). Capacity: Sole participant (100%). Period: Recorded from 2022-11-03; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e32", "e131" ] }, { "id": "c-role-319", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Transleasing-Alliance CJSC. Capacity: Chair of the liquidation commission. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e137" ] }, { "id": "c-role-320", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Liquidator. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e138" ] }, { "id": "c-role-321", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Spetskompani LLC. Capacity: Company head during the recorded 2016–2021 mandate. Period: 2016-12-16–2021-12-21.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e139" ] }, { "id": "c-role-322", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Transleasing-Alliance CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e137" ] }, { "id": "c-role-323", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Trading Company RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historic register entry; deletion of the founder field is not a proven disposal date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e140" ] }, { "id": "c-role-324", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Spetskompani LLC. Capacity: Founder during the recorded 2011–2021 period. Period: 2011-12-09–2021-12-21.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e139" ] }, { "id": "c-role-326", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Inter Cargo Company JSC (IKK) — Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov. Capacity: Co-defendant in the pending ministry wagon claim. Period: Ministry claim announced 7 October 2026; final outcome not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The ministry is a party stating its case. The retained announcement establishes a filed request, not a judgment transferring these 79 wagons or a conviction. This October proceeding must remain separate from the completed January KVBZ judgment and April register transfer.", "response": "No substantive response to this new claim, or final ruling on it, is established by the retained October announcement.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127", "s-d30", "s-d388" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "c-role-328", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Mitrakhov Aleksey Sergeevich — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: Historic founder; recorded contribution RUB 15,000. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e50" ] }, { "id": "c-role-329", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volokhov Vitaliy Andreevich — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e72" ] }, { "id": "c-role-330", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Astashenkova Alla Vasilevna — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: Former general director. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e141" ] }, { "id": "c-role-331", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Solovev Gennadiy Arsentevich — Khimresurs Plus CJSC. Capacity: Former general director. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 28 December 2023; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e15", "e142" ] }, { "id": "c-role-333", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sultanov Pavel Viktorovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e112" ] }, { "id": "c-role-335", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Pavlyukevich Andrey Anatolevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e143" ] }, { "id": "c-role-336", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e29" ] }, { "id": "c-role-337", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rusanova Natalya Aleksandrovna — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2011-06-30; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e144" ] }, { "id": "c-role-338", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rayvel Audit Company LLC — ENA JSC. Capacity: External auditor. Period: Source recorded 2011-06-30; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e34" ] }, { "id": "c-role-339", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Kintana Investments Limited (historical ENA shareholder) — ENA JSC. Capacity: Proposed subscriber for 267,661 new shares under the 2011 resolution. Period: Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e145" ] }, { "id": "c-role-340", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Acorient Constructions Ltd — ENA JSC. Capacity: Proposed subscriber for 475,287 new shares under the 2011 resolution. Period: Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e146" ] }, { "id": "c-role-341", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Omni Eurotrading Ltd — ENA JSC. Capacity: Proposed subscriber for 394,847 new shares under the 2011 resolution. Period: Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e147" ] }, { "id": "c-role-342", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maltesert Group Inc. — ENA JSC. Capacity: Proposed subscriber for 462,205 new shares under the 2011 resolution. Period: Private-placement resolution 30 June 2011; completion of the allocated subscriptions not established here.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e148" ] }, { "id": "c-role-343", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Omni Eurotrading Ltd — ENA JSC. Capacity: Holder of 22.54% in the May–June 2012 disclosure. Period: Shareholding disclosed from 4 May 2012 in the June 2012 issuer record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e147" ] }, { "id": "c-role-344", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Acorient Constructions Ltd — ENA JSC. Capacity: Holder of 24.9% in the May–June 2012 disclosure. Period: Shareholding disclosed from 4 May 2012 in the June 2012 issuer record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e146" ] }, { "id": "c-role-345", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maltesert Group Inc. — ENA JSC. Capacity: Holder of 24.9% in the May–June 2012 disclosure. Period: Shareholding disclosed from 4 May 2012 in the June 2012 issuer record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e148" ] }, { "id": "c-role-346", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Abarkin Denis Aleksandrovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Recorded from 2012-06-29; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e149" ] }, { "id": "c-role-347", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Board roster during 1 January–28 November 2024; reporting-period start is not an appointment date.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e60" ] }, { "id": "c-role-348", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Murtazaliev Gadzhi Omarovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Supervisory-board roster through 28 November 2024.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e31" ] }, { "id": "c-role-349", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Source recorded 2024-11-28; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-350", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e25" ] }, { "id": "c-role-351", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-352", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Magomedov Magomed Akhmedinovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e60" ] }, { "id": "c-role-353", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Meshkov Roman Vladimirovich — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e40" ] }, { "id": "c-role-354", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zubov Stepan Sergeevich — ENA JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: Office recorded throughout the 2025 reporting year; report dates are not appointment and resignation dates.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e36" ] }, { "id": "c-role-355", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Kintana Investments Limited (historical ENA shareholder) — ENA JSC. Capacity: Holding reduced to 19.69% from 23.69% on 24 January 2012. Period: Reduction reported effective 24 January 2012; no termination of the remaining 19.69% established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e145" ] }, { "id": "c-role-358", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Sultanov Pavel Viktorovich — Private Security Company NOIS-11 LLC. Capacity: Historic founder and general director. Period: Source recorded 2025-02-12; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e112", "e150" ] }, { "id": "c-role-360", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ibragim Stanislavovich Gamzalov — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Recorded from 2021-09-06; later status not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e30" ] }, { "id": "c-role-361", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ryumina Natalya Vladimirovna — ENA JSC. Capacity: Supervisory-board member. Period: Ended by 2021-06-15.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409", "s-d63" ], "entity_ids": [ "e25", "e151" ] }, { "id": "c-role-363", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maltesert Group Inc. — Unitrust Corporate Services Ltd.. Capacity: Company for which Unitrust was the recorded intermediary. Period: Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e148", "e153" ] }, { "id": "c-role-364", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Verter Holdings Ltd — Maltesert Group Inc.. Capacity: Historic shareholder in the ICIJ record. Period: Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e148", "e154" ] }, { "id": "c-role-365", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Juan Jose Tenorio Rodriguez — Maltesert Group Inc.. Capacity: Director. Period: 18 November 2005–15 October 2009.