--- title: "Other court cases, the 2017 Chinese charges and unresolved records" language: en canonical: https://dossiertwist.com/dossiers/trafigura/disputes/ as_of: 2026-10-16 keywords: ["Trafigura Pte Ltd","Trafigura Group Pte. Ltd.","Trafigura Beheer B.V.","Farringford Foundation","Trafigura Control Holdings","TPTE Holding Limited","Swiss Angola bribery case","SK.2023.49","Sonangol Distribuidora","Petrobras","Foreign Corrupt Practices Act","CFTC","Mongolia","Lex Oil","nickel fraud","Prateek Gupta","Myra Falls","Breakwater Resources","Volare Shipping","Trafigura Nat Gas"] --- # Other court cases, the 2017 Chinese charges and unresolved records **Question.** In which other proceedings and reports does Trafigura Pte Ltd appear, and what is unresolved? **Answer.** Trafigura Pte Ltd has been both claimant and defendant in commercial cases in Singapore and England: a margin dispute with United Petroleum Trading, a cargo-damage claim against TKK Shipping, a gasoline sale to El Soobat in Sudan and a restitution claim by Rasmala that the courts dismissed. A news agency reported in 2017 that Chinese prosecutors had charged a 'Trafigura (Singapore) Pte Ltd' and frozen TPTE funds; the outcome is not in the record. A North Korea dataset record and an offshore-records node bearing the company's name carry no identifier and remain unresolved. ## Commercial litigation - Analysis: In Singapore High Court Suit No 1055 of 2019, United Petroleum Trading Limited sought to recover three sums from Trafigura Pte Ltd, US$4.4m, US$1.38m and US$2.5m, which it said had been paid as initial margin under an agreement for Trafigura to trade gasoline futures for it; Trafigura denied that agreement and said the money was owed to it under a different one. On 23 September 2021 the Appellate Division ([2021] SGHC(A) 13) dismissed United Petroleum's appeal, holding the first two claims clearly time-barred and awarding TPTE costs of $30,000; the US$2.5m claim was going to trial, and its result is not in the record. [src-019] [src-006] - Analysis: In Trafigura Pte Ltd v TKK Shipping Pte Ltd ([2023] EWHC 26 (Comm), 13 January 2023), TPTE, owner of a cargo of zinc calcine on the Thorco Lineage, which grounded in French Polynesia in June 2018 on a voyage from the United States to Australia, claimed for its liability to the salvors (USD 7,355,000) and on-shipment costs; the court held that the carrier's Hague-Visby limit is calculated on the weight of the whole cargo, not only the damaged part. On 4 July 2025 the English Commercial Court ([2025] EWHC 1684 (Comm)) gave TPTE summary judgment against El Soobat Energy Co Ltd, a petrochemical company registered in Sudan, on a 2021 claim under a contract for 40,000 tonnes of gasoline to be delivered in February 2020; the sum claimed was revised to USD 2,118,534.49, and El Soobat did not take part in the hearing. [src-071] [src-101] [src-091] - Analysis: Rasmala Trade Finance Fund paid TPTE five sums totalling over US$22.6 million between August 2017 and March 2018, believing it was financing coal supplies by Trafigura to the coal trader Farlin Energy & Commodities FZE; Farlin had defrauded Rasmala and the supposed contracts were not valid, and Rasmala sued Trafigura for restitution. Farlin had been a Trafigura customer since September 2015, with an open credit limit of about $2 million in 2016 raised to $11 million in December 2016, and by mid-2017 was struggling to stay within it. Trafigura relied on a change of position: having treated the payments as valid and applied them to Farlin's debts, it extended more credit and supplied Farlin with coal worth almost $60 million. Mr Justice Rajah dismissed the claim on 23 June 2025, and on 7 October 2026 the Court of Appeal ([2026] EWCA Civ 1259) unanimously dismissed Rasmala's appeal. [src-092] - Analysis: In the Singapore High Court's 2024 decision on the schemes of arrangement proposed by the liquidators of Hin Leong Trading (Pte) Ltd, a fuel wholesaler in compulsory liquidation, TPTE is listed among named non-parties with several banks; under the scheme US$80 million was to be shared among scheme creditors, who would recover about 1.7% of their admitted claims. The judgment does not state the nature or size of any TPTE claim against Hin Leong. [src-055] [src-006] [src-039] - Documented: Hin Leong Trading (Pte.) Ltd. (UEN 