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e148", "e155" ] }, { "id": "c-role-366", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Danette Sandra Tania Athanase — Maltesert Group Inc.. Capacity: Director. Period: Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e148", "e156" ] }, { "id": "c-role-367", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Standard Directors Ltd. — Maltesert Group Inc.. Capacity: Incorporation director. Period: Historic ICIJ record, data through 2010; current capacity not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e148", "e157" ] }, { "id": "c-role-371", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — Transleasing-Alliance CJSC. Capacity: Chair of the liquidation commission. Period: Recorded from 2009-11-23; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e137" ] }, { "id": "c-role-373", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Acorient Constructions Ltd — Transleasing-Alliance CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e137", "e146" ] }, { "id": "c-role-374", "kind": "attributed", "text": "FELEDINO HOLDINGS LIMITED — Transleasing-Alliance CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 30 June 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e137", "e160" ] }, { "id": "c-role-377", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Abarkin Denis Aleksandrovich — Vossloh Fastening Systems Rus JSC. Capacity: General director. Period: 2019-02-15–2022-02-17.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e149", "e161" ] }, { "id": "c-role-378", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Abarkin Denis Aleksandrovich — Foresight Engineering Centre LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: 2025-10-03–2026-01-30.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d15", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456", "s-d64" ], "entity_ids": [ "e149", "e162" ] }, { "id": "c-role-379", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Konstantinos Parmaxis — Fofasio Limited. Capacity: Director. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e27", "e163" ] }, { "id": "c-role-380", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maria Michailidou Misailidou — Fofasio Limited. Capacity: Secretary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e27", "e164" ] }, { "id": "c-role-381", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gorelov Igor Mikhaylovich — RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e19", "e138" ] }, { "id": "c-role-382", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Gorelova Galina Ivanovna — RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Historic registered founder. Period: Historical capacity; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e138", "e165" ] }, { "id": "c-role-383", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Chabrov Evgeniy Sergeevich — RusUkrVagon CJSC. Capacity: Liquidator. Period: Recorded from 2009-11-27; entity ceased 19 July 2010; role did not continue beyond that event.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e29", "e138" ] }, { "id": "c-role-385", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Reestr JSC — Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya JSC (PTP). Capacity: Shareholder registrar; not an equity owner. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e133", "e166" ] }, { "id": "c-role-387", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — OW Capital Management GmbH. Capacity: Controller of the company that held the historic KVBZ interest. Period: Source recorded 2021-10-18; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-role-392", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Acorient Constructions Ltd — Fofasio Limited. Capacity: Recorded shared business site. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "A shared business site is not proof of common ownership or control. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e27", "e146" ] }, { "id": "c-role-393", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Menelaos Sazos — Acorient Constructions Ltd. Capacity: Director. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e146", "e167" ] }, { "id": "c-role-394", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Panagiota Christofi — Acorient Constructions Ltd. Capacity: Secretary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e146", "e168" ] }, { "id": "c-role-395", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; rounded 34.4%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e47" ] }, { "id": "c-role-396", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; 34.37%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e169" ] }, { "id": "c-role-397", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Kremenchuk Mechanical Products Plant JSC (KrZMV). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; 35.6%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e170" ] }, { "id": "c-role-398", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — YUTS LLC. Capacity: Holder of 75%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e171" ] }, { "id": "c-role-400", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maksym Viktorovych Kramarenko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e45" ] }, { "id": "c-role-401", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Maksym Viktorovych Kramarenko — PRFD LLC. Capacity: Former owner or beneficiary; exact former interest unstated. Period: Former capacity expressly described in the retained source; exact end date not established.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e45", "e172" ] }, { "id": "c-role-402", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e46" ] }, { "id": "c-role-403", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Kremenchuk Mechanical Products Plant JSC (KrZMV). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; 35.6%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e170" ] }, { "id": "c-role-404", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — PRFD LLC. Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary; 12%. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e172" ] }, { "id": "c-role-405", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e169" ] }, { "id": "c-role-406", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko. Capacity: Parallel disclosed corporate interests; no family relationship inferred. Period: Source recorded 2026-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480", "s-d70" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e47" ] }, { "id": "c-role-408", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: Historical indirect interest through KVBZ and OW. Period: Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e169" ] }, { "id": "c-role-409", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — V.N.V. LLC. Capacity: Historical indirect interest through KVBZ and OW. Period: Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e173" ] }, { "id": "c-role-410", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ) — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: Sole parent (100%). Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e169" ] }, { "id": "c-role-411", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e169" ] }, { "id": "c-role-412", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Nataliia Viktorivna Prykhodko — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e47", "e169" ] }, { "id": "c-role-413", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Rukavichko Sergiy Mikolayovich — Instrumentalnyi Zavod LLC (IZ). Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e169", "e174" ] }, { "id": "c-role-415", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ) — V.N.V. LLC. Capacity: Sole parent (100%). Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e173" ] }, { "id": "c-role-416", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov — V.N.V. LLC. Capacity: Stale beneficiary entry; historical chain ended after the 2026 parent-stake transfer. Period: Historical indirect chain through OW and KVBZ; OW stake passed to the state in 2026.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d130", "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e173" ] }, { "id": "c-role-417", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Volodymyr Ivanovych Prykhodko — V.N.V. LLC. Capacity: Reported indirect beneficiary. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e46", "e173" ] }, { "id": "c-role-418", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Ovchar Igor Oleksandrovich — V.N.V. LLC. Capacity: General director. Period: Source recorded 2026-10-10; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e173", "e175" ] }, { "id": "c-role-422", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ) — V.N.V. LLC. Capacity: Sole parent (100%). Period: Source recorded 2026-09-17; underlying event date and later status depend on the cited record.", "qualification": "The capacity is source-qualified and dated; it does not transfer another participant’s conduct or prove a current mandate. An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e23", "e173" ] }, { "id": "c-role-elz-veb-memorandum", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (old ELZ) — Vnesheconombank (VEB.RF). Capacity: Participant with Vnesheconombank in the project-cooperation memorandum. Period: Memorandum signed 4 June 2013; separate VEB-Leasing loans described in the judgment.", "qualification": "The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e55", "e3001" ] }, { "id": "c-role-bcl-other-half", "kind": "attributed", "text": "RRR Holdings Limited / Kirk-Investment — Balakovo-Centrolit JSC. Capacity: Holder of the other 50% in the documented 2024 capital structure. Period: 2024 position reconstructed in the January 2026 judgment.", "qualification": "The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d19", "s-d290", "s-d58" ], "entity_ids": [ "e26", "e3002" ] }, { "id": "c-role-zmk-mosregiontrans", "kind": "attributed", "text": "Zavod Metallokonstruktsy JSC (ZMK) — MosRegionTrans. Capacity: Supplier under the contested contract for 1,000 grain wagons. Period: June 2022 contract; renewed dismissal reported February 2025 with appeals pending.", "qualification": "The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e16", "e3003" ] }, { "id": "c-overview-company", "kind": "analysis", "text": "OW Capital Management is an Austrian holding company whose retained records name Stanislav Gamzalov as sole shareholder and Irina Gamzalova as managing director. Its industrial portfolio spans distinct companies and dates. The filed 2025 accounts show negative equity, but management expressly disputes over-indebtedness under insolvency law and relies on recovery prospects and creditor extensions.", "qualification": "The Austrian balance sheet is not consolidated industrial revenue or a present market valuation. The 2016 portfolio cannot be read as a current ownership register.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d131", "s-d15", "s-d170", "s-d19", "s-d23", "s-d3", "s-d344", "s-d6", "s-d68", "s-d85", "s-d86", "s-d89", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16", "e17", "e23", "e25", "e26", "e27", "e3", "e5" ] }, { "id": "c-overview-ukraine", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The 25% shareholding in Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ) left OW following Ukraine’s January 2026 sanctions-confiscation judgment and the April register transfer to the state. A September court order later lifted the arrest of the wholly owned V.N.V. subsidiary’s capital because the relevant parent stake had already passed to the state. In October the ministry brought a separate claim seeking 79 wagons from Gamzalov and Inter Cargo Company.", "qualification": "The ministry’s new request is not a completed recovery. The share-confiscation judgment is not a criminal conviction, and the V.N.V. arrest release is not an acquittal on every allegation. OW and the individual did not provide substantive responses in the confiscation case; nonappearance is not an admission.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127", "s-d129", "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d27", "s-d30", "s-d360", "s-d388", "s-d444", "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491", "s-d67", "s-d7", "s-d70", "s-d8", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16", "e169", "e173", "e175", "e23", "e24", "e25", "e26", "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "c-overview-outcomes", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Russian proceedings reached different results on different claims. The subsidiary-liability demand in the bankruptcy of the original Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (ELZ) was rejected and the appellate courts found no proved culpable conduct sufficient for that liability. The plant’s assets were sold, its bankruptcy completed and the old company liquidated. Zavod Metallokonstruktsy (ZMK) successfully defended its share-issue resolution, while OW’s separate grain-wagon contract action was again dismissed in the retained February 2025 account, with appeals then pending.", "qualification": "An auction asset purchaser does not automatically own every new company at the site. A valid share-issue resolution does not establish a completed subscription. The later companies, legal claims and historic founder records remain separately identified.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d15", "s-d203", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d261", "s-d264", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340", "s-d341", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d387", "s-d399", "s-d456", "s-d75", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e105", "e109", "e129", "e13", "e133", "e134", "e16", "e166", "e18", "e3001", "e3003", "e31", "e32", "e48", "e5", "e55", "e56", "e57", "e58", "e59", "e66", "e70", "e71", "e80", "e89", "e9" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-0a449204c5de9fe2c07bab4e", "kind": "analysis", "text": "OW Capital Management is an Austrian holding company whose retained records name Stanislav Gamzalov as sole shareholder and Irina Gamzalova as managing director. Its industrial portfolio spans distinct companies and dates. The filed 2025 accounts show negative equity, but management expressly disputes over-indebtedness under insolvency law and relies on recovery prospects and creditor extensions.", "qualification": "The Austrian balance sheet is not consolidated industrial revenue or a present market valuation. The 2016 portfolio cannot be read as a current ownership register.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d131", "s-d15", "s-d170", "s-d19", "s-d23", "s-d3", "s-d344", "s-d6", "s-d68", "s-d85", "s-d86", "s-d89", "s-d90" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16", "e17", "e23", "e25", "e26", "e27", "e3", "e5" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-6e1d6c26b4b79fc3da402ed3", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The 25% shareholding in Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ) left OW following Ukraine’s January 2026 sanctions-confiscation judgment and the April register transfer to the state. A September court order later lifted the arrest of the wholly owned V.N.V. subsidiary’s capital because the relevant parent stake had already passed to the state. In October the ministry brought a separate claim seeking 79 wagons from Gamzalov and Inter Cargo Company.", "qualification": "The ministry’s new request is not a completed recovery. The share-confiscation judgment is not a criminal conviction, and the V.N.V. arrest release is not an acquittal on every allegation. OW and the individual did not provide substantive responses in the confiscation case; nonappearance is not an admission.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d127", "s-d129", "s-d130", "s-d19", "s-d27", "s-d30", "s-d360", "s-d388", "s-d444", "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491", "s-d67", "s-d7", "s-d70", "s-d8", "s-d9" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16", "e169", "e173", "e175", "e23", "e24", "e25", "e26", "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-f73f62cf281fd4856c77e686", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Russian proceedings reached different results on different claims. The subsidiary-liability demand in the bankruptcy of the original Engels Locomotive Plant JSC (ELZ) was rejected and the appellate courts found no proved culpable conduct sufficient for that liability. The plant’s assets were sold, its bankruptcy completed and the old company liquidated. Zavod Metallokonstruktsy (ZMK) successfully defended its share-issue resolution, while OW’s separate grain-wagon contract action was again dismissed in the retained February 2025 account, with appeals then pending.", "qualification": "An auction asset purchaser does not automatically own every new company at the site. A valid share-issue resolution does not establish a completed subscription. The later companies, legal claims and historic founder records remain separately identified.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d15", "s-d203", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d261", "s-d264", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340", "s-d341", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d387", "s-d399", "s-d456", "s-d75", "s-d82" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e105", "e109", "e129", "e13", "e133", "e134", "e16", "e166", "e18", "e3001", "e3003", "e31", "e32", "e48", "e5", "e55", "e56", "e57", "e58", "e59", "e66", "e70", "e71", "e80", "e89", "e9" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-ee0b334fa1cd28dc670a6527", "kind": "analysis", "text": "OW Capital Management GmbH is the Austrian holding company registered as FN 278008k, with EUID ATBRA.278008-000 and VAT number ATU62706735. The retained registry-derived records identify Stanislav Dzhakhparovich Gamzalov as its sole shareholder, entered on 28 May 2008, and Irina Vyacheslavovna Gamzalova as its independently authorized managing director from 21 March 2012. Its registered capital grew from €35,000 to €335,000 in 2007 and to €735,000 in 2008. The company was entered in the register on 14 July 2006.", "qualification": "A separate record’s 14 April 2006 legal-form date is not silently substituted for the July registration date. Changes of address and personal name in the filing history do not establish changes of ownership. The identically named German company with Munich number HRB 138024 is a separate entity. The subject is Austrian even though its shareholder and many industrial interests are connected to Russia.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d3", "s-d6", "s-d23", "s-d68", "s-d85", "s-d131", "s-d170" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3", "e5" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-9daccff569034577f32ddd04", "kind": "analysis", "text": "OW’s filed 2025 small-company accounts report assets of €70,349,859.90, including €41,647,014.87 of financial investments and €12,356,017.38 cash. Liabilities were €119,829,335.72 and equity was negative €49,490,876.82. The investment schedule records acquisition cost of €86,612,040.87 and accumulated impairment of €44,965,026.00. The accounts report no employees. These figures describe the Austrian holding company, not consolidated revenue or assets of every industrial investment.", "qualification": "Carrying values are not current sale values. The small-company filing does not identify every investment or reconstruct the present capitalization of each subsidiary. Its maturity table puts the liabilities within one year, while the narrative discusses creditor extensions; that presentation difference remains visible rather than being silently reconciled.", "response": "Management expressly states that there is no over-indebtedness within the meaning of insolvency law. It relies on expected recovery in investments after the Russia–Ukraine crisis and extensions individually agreed with creditors. Negative accounting equity alone is not presented here as a court declaration of insolvency.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d85", "s-d86" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-308370c6494562acbc5b7407", "kind": "analysis", "text": "A description based on OW’s 2016 balance sheet listed interests of 72.435% in Zavod Metallokonstruktsy (ZMK), 96.17% in ENA, 50% in Balakovo-Centrolit, 74.8% in BEHAN, now identified as MASZ, and 25% in Kryukiv Railway Car Building Works (KVBZ). Later evidence has to be read investment by investment. The 2026 Ukrainian judgment retained the 96.17% ENA and 50% Balakovo-Centrolit positions, while the KVBZ interest passed to the Ukrainian state.", "qualification": "The historical portfolio is not a current ownership certificate. ZMK’s total-capital percentage and the 17,333 of 17,947 ordinary voting shares described by the Russian court use different denominators. The 2020 related-party disclosure’s 87.8265% concerns the controlling individual at the transaction date, not necessarily OW’s direct fraction. A 2012 proposal referred to 25% plus one KVBZ share; the later confiscation identifies exactly 28,669,889 shares as 25%.