197301412M) is a Singapore fuel wholesaler registered on 25 July 1973 that is in compulsory liquidation. [src-039] - Qualification: Aggregator presentation of the ACRA record. ## The 2017 Chinese charges - Analysis: A news agency reported in August 2017, citing an indictment it had reviewed, that prosecutors in Langfang, Hebei province, had on 4 August charged 'Trafigura (Singapore) Pte Ltd' and a Beijing-based oil marketer working for it with fraudulently obtaining bank credit through fabricated gasoline deals with Qingdao United Energy, which said it had lost $32 million; the Singapore entity was charged as Qingdao's counterparty. Trafigura declined to comment, while senior sources said it regarded the dispute as commercial; the employee also declined to comment. The name reported does not match TPTE's registered name and no registration number is given, and a registry aggregator attaches the report to the page of Trafigura Control Holdings, formerly Trafigura (Singapore) Trading Pte. Ltd., by automated matching. The agency added that Chinese authorities had frozen $32.9 million that Trafigura Pte Ltd had put into a metals project in south-western China jointly owned with Jinchuan Group, a main client of the group's metals business. Neither the outcome of the prosecution nor the fate of the frozen funds is in the record. [src-076] [src-100] [src-027] ## The North Korea cargo and the dataset record - Analysis: A financial news service reported in January 2018 that South Korea's foreign ministry had said Trafigura Group owned the cargo of the tanker Lighthouse Winmore, suspected of transferring oil to a North Korean vessel in breach of UN sanctions, and that it was investigating whether the company ordered the transfer. Trafigura denied any involvement: it said it neither owned nor chartered the ship and had sold the cargo to Hong Kong-based Global Commodities Consultants Ltd., which said it resold it to Oceanic Enterprise Ltd.; both said their contracts required any resale to comply with sanctions. The ministry's statement and any outcome are not in the record. [src-089] - Analysis: A record from a research institute's North Korea dataset, republished by a sanctions-data aggregator, describes 'Trafigura Pte. Ltd.' as shipper of refined petroleum transferred to North Korea by the Lighthouse Winmore and Billions No. 18, with an address in Geneva and no registration number or sanctions designation. It cannot be tied to TPTE by an identifier, conflicts in part with the company's account of the cargo sale and is not a sanctions listing. At the time of the research, the aggregator's screening returned no sanctions or politically-exposed-person topics for Trafigura Group; that is a screening result, not a full sanctions review. [src-088] [src-005] ## An unresolved name match - Analysis: In a journalists' offshore-records database (leaked records of an offshore law firm, data to 2014), a node named 'Trafigura Pte. Ltd', with an address at 1 Marina Boulevard, Singapore, is listed as shareholder of Damlos Investments Limited (British Virgin Islands, 2011) and Napoil Limited (Bermuda, 1992). The node has no identifier tying it to TPTE, and the database's publisher states that inclusion in it does not suggest wrongdoing. [src-083] ## Sources - [src-019] United Petroleum Trading Ltd v Trafigura Pte Ltd [2021] SGHC(A) 13, Appellate Division of the High Court of Singapore, 2021-09-23 - [src-006] Corporate registry source · src-006 - [src-071] Court record source · src-071 - [src-101] Other source · src-101 - [src-091] Trafigura Pte Ltd v El Soobat Energy Co Ltd [2025] EWHC 1684 (Comm), High Court of Justice, Commercial Court (England and Wales), 2025-07-04 - [src-092] Rasmala Trade Finance Fund v Trafigura Pte Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1259, Court of Appeal (Civil Division), England and Wales, 2026-10-07 - [src-055] Re Hin Leong Trading (Pte) Ltd (in liquidation) [2024] SGHC 256, General Division of the High Court of Singapore, 2024 - [src-039] Corporate registry source · src-039 - [src-076] Media source · src-076 - [src-100] Corporate registry source · src-100 - [src-027] Company statement source · src-027 - [src-089] Media source · src-089 - [src-088] Sanctions list source · src-088 - [src-005] Sanctions list source · src-005 - [src-083] Corporate registry source · src-083