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d19", "s-d68", "s-d89", "s-d90", "s-d344" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e16", "e17", "e23", "e25", "e26", "e27" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-390e330c1c28b952f5a3ee90", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Inter Cargo Company is the Russian transport-leasing company OGRN 1097746377530. Registry history records Gadzhi Murtazaliev’s general-director mandate from February 2021 to August 2024, followed by Stanislav Gamzalov. The 2026 Ukrainian judgment identifies Gamzalov as its beneficiary and controlling executive. Older public records described Dowden Investments at 60% and Sergey Reva and Viktor Nemirko at 20% each in a 2017 ownership snapshot.", "qualification": "Removal of founder fields from the Russian joint-stock register in 2022 is not evidence of a completed sale that day. The old 60/20/20 snapshot does not conclusively identify present shareholders. Property taxes and trademark entries do not identify the beneficial owner of every property or establish that the taxes relate specifically to the purchased ELZ site. The pending October wagon claim and the old ELZ asset transaction have different legal statuses.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d10", "s-d19", "s-d27", "s-d87", "s-d120", "s-d204", "s-d242", "s-d261", "s-d262", "s-d263", "s-d353" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9", "e31", "e106", "e107", "e108" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-621f8fb350bdd7ec5ac2aa68", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The retained sanctions records identify OW by the same FN 278008k and identify Stanislav Gamzalov separately. They report Ukrainian restrictions under decree 279/2023 from 12 May 2023 for five years, including asset blocking. The subsequent Ukrainian confiscation judgment expressly applies the sanctions framework to the identified shareholder and the OW-held KVBZ stake.", "qualification": "Aggregator candidate warnings and control-based tags are screening leads, not separate convictions or proof of a designation by every jurisdiction. This dossier does not certify the absence of sanctions elsewhere. A sanction, a civil confiscation decision and a criminal finding of guilt are different legal events.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d7", "s-d8", "s-d9", "s-d19", "s-d27", "s-d67", "s-d444" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e9" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-21ecf353ed93771191dfb828", "kind": "analysis", "text": "On 7 October 2026 Ukraine’s Ministry of Justice announced a new High Anti-Corruption Court claim against Stanislav Gamzalov and Inter Cargo Company seeking recovery of 79 railway wagons. Its announcement alleged that the enterprises materially supported Russia’s armed aggression and referred to the earlier KVBZ recovery.", "qualification": "The ministry is a party stating its case. The retained announcement establishes a filed request, not a judgment transferring these 79 wagons or a conviction. This October proceeding must remain separate from the completed January KVBZ judgment and April register transfer.", "response": "No substantive response to this new claim, or final ruling on it, is established by the retained October announcement.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d30", "s-d127", "s-d388" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9", "e24" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-94f56b5a0ea0dc3bbf04ae6f", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Irina Gamzalova’s former Mitrakhova name is connected by retained register histories, including the same Companies House person-with-significant-control record for Bargo Steel Ltd, number 13176974. That UK record describes significant influence or control, not a disclosed 100% shareholding. Bargo was incorporated in February 2021, and Juliette Michel Clarisse is its recorded director. Its February 2026 accounts report no fixed assets, cash of £2,487 and net assets of £277. New Investments’ 2025 directory accounts report RUB 45.5 million revenue, RUB 16.6 million net profit and RUB 116.1 million assets. Its property and transport tax payments indicate taxable assets but do not identify individual properties or vehicles.", "qualification": "Small balances and a director’s many appointments do not prove illicit activity or a nominee arrangement. In Russia, the retained records identify Irina as general director of New Investments and Negocianttrans. Negocianttrans’s two reported 50% participants are Irina and Stanislav, the latter from July 2024. Those corporate capacities can be presented without residential addresses, personal tax identifiers or assumptions about family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d11", "s-d62", "s-d138", "s-d139", "s-d147", "s-d151", "s-d152", "s-d180", "s-d181", "s-d285" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3", "e5", "e6", "e13", "e78", "e81" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-f1358d3ccdf48d3ffa7ec0cf", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The professional network includes directors, managers, the Rayvel audit company, registrars and former officers with assignments in more than one industrial enterprise. Rayvel’s records identify Nataliia Tiutiunnyk and Zoya Dymova as equal participants and Tiutiunnyk as general director. ENA and ZMK issuer materials establish the audit and governance roles independently of mere name similarity. Registry histories distinguish completed outside mandates from ongoing source-date entries.", "qualification": "Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d64", "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e18", "e19", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e32", "e34", "e36", "e37", "e40", "e43", "e60", "e76", "e77", "e112", "e127", "e128", "e131", "e134", "e135", "e136", "e149", "e161", "e162", "e166" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-2e50a1c5b363426932394646", "kind": "analysis", "text": "On 14 January 2026 the High Anti-Corruption Court of Ukraine ordered 28,669,889 KVBZ shares held by OW, representing 25% of capital and nominal value UAH 21,502,416.75, recovered for the state. The full decision was prepared on 16 January. The issuer’s 17 April disclosure says the judgment took effect on 27 January and that the register received on 15 April changed OW’s interest from 25% to zero and the state’s from zero to 25% of capital, or 25.0717% of voting shares. The earlier 2022 ARMA arrangement was management of the arrested securities account, not a transfer of ownership.", "qualification": "The ruling is a sanctions confiscation decision, not a criminal conviction. The personal name is redacted in the official judgment; the unique OW identity, ownership and issuer records support the corporate chain without publishing private identifiers. Registry history entries from earlier years cannot postpone or erase the documented 2026 transfer.", "response": "The court records that the individual did not appear and provided no substantive response. OW also did not appear or supply substantive explanations; the court considered its notice through published notices adequate. The KVBZ representative supported the ministry’s claim despite the company’s formal third-party alignment on the defendant’s side. Nonappearance is not an admission.", "outcome": "The April issuer disclosure supplies the completed transfer, beyond the January ruling alone. A separate 7 April order lifted the earlier arrest of the 25% stake and took effect on 14 April. The historical OW–KVBZ ownership edges therefore end with the 2026 confiscation and recorded transfer.", "source_ids": [ "s-d19", "s-d70", "s-d130", "s-d360", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e23", "e24" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-e85411c85db072b948d6268e", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Ukrainian court found that Gamzalov controlled Inter Cargo Company and, through OW, held the documented interests in ZMK, ENA and Balakovo-Centrolit. It relied on Russian tax payments and specified industrial contracts when applying the statutory grounds for recovery. The judgment discusses ZMK rail-related supply contracts and ENA pump contracts, including a 2017 shipyard contract as well as civil and nuclear-sector customers.", "qualification": "These are the court’s findings and reasoning in that sanctions case. Historic contracts are not proof of new shipments in 2026. The court’s aggregate tax calculation is not a payment made by OW itself, nor does the ownership chain establish that every director personally participated in each industrial transaction. The judgment is not generalized here into a criminal conviction of the network.", "response": "The court records nonappearance and no substantive explanations from OW or the individual, while KVBZ supported the claim. The separate Russian ELZ liability litigation reached a favorable result for its defendants on different claims and must not be conflated with this sanctions proceeding.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d19", "s-d129" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e9", "e16", "e23", "e25", "e26" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-24b1c5446eaa0061bb006277", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The retained company records identify Instrumentalnyi Zavod (IZ, registration 21073227) and V.N.V. (39564144) as wholly owned KVBZ subsidiaries. Gamzalov’s recorded relationship was an indirect interest through the parent, not an independently established personal holding of all their shares. On 17 September 2026 the Holosiivskyi district court granted V.N.V.’s application to lift the arrest of 100% of its capital. The order explains that the OW-held KVBZ stake had already passed to the state.", "qualification": "An October directory still showing Gamzalov as V.N.V.’s beneficiary is a stale or unreconciled entry in light of the court and issuer records. A directory’s generic founder label does not convert indirect control into a direct personal shareholding. The release order is not an acquittal on all allegations in the underlying criminal investigation.", "response": "The prosecutor did not attend and the requested investigation materials were not supplied. The court found no evidence establishing the continuing need for the restriction and granted the company’s request; the order states that it was not subject to appeal.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d487", "s-d488", "s-d489", "s-d490", "s-d491" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e23", "e169", "e173", "e175" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-da8c1da41e5db985fbb79dbf", "kind": "analysis", "text": "KVBZ’s September 2021 disclosure identified OW at 25%, Skinest Finants at 25%, Delantina at 25% and Transbuilding Service at 20%. Later Estonian, UK and Ukrainian records connect Volodymyr and Nataliia Prykhodko with interests through other holdings. Dzhakhpar Gamzalov represented OW on the supervisory board until September 2021, and Vadym Duzyk’s OW representative mandate ended in June 2022. The parent’s 2025 directory financials report UAH 2.617 billion revenue and a UAH 124.57 million net loss.", "qualification": "Later control records dated 2018, 2022 or 2023 do not automatically prove the same chain at every earlier shareholding date. Co-investment in KVBZ does not make the Prykhodko network an OW subsidiary. The historic indirect Gamzalov chain ended with the documented 2026 state transfer, and generic directory founder labels must not create a direct personal stake in its subsidiaries. Corporate capacities are retained without inferring private family relationships.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d70", "s-d297", "s-d298", "s-d299", "s-d300", "s-d301", "s-d302", "s-d360", "s-d477", "s-d478", "s-d480" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e18", "e23", "e45", "e46", "e47", "e123", "e124", "e125", "e126", "e169", "e170", "e171", "e172", "e173", "e174" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-2dfe929c9ed433e72182bf2a", "kind": "analysis", "text": "ZMK’s issuer reports document changing boards and a continuing general-director role for Maxim Stolbun. The 2020 board included Igor Gorelov, Dzhakhpar Gamzalov, Mikhail Krivoshein, Stolbun and Igor Ulyanov. Later boards introduced Evgeny Chabrov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Gadzhi Murtazaliev, Valentin Nersesyan and Andrey Ageev. Irina Gamzalova joined the disclosed board from 29 November 2024. The company reported RUB 26.192 billion revenue and RUB 3.285 billion net profit in 2025, compared with RUB 33.691 billion and RUB 5.433 billion in 2024.", "qualification": "Board membership is dated and does not prove a personal equity holding. A report covering a year is not automatically an appointment on 1 January or a resignation on 31 December. Auditor and registrar roles are service relationships. Procurement totals and trademark records do not establish misconduct by individual board members. The retained annual reports distinguish the Dzhakhpar and Ibragim roles; a later press description of Dzhakhpar as Stanislav’s father is not relied upon.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d53", "s-d56", "s-d136", "s-d387" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e16", "e18", "e19", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e29", "e30", "e31", "e32", "e34", "e35", "e63" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-b6436437ab9ddbbed92c86b7", "kind": "analysis", "text": "ZMK’s 28 March 2024 extraordinary meeting approved a proposed private placement of 5,055,201 additional ordinary shares at RUB 10 nominal value. The Russian cassation judgment records 17,333 OW votes out of 17,947 ordinary shares, about 96.58% of that voting class. A holder of 519 preferred shares challenged the issue, alleging an improper price, dilution, lack of investment need and an impermissible foreign-controlled vote. The court rejected the claim; the 15 October 2024 decision was upheld on 26 December 2024 and in April 2025.", "qualification": "The court’s meeting date is 28 March, correcting a secondary account’s 28 April. The full April judgment is dated 18 April, following the operative ruling on 8 April; a mirror header has a different date. Judicial approval of the resolution is not proof that all proposed new shares were issued to Gamzalov. The retained 2025 accounts still report RUB 239,290 registered capital. The record does not establish a completed 99.9% direct personal holding.", "response": "ZMK said the funds would finance foundry capacity and reduce dependence on suppliers. The courts found no proven bad faith or impairment of the protected dividend rights and accepted disclosed Russian control when rejecting the foreign-state restriction argument. Appeals by later purchasers were terminated on standing grounds. A separate 2025 regulator-instruction challenge concerned placement disclosures and pre-emption periods; the retained report says interim relief was refused but does not establish a final merits result in that separate case.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d75", "s-d343", "s-d344", "s-d356", "s-d387" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e16", "e48", "e56" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-271e42e603143ebfa3c5ee53", "kind": "analysis", "text": "OW and Gamzalov also sued in ZMK’s interest to invalidate a June 2022 contract with MosRegionTrans for 1,000 grain wagons worth RUB 4.5 billion. The February 2025 report describes a renewed dismissal after remand, with appeals accepted and a hearing then scheduled for 5 March. This contract dispute is distinct from the shareholder challenge to ZMK’s additional share issue.", "qualification": "The contract’s size is not an adjudicated loss. The retained February account does not establish the eventual outcome of the accepted appeals. Its combined ownership description does not split the individual’s and OW’s direct percentages.", "response": "Gamzalov argued that shareholder approval was absent and a 5% advance would create an extraordinary financing burden. The defendant produced an audio recording said to show his approval. A valuation expert and the court considered phased batches of about 50 wagons financially feasible, with such advances common in large contracts. The court rejected the interpretation that all deliveries had to occur on a single day.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d341" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e16", "e3003" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-3dda91b9b1fa2ac47fa3efcc", "kind": "analysis", "text": "ENA’s disclosures show an older ownership layer before the 96.17% OW holding described in the Ukrainian judgment. A 2011 resolution named Kintana, Acorient, Omni and Maltesert in a private share placement. By the June 2012 affiliated-person list, Omni held 22.54%, Acorient 24.9% and Maltesert 24.9%; a January 2012 disclosure had reduced Kintana’s interest from 23.69% to 19.69%. These are dated ownership events, not a simultaneous current cap table.", "qualification": "The sources do not establish that all those offshore shareholders were beneficially owned by Gamzalov. A placement resolution is distinct from a completed transfer. ENA’s 2024 and 2025 reports identify changing supervisory boards, including Meshkov, Ibragim Gamzalov, Irina Gamzalova, Sheverdov and Magomedov in the later roster. Dzhakhpar’s 2021 mandate ended before Ibragim’s began in September; the two people must not be merged. The 2024 report lists RUB 1.5925 billion revenue and RUB 132 million capital, not OW’s standalone revenue.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d63", "s-d135", "s-d143", "s-d202", "s-d249", "s-d251", "s-d400", "s-d402", "s-d403", "s-d404", "s-d406", "s-d407", "s-d409" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e3", "e18", "e25", "e30", "e36", "e38", "e40", "e41", "e42", "e60", "e112", "e143", "e144", "e145", "e146", "e147", "e148", "e149" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-c060fdd5cde179188a674b47", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The archive traces corporate-service and historic officer records around Fofasio, Acorient and Maltesert, and a separately identified Latvian GS Finance & Trusts company. The ICIJ data describe a historic Maltesert shareholder and service-provider chain; they do not themselves prove a link to OW’s ultimate owner. The exact Acorient Cyprus registration HE 187773 is corroborated by issuer and directory identity data.", "qualification": "The issuer’s historical Kintana name has not been conclusively reconciled with the candidate Cyprus registration HE 266685. Directory snapshots also conflict over whether that candidate was dissolved or active and name different officers. Those candidate officers are therefore not attached to the issuer shareholder as established identities. Many service-company appointments do not by themselves prove a nominee relationship or wrongdoing. Offshore registration is not an adverse finding.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d190", "s-d196", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d434", "s-d435", "s-d439", "s-d440", "s-d445", "s-d474", "s-d508" ], "entity_ids": [ "e27", "e100", "e106", "e145", "e146", "e148", "e153", "e154", "e155", "e156", "e157", "e163", "e164", "e167", "e168" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-64b049277a236e09450b339a", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Ukrainian judgment describes Balakovo-Centrolit as owned 50% by OW and 50% by RRR Holdings, later redomiciled as Kirk-Investment, in 2024. OW advanced US$10.635 million under 2015–2016 loan contracts, and also received claims assigned by Fofasio. The US$81.3563 million loan balance at 31 December 2024 was owed to several lenders, including OW, with repayment due no later than November 2032.", "qualification": "The total multi-lender balance is not wholly an OW loan. A debt assignment is different from equity ownership. Press accounts describing Gamzalov’s wider control of Balakovo industrial plants do not supply a complete present direct share register for VSZ. Nikita Mishin’s successive executive roles at VSZ and Balakovo-Centrolit are dated offices, not personal ownership.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d19", "s-d58", "s-d142", "s-d156", "s-d290" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e26", "e27", "e37", "e40", "e74", "e3002" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-94cc8a85a871d04683e36592", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The Hungarian company is MASZ Csoport Kft., registration 07-09-028907 and tax number 12390652-2-07; the retained company-history directory identifies its earlier BEHAN name. The 74.8% OW interest belongs to the 2016 portfolio description. On 16 November 2020 ZMK assigned OW its claims under five MASZ loans originating in 2017 and 2018. Contemporary directories identify Gamzalov Dzhakhpar as a manager, and one calls him an owner, while another counts three owners without naming them.", "qualification": "The record does not resolve current ownership percentages or conclusively equate that Hungarian manager with the full-name ZMK board member. A manager’s name alone cannot close that identity gap. Reported blocked accounts, enforcement and negative-information flags do not establish an insolvency judgment. Directories report losses and substantial financial expenses, but those figures do not prove that OW’s assigned loans caused the losses. The 2024 directory table distinguishes HUF 373.950 million of net sales from HUF 379.246 million of total income. The latter adds HUF 4.269 million of other income and HUF 1.027 million of financial income; these are different measures, not conflicting revenues.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d20", "s-d68", "s-d69", "s-d73", "s-d74", "s-d123", "s-d124", "s-d145", "s-d248", "s-d292" ], "entity_ids": [ "e1", "e16", "e17", "e28", "e76", "e77" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-da1f75c20e200c8948c67240", "kind": "analysis", "text": "In the bankruptcy of the original Engels Locomotive Plant JSC, a request sought RUB 27.293 billion of subsidiary liability from former controlling persons. The application was rejected on 28 November 2022, and that result was upheld on 14 February and 13 April 2023. The April judgment describes Rafelar Holdings and Volkam Trading each holding 42.55% of the voting shares from December 2013. It distinguishes Vnesheconombank’s participation in the June 2013 cooperation memorandum from VEB-Leasing’s direct loans to ELZ. ELZ in turn lent to First Locomotive Company for the Bombardier project.", "qualification": "The amount sought is not an award against the defendants. The published court text redacts individual names; press identifications are separately attributed and do not authorize silently assigning every redacted finding to a named person. Loans of RUB 4.83 billion and RUB 300 million from ELZ to the project company are not, merely because related, an adjudicated diversion.", "response": "The defendants sought to uphold the rejection. The courts found that external market conditions, including loss of the Ukrainian customer market, affected the project. Management pursued Russian customers, prototypes and certification; VEB-Leasing knew and monitored the purposes of its project loans. Unlawful culpable actions sufficient for the claimed liability were not proved. In December 2024 the courts also invalidated creditor-committee decisions demanding renewed liability steps and withholding the trustee’s compensation because the committee exceeded its powers.", "outcome": "The favorable 2022–2023 liability outcome remains attached to the historic allegations. Invalidating the later committee decisions does not bar every possible future claim on different grounds.", "source_ids": [ "s-d133", "s-d134", "s-d203", "s-d247", "s-d307", "s-d308", "s-d340" ], "entity_ids": [ "e5", "e18", "e32", "e55", "e57", "e58", "e59", "e70", "e80", "e105", "e129", "e3001" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-4993d859650b843372502e6c", "kind": "analysis", "text": "Inter Cargo Company won the auction for the original ELZ industrial complex on 23 January 2023; a three-party purchase contract followed on 1 February. The reported RUB 2.85 billion price concerned the combined lot, while RUB 2.124 billion described the debtor’s pledged-property portion. The later fee litigation records different creditor-recovery percentages at different dates. The bankruptcy was completed by a 12 May 2026 order despite the creditors’ earlier opposition, and the company was subsequently recorded as liquidated on 15 July 2026.", "qualification": "Acquiring industrial assets is not acquiring the old debtor’s shares or automatically owning every new company at the same site. The 2024 reversal in the fee dispute did not undo the entire bankruptcy or establish the liability request. Press claims of affiliation with the buyer are allegations, not substitutes for the court’s separate ownership and conduct findings.", "response": "Creditors disputed completion and compensation. In the later fee appeal the court reduced the trustee’s percentage remuneration to RUB 4,025,812.34 after accounting for the work and unpaid fee of the assisting organization, rather than reinstating the much larger earlier request.", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d82", "s-d204", "s-d235", "s-d247", "s-d264", "s-d399" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e55", "e129" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-52c9919b3945019f1c8321be", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The archive contains three different locomotive-plant identities: the old bankrupt JSC, OGRN 1116449006123; a Moscow LLC formed on 30 January 2023, OGRN 1237700072015; and Engels Plant of Locomotives JSC, OGRN 1236400002431, formed on 1 March 2023. The short-lived LLC was owned 90% by Inter Cargo Company and 10% by New Investments, and was liquidated on 29 September 2023. The newer JSC operated at the old industrial site; its directory history records Boris Gruzd replacing Ivan Pankov as general director in February 2026.", "qualification": "A similar name, reused site or former manager does not merge these legal entities. The purchase of old ELZ assets does not by itself establish the current shareholders of the new JSC. A separate reported industrial project, Promyshlennye Tekhnologii Povolzhya (PTP, OGRN 1246400005125), shares ZMK’s business site and registrar, but its shareholders are not disclosed in the retained public register. The registrar is not its owner.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d138", "s-d140", "s-d204", "s-d206", "s-d261", "s-d290", "s-d294", "s-d357", "s-d358", "s-d381", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e9", "e13", "e31", "e55", "e66", "e70", "e71", "e89", "e109", "e133", "e134", "e166" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-015d70127b4385e028eb207d", "kind": "analysis", "text": "First Locomotive Company LLC (PLK, OGRN 1127747221161) had Swiss First Locomotive Holding AG, CHE-380.001.522, as its sole participant from August 2014. The Russian company entered bankruptcy in November 2022 and was liquidated on 24 November 2025. The retained Swiss publication history separately records the holding company’s bankruptcy on 8 September 2023 and removal on 8 January 2026. Roman Meshkov’s historic management positions in PLK, Balakovo-Centrolit and ENA link professional roles without making those companies identical.", "qualification": "The holding company’s ultimate owner is not established. Thilo Pachmann’s Swiss board position and OBT’s historic audit appointment do not identify a Gamzalov beneficial holding. The lawyer’s mandates for other clients are not treated as hidden assets of this group. Russian litigation totals, tax amounts and unsuccessful enforcement records in directories are dated summaries, not additional personal liability judgments.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d346", "s-d349", "s-d350", "s-d363", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d389", "s-d452" ], "entity_ids": [ "e40", "e80", "e130", "e135", "e136" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-4990c52feeae826e637d4d25", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The wider register preserves historical founders, officers, successors and commercial connections around the industrial companies. Several named companies had already ceased operating long before a 2021 or 2022 database deletion of their founder fields. The old Metpromgrupp closed joint-stock company merged into Geoplant in 2015; the similarly named LLC is a separate legal entity whose 2025 record names Magomed Magomedov as sole participant and Pavel Sultanov as director. ZMK-Trans ended through accession to Repetek in 2019. Other ENA-linked companies were liquidated in 2003, 2009, 2010 or 2011.", "qualification": "A deleted founder field is not automatically an ownership disposal. A historic founder is not necessarily the current shareholder, and a liquidated company is not a current operating asset. Similar names, shared professional contacts or the same business site do not prove succession, common beneficial ownership or a family relationship. The accepted graph labels the supported capacity and its dated limit; it does not revive these entities as a present group. Negative search results are not complete beneficial-ownership clearance.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d9", "s-d10", "s-d11", "s-d59", "s-d62", "s-d87", "s-d88", "s-d134", "s-d136", "s-d137", "s-d141", "s-d172", "s-d176", "s-d177", "s-d178", "s-d187", "s-d188", "s-d193", "s-d194", "s-d195", "s-d196", "s-d199", "s-d200", "s-d201", "s-d228", "s-d229", "s-d230", "s-d231", "s-d232", "s-d243", "s-d244", "s-d245", "s-d246", "s-d280", "s-d281", "s-d282", "s-d283", "s-d284", "s-d289", "s-d293", "s-d354", "s-d355", "s-d362", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d392", "s-d396", "s-d397", "s-d408", "s-d441", "s-d443", "s-d444", "s-d446", "s-d453", "s-d461" ], "entity_ids": [ "e3", "e5", "e6", "e7", "e8", "e10", "e11", "e12", "e13", "e14", "e15", "e16", "e25", "e43", "e50", "e51", "e52", "e60", "e61", "e62", "e64", "e65", "e74", "e75", "e83", "e87", "e88", "e89", "e90", "e91", "e92", "e93", "e94", "e95", "e96", "e97", "e98", "e99", "e100", "e101", "e102", "e103", "e104", "e106", "e107", "e108", "e110", "e111", "e112", "e113", "e114", "e115", "e116", "e117", "e118", "e119", "e120", "e121", "e131", "e132", "e137", "e138", "e139", "e140", "e141", "e142", "e149", "e160", "e161", "e162", "e165" ] }, { "id": "display-claim-850a9767ed800deaa500695a", "kind": "analysis", "text": "The professional network includes directors, managers, the Rayvel audit company, registrars and former officers with assignments in more than one industrial enterprise. Rayvel’s records identify Nataliia Tiutiunnyk and Zoya Dymova as equal participants and Tiutiunnyk as general director. ENA and ZMK issuer materials establish the audit and governance roles independently of mere name similarity. Registry histories distinguish completed outside mandates from ongoing source-date entries.", "qualification": "Employment, board membership and professional services do not transfer an enterprise’s conduct to every professional. No claim is made that the audit engagement verified every transaction or excluded fraud. The Hungarian manager’s abbreviated name remains distinct from the full-name ZMK person until exact identity evidence resolves it. Personal biographies and unrelated clients are not treated as ownership evidence.", "response": "", "outcome": "", "source_ids": [ "s-d15", "s-d64", "s-d142", "s-d143", "s-d145", "s-d265", "s-d309", "s-d311", "s-d349", "s-d365", "s-d366", "s-d381", "s-d382", "s-d383", "s-d385", "s-d389", "s-d404", "s-d408", "s-d409", "s-d443", "s-d456" ], "entity_ids": [ "e18", "e19", "e20", "e21", "e22", "e28", "e29", "e30", "e32", "e34", "e36", "e37", "e40", "e43", "e60", "e76", "e77", "e112", "e127", "e128", "e131", "e134", "e135", "e136", "e149", "e161", "e162", "e166" ] } ], "sources": [ { "id": "s-d3", "title": "Corporate registry source · s-d3", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d6", "title": "Other source · s-d6", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d7", "title": "Other source · s-d7", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d8", "title": "Other source · s-d8", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d9", "title": "Other source · s-d9", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d10", "title": "Other source · s-d10", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d11", "title": "Other source · s-d11", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d15", "title": "Company statement source · s-d15", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d19", "title": "Court record concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "Judiciary of Ukraine", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://court.gov.ua/storage/portal/hcac/administrative/judgments/991_12957_25_14.01.2026.pdf" }, { "id": "s-d20", "title": "Other source · s-d20", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d23", "title": "Other source · s-d23", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d24", "title": "Other source · s-d24", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d27", "title": "Other source · s-d27", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d30", "title": "Media source · s-d30", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d53", "title": "Company statement source · s-d53", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d56", "title": "Company statement source · s-d56", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d57", "title": "Other source · s-d57", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d58", "title": "Other source · s-d58", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d59", "title": "Other source · s-d59", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d62", "title": "Other source · s-d62", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d63", "title": "Company statement source · s-d63", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d64", "title": "Other source · s-d64", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d67", "title": "Other source · s-d67", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d68", "title": "Other source · s-d68", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d69", "title": "Other source · s-d69", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d70", "title": "Other source · s-d70", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d73", "title": "Other source · s-d73", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d74", "title": "Other source · s-d74", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d75", "title": "Media source · s-d75", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d82", "title": "Media source · s-d82", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d85", "title": "Other source · s-d85", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d86", "title": "Company statement source · s-d86", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d87", "title": "Other source · s-d87", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d88", "title": "Other source · s-d88", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d89", "title": "Media source · s-d89", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d90", "title": "Media source · s-d90", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d120", "title": "Other source · s-d120", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d123", "title": "Other source · s-d123", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d124", "title": "Other source · s-d124", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d127", "title": "Regulatory record source · s-d127", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d129", "title": "Media source · s-d129", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d130", "title": "Company statement concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "Ukraine issuer disclosure system", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.smida.gov.ua/db/feed/showform/vlasn_tpr/150797" }, { "id": "s-d131", "title": "Other source · s-d131", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d133", "title": "Other source · s-d133", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d134", "title": "Other source · s-d134", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d135", "title": "Company statement source · s-d135", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d136", "title": "Other source · s-d136", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d137", "title": "Other source · s-d137", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d138", "title": "Other source · s-d138", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d139", "title": "Other source · s-d139", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d140", "title": "Other source · s-d140", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d141", "title": "Other source · s-d141", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d142", "title": "Other source · s-d142", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d143", "title": "Other source · s-d143", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d145", "title": "Other source · s-d145", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d147", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/13176974/persons-with-significant-control" }, { "id": "s-d151", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/13176974/officers" }, { "id": "s-d152", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/officers/JZYPvaTMAQMPV0PD4NXBvYyVNzM/appointments" }, { "id": "s-d156", "title": "Media source · s-d156", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d170", "title": "Other source · s-d170", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d172", "title": "Other source · s-d172", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d176", "title": "Other source · s-d176", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d177", "title": "Other source · s-d177", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d178", "title": "Other source · s-d178", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d180", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/13176974/filing-history" }, { "id": "s-d181", "title": "Company statement concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/13176974/filing-history/MzUyMDExNjE2MGFkaXF6a2N4/document?format=pdf&download=0" }, { "id": "s-d183", "title": "Media source · s-d183", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d187", "title": "Other source · s-d187", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d188", "title": "Other source · s-d188", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d190", "title": "Other source · s-d190", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d193", "title": "Other source · s-d193", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d194", "title": "Other source · s-d194", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d195", "title": "Other source · s-d195", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d196", "title": "Other source · s-d196", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d199", "title": "Other source · s-d199", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d200", "title": "Other source · s-d200", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d201", "title": "Other source · s-d201", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d202", "title": "Company statement source · s-d202", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d203", "title": "Media source · s-d203", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d204", "title": "Media source · s-d204", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d206", "title": "Other source · s-d206", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d228", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/05175077/persons-with-significant-control" }, { "id": "s-d229", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/05175077/officers" }, { "id": "s-d230", "title": "Other source · s-d230", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d231", "title": "Other source · s-d231", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d232", "title": "Other source · s-d232", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d235", "title": "Other source · s-d235", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d242", "title": "Other source · s-d242", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d243", "title": "Other source · s-d243", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d244", "title": "Other source · s-d244", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d245", "title": "Other source · s-d245", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d246", "title": "Other source · s-d246", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d247", "title": "Court record source · s-d247", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d248", "title": "Other source · s-d248", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d249", "title": "Other source · s-d249", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d251", "title": "Company statement source · s-d251", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d261", "title": "Other source · s-d261", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d262", "title": "Other source · s-d262", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d263", "title": "Other source · s-d263", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d264", "title": "Court record source · s-d264", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d265", "title": "Other source · s-d265", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d280", "title": "Other source · s-d280", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d281", "title": "Other source · s-d281", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d282", "title": "Other source · s-d282", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d283", "title": "Other source · s-d283", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d284", "title": "Other source · s-d284", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d285", "title": "Other source · s-d285", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d289", "title": "Other source · s-d289", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d290", "title": "Media source · s-d290", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d292", "title": "Other source · s-d292", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d293", "title": "Other source · s-d293", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d294", "title": "Other source · s-d294", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d297", "title": "Media source · s-d297", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d298", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "Estonian e-Business Register", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://ariregister.rik.ee/est/company/11080094" }, { "id": "s-d299", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "UK Companies House", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/04764608/persons-with-significant-control" }, { "id": "s-d300", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "Estonian e-Business Register", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://ariregister.rik.ee/est/company/12489928" }, { "id": "s-d301", "title": "Media source · s-d301", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d302", "title": "Media source · s-d302", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d307", "title": "Court record source · s-d307", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d308", "title": "Court record source · s-d308", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d309", "title": "Other source · s-d309", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d311", "title": "Other source · s-d311", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d340", "title": "Court record source · s-d340", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d341", "title": "Media source · s-d341", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d343", "title": "Court record source · s-d343", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d344", "title": "Court record source · s-d344", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d346", "title": "Other source · s-d346", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d349", "title": "Other source · s-d349", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d350", "title": "Corporate registry concerning OW Capital or the identified participant", "publisher": "Swiss UID Register", "date": "", "locator": "Retained original sections referenced in private witnesses", "basis": "Retained original passages; directory summaries, allegations, management statements and entered orders have distinct evidentiary scope.", "source_type": "corporate_registry", "publisher_type": "government", "url": "https://www.uid.admin.ch/Detail.aspx?uid_id=CHE-380.001.522" }, { "id": "s-d353", "title": "Other source · s-d353", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d354", "title": "Other source · s-d354", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d355", "title": "Other source · s-d355", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d356", "title": "Media source · s-d356", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d357", "title": "Media source · s-d357", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d358", "title": "Other source · s-d358", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d360", "title": "Other source · s-d360", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d362", "title": "Other source · s-d362", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d363", "title": "Other source · s-d363", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d365", "title": "Other source · s-d365", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d366", "title": "Other source · s-d366", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d381", "title": "Other source · s-d381", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d382", "title": "Other source · s-d382", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d383", "title": "Other source · s-d383", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d385", "title": "Other source · s-d385", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d387", "title": "Other source · s-d387", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d388", "title": "Regulatory record source · s-d388", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "regulatory_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d389", "title": "Other source · s-d389", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d392", "title": "Other source · s-d392", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d396", "title": "Other source · s-d396", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d397", "title": "Other source · s-d397", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d399", "title": "Media source · s-d399", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d400", "title": "Company statement source · s-d400", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d402", "title": "Company statement source · s-d402", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d403", "title": "Company statement source · s-d403", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d404", "title": "Company statement source · s-d404", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d406", "title": "Company statement source · s-d406", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d407", "title": "Company statement source · s-d407", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d408", "title": "Other source · s-d408", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d409", "title": "Company statement source · s-d409", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "company_statement", "publisher_type": "corporate", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d434", "title": "Other source · s-d434", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d435", "title": "Media source · s-d435", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "media", "publisher_type": "media", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d439", "title": "Other source · s-d439", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d440", "title": "Other source · s-d440", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d441", "title": "Other source · s-d441", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d443", "title": "Other source · s-d443", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d444", "title": "Other source · s-d444", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d445", "title": "Other source · s-d445", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d446", "title": "Other source · s-d446", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d452", "title": "Other source · s-d452", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d453", "title": "Other source · s-d453", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d456", "title": "Other source · s-d456", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d461", "title": "Other source · s-d461", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d474", "title": "Other source · s-d474", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d477", "title": "Other source · s-d477", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d478", "title": "Other source · s-d478", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d480", "title": "Other source · s-d480", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d487", "title": "Other source · s-d487", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d488", "title": "Other source · s-d488", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d489", "title": "Other source · s-d489", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d490", "title": "Other source · s-d490", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d491", "title": "Court record source · s-d491", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "court_record", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" }, { "id": "s-d508", "title": "Other source · s-d508", "publisher": "", "date": "", "locator": "", "basis": "Source classification retained; identifying metadata omitted.", "source_type": "other", "publisher_type": "unknown", "url": "" } ], "atlas": { "version": "1.0", "reference": "dudil-report-assembler/2.19.0", "default_view": "target_overview", "hypotheses_default": true, "path_policy": "evidence_first", "context_entity_ids": [ "e1", "e5", "e3", "e16", "e25", "e26", "e23", "e9", "e17" ] }, "case_id": "ow-capital", "version": "2026-10-15-reader1", "as_of": "2026-10-